Exposure
By Candlelight Gothic horror 12 min
Before you go in
- The death of a child, and post-mortem photography
- Fear of premature burial, including of a child
- A coffin is opened
The dead are the best sitters in London, Mr Pruett used to say, because they are the only ones who can hold still for a full minute.
He said it to me on my first morning at the studio, and I laughed, because I was seventeen and wanted him to like me. He did not mean it cruelly. It was a plain fact of the trade. A living sitter in a good light needs twenty seconds with the lens open, and in twenty seconds a living person blinks, breathes, shifts on the chair, and the plate takes all of it: a softness at the eyes, a grey smear where a hand was restless. The dead give you nothing to smear. By the spring of 1862, with the Prince four months in his grave, half of London wanted a portrait in black, and a good share of them wanted it of someone who could not come to the studio.
Mr Pruett had photographed my sister Kitty two years before, on the bed in our front room in Somers Town, the day after the scarlet fever took her. She was six. He charged us nothing. A month later he offered me a place as his assistant at eight shillings a week, and my mother said it was the kindest thing anyone had ever done for the Hales, and she said it often enough that I believed it.
The Marchant sitting was on a Tuesday in April.
Canonbury, a tall house with a fanlight and straw laid in the street to muffle the carts. We came up with the camera and the stand on the barrow and the dark tent folded on top, and the maid showed us into the back parlour, where the curtains had been taken down entirely to let in the light.
Alice Marchant was nine. She lay on the sofa in a white dress with her hands crossed at the waist and a sprig of box in them. Her mother sat at her head. Her father stood at the window and did not look at any of us.
I set up the tent in the scullery. For those who have not seen it done: you pour the collodion onto the glass, tilt it to cover, dip the plate in the silver bath until it goes creamy, and carry it to the camera wet in its holder. You have perhaps ten minutes before it dries and is spoiled. So you are always hurrying, and the silver gets on your fingers and turns them black, and you smell of ether for the rest of the day.
Mr Pruett took the cap off the lens and held it in one hand and his watch in the other, and counted. Thirty-five seconds. Then a second plate, forty-five, because Mrs Marchant wished one with the light a little further round.
I developed them both in the scullery by the yellow window of the tent. The first came up clean. The girl’s face, the white dress, the box sprig, the mother’s hand resting on the cushion, blurred a little, as the living always are.
The second came up and I held it to the yellow light and did not understand it.
Her right hand was doubled. There was the hand crossed over the left, sharp, as in the first plate, and above it, fainter, a second hand, the fingers lifted perhaps a quarter of an inch from the first, as if for part of the forty-five seconds they had risen and then settled back.
I looked at it until the developer began to stain. Then I fixed it, and washed it, and took it out to Mr Pruett.
“The holder slipped,” he said.
We were back at the studio on the Pentonville Road, in the glasshouse on the roof, with the plate on the retouching desk and the light coming through it.
“Only the hand is doubled,” I said. “If the holder slipped, everything would be.”
“Then the body settled.” He did not look up from his varnishing. “They settle, Walter. The muscles let go in their own time. A hand lifts a hair’s breadth and falls again. I’ve seen a jaw drop open in the middle of an exposure. I’ve seen a whole head roll on the pillow.”
“And the mother?”
“The mother is alive. She moves. Look at her.”
I did not tell him that I had already looked at the mother, and at the girl’s face, with a glass. That along the lower edge of each eyelid there was the same faint doubling, a thin dark line where the lid was, and a paler one below it, as if for part of the exposure the eyes had been a little open.
He wrote the sitting into the day-book that evening in his round clerk’s hand, the way he wrote them all.
Marchant, Alice, aged 9. Canonbury Square. Two plates, half-plate. 35 sec, 45 sec. Delivered prints Thursday. One guinea.
I read it over his shoulder. I had never paid attention to the seconds before. I turned back through the book that night after he had gone down, and I saw what I had not noticed in two years of carrying his barrow. For the living he gave twenty seconds, twenty-five on a dull day. For the dead he never gave less than thirty-five. Often fifty. Once, for an old man in Clerkenwell, ninety.
The dead don’t mind, he said, when I asked him the next morning. You give them the long exposure because you can, and the plate is richer for it.
The negatives are kept in the cellar under the shop, in grooved boxes, one for each month, so that a family can have more prints made years later. I went down with a candle on the Wednesday night and began with January.
I will not pretend I was careful. I took the plates out one at a time and held them to the flame, looking only at the dead. Most were clean. The old man in Clerkenwell was clean, ninety seconds and not a hair of him moved. A baby in a christening gown, clean. A young woman in Islington, laid out on her own bed, clean.
Then a boy of about twelve, February, Holloway, forty seconds. The fingers of his left hand doubled on the counterpane.
Then a girl in March, fifty seconds, with a faint second line along her lips, as if her mouth had parted.
I went through every box back to the summer before. I found five. Each was the dead only. None of the living in the frames had the same mark. The living blurred all over, as the living do; these five were sharp everywhere except in one small place, a hand, a mouth, an eyelid, where something had moved and gone back.
I told myself Mr Pruett was right. Bodies settle. I had seen my own sister’s jaw fall open on the second day, and my mother tie it with a strip of linen. I told myself that five in a year was not many, when we took forty dead.
Then I noticed that the boxes for 1860 and 1861 were short. Each month had a few empty grooves. The plates for those sittings were not there.
He kept them in his own room at the back of the shop, in a japanned deed box on the shelf above the washstand, which I had dusted a hundred times without lifting the lid. On the lid, on a paper label, in the round clerk’s hand: Not for reprinting.
I opened it on the Thursday, when he had gone out to deliver the Marchant prints.
There were perhaps thirty plates inside, each wrapped in tissue, each with a slip of paper tucked into the wrapping. A name, an age, a date. And under the date, a cemetery. Highgate. Kensal Green. Nunhead. Abney Park. St Pancras and Islington.
I unwrapped them one by one and held them to the window. Every one was doubled somewhere. A hand. A mouth. On one, a young man’s eyes, wide open for part of the exposure and shut again by the end of it, so that he looked out of the plate with two faces laid over one another, the sleeping one and the other.
The seventh slip said: Hale, Catherine, aged 6. Somers Town. St Pancras and Islington.
I knew the plate before I unwrapped it. I had seen the print every evening of my life for two years. Kitty on the bed, her hair on the pillow, my mother’s hand on the coverlet at the edge of the frame. And her own hand, the left, lying on the coverlet, and above it, faint, grey as breath on a window, a second hand, the fingers lifted and reaching a little way toward the edge of the frame, toward my mother.
I was sitting on his bed with it in my lap when he came in.
He did not ask what I was doing. He took his hat off and put it on the washstand and stood there.
“You saw it,” I said. “In ours. You saw it that day.”
“I saw it in the scullery,” he said. “Same as you saw the Marchant girl. I had perhaps five minutes with it before your mother came in to ask if it had come out.”
“And you said nothing.”
“I said it had come out beautifully.” He sat down on the chair by the door, heavily. “Walter, in fifty-eight I told a family. A man in Pimlico, his wife on the plate, her mouth open for twenty seconds and shut again. I went to him with the plate the night before the funeral and I told him what I thought it meant.”
“What did he do?”
“He had his man throw me down his front steps. Then he wrote to every undertaker between Pimlico and the City to say that Josiah Pruett frightened the bereaved with lies to sell them extra plates. For a year I had no dead to take. I had a wife then.” He looked at the box. “They never opened the coffin. I asked. So I don’t know, and neither does he, and neither will you. Bodies settle. You know that. I told you that.”
“Then why do you keep them?”
He did not answer that for some time.
“Your mother had buried one already that year,” he said at last. “The boy, before Kitty. You remember. What was I to say to her? That the plate had caught something? That she ought to go to St Pancras with a spade?” He rubbed his face. “I gave you work. It was the only thing I could think of to give.”
The kindest thing anyone ever did for the Hales.
“The Marchants bury her tomorrow,” I said. “Highgate. Eleven o’clock.”
“I know when they bury her. I delivered the prints.”
“The lid won’t be screwed down until the morning.”
“Walter.”
“You can dismiss me,” I said. “I’ll take the plates myself.”
He looked at me for a long moment, and then he got up and took Kitty’s plate out of my hands, gently, and wrapped it again in its tissue, and put it back in the box.
“Take the proper ones,” he said. “Both of them. The first as well, so they can see the difference.”
Mr Marchant came down to the door himself in his shirtsleeves. He knew me. He saw the plate box under my arm and his face went quite white.
“Get away from this house.”
“Sir, if you’d only look.”
“I have looked. My wife has the prints on her dressing table.”
“Not at the prints. The prints are retouched. At the glass.”
He began to close the door, and a voice on the stairs behind him said, “Edward.”
Mrs Marchant came down in a wrapper with a candle. She did not look at me. She looked at the box. She said, “Show me,” and her husband said her name again, and she said, “Show me,” in exactly the same voice, and he stood aside.
I held the two plates to the gas bracket in the hall, one and then the other, and showed her the hand. I showed her the eyelids with the glass. She looked for a long time. Her husband would not look at all.
“Where is she?” I said.
She took me into the front parlour. The coffin was on trestles under the window, with candles at either end, and the lid was on but not screwed. Mrs Marchant set her own candle down and put her hands on the lid and waited, and after a moment her husband came in and put his hands beside hers, and they lifted it together and set it against the wall.
Alice lay as they had laid her. The white dress. The hands crossed at the waist on the sprig of box, the right over the left. Pennies on her eyes, to keep the lids down, as is done.
One was on her left eye. The other had slipped and lay on the pillow beside her cheek. Beneath where it had been, the lid was not quite closed. There was a line of white under it.
Nobody said anything. I did not know what I had expected. I had expected something I would know when I saw it. I had not expected something that could be either.
Mrs Marchant reached into the coffin. She laid her fingertips on her daughter’s cheek, and I saw her feel the cold of it and not flinch. Then with her thumb she drew the eyelid down, very gently, and picked up the penny from the pillow and put it back where it belonged.
“She always slept with them a little open,” she said. “Ever since she was a baby. Edward used to say she was keeping watch for him to come home.”
Mr Marchant made a sound and went out of the room.
She put the lid back herself. It was heavy and she would not let me help. Then she took the plates out of my hands and looked at them once more by the candle, and gave them back.
“Thank you,” she said. “You may go.”
Alice Marchant was buried at Highgate at eleven the next morning. I was not there. Mr Pruett did not dismiss me, which I had not expected either. He took the second Marchant plate from me in the glasshouse, wrapped it in tissue, wrote a slip for it, Highgate, and put it in the japanned box with the others. That is his kind of honesty. I have come to think it is the only kind the trade allows.
I went home that evening to Somers Town, and my mother had the kettle on, and after supper she took the duster to the mantelpiece as she always does, and lifted Kitty’s portrait in its black frame, and wiped the glass.
I looked at it over her shoulder. I had never looked at the print closely, only at the girl in it. It is there in the print, too. You have to know it is there. A paleness above the hand on the coverlet, grey as breath on a window, reaching a little toward the edge of the frame where my mother’s hand rests.
“She looks as if she’s about to wake up,” my mother said, and set it down, and straightened it.
She has said it most evenings for two years, and I always heard it as grief. I have not told her. I do not think I ever will. But I cannot hear it that way any longer. When she says it now, I hear it the way Mr Pruett must have heard it, standing in our front room that first day with the lens cap in one hand and his watch in the other: as the plain description of a photograph.