The Tuner
By Candlelight Historical horror 16 min
Before you go in
- Being locked in a building overnight
- Fear of losing hearing and voice
Pieter rang for wind at a quarter past ten, and the wind came before the bell had stopped swinging.
He sat back on the bench and listened to it arrive. The bellows in the loft behind the organ filled and the wind went down the trunks into the chests with the long soft sigh it always made, a sound like a big animal settling, and then the case was full of it, three manuals and the pedal holding their breath above him in the dark.
Joost never managed that. Joost Verbeek had been the city’s bellows-treader for twenty years and he was fat and slow and wheezed on the ladder, and when Pieter pulled the knob marked Calcant, which rang the little bell up in the loft, it was usually a count of thirty before the first bellows rose. And Joost’s wind shook. You could see it in the wind gauge screwed beside the music desk, a bent glass tube with water in it, the one Master Müller had brought from Germany. When Joost trod, the water jumped and settled and jumped, a step behind every step.
The water stood in the glass now as if it had been painted there.
“Joost?” Pieter called up.
The answer came down from the dark at the back of the case, unhurried.
“Joost is at home.”
Not Joost’s voice. Lower, and with no Haarlem in it, and no Amsterdam either. Pieter waited for more and got none.
“He sent you?”
“He did.”
There was no reason to mind. The city paid for wind and somebody was giving it, and the koster had locked the great west door behind Pieter at ten and would not come back with the key until five, so whoever was up there was locked in with him and would have to tread till morning like it or not. Pieter turned the candle on the music desk so that it lit the stop knobs on the left, and drew the Octaaf of the Hoofdwerk, and began.
The organ was nearly finished. It had taken three years and most of the tin in Holland, people said, and it was the largest in the world, people also said, which Pieter had stopped correcting because it might be true. Sixty stops. Five thousand pipes. A front of burnished tin climbing to the vaults, the biggest pipes of the pedal standing in their towers like the masts of a ship, and around them Jan van Logteren’s carving, angels and garlands and two lions holding up the city’s arms. In September the city’s examiners would come and play it for a week and either sign for it or not, and Master Müller would be paid or not. The master was in Amsterdam until Saturday arguing with the tin merchant. He had left Pieter the temperament.
That was the trust of it. You could build an organ in a workshop, but you had to tune it in the room it would sing in, and the first thing tuned, the thing every other pipe would be tuned against, was the temperament. Twelve notes laid on one four-foot stop by ear, the bones of the whole instrument. Pieter was twenty. He had been with the master six years. He had never been given the bones before.
He tuned the way the master had taught him, the old Dutch way the city’s organists wanted. Middle C first, from the master’s pitch pipe. Then E above it, pure, a major third so sweet it had no shiver in it at all. Then the fifths in between, C to G, G to D, D to A, A to E, each one shaved a little narrow, not pure, never pure, until the four of them together landed on the same E the pure third had already given him. It was the ear doing sums. When the sum came out, the third rang still and clean, and the narrow fifths beat slowly against each other like four men breathing in a room.
The sums never came out entirely. That was the first thing the master had taught him, and the thing he believed most deeply about his trade. If you tuned every fifth pure and went round all twelve, you did not come back to the note you started from. You overshot it by a sliver. There was always something left over. Every temperament was a way of deciding where to put it.
The old Dutch way put all of it in one place, between G sharp and E flat. The fifth there came out so wide it howled, and organists called it the wolf and never played it, and so nobody heard it. The master had a German book in his chest, by a man named Werckmeister, which said that the numbers of music were God’s numbers and the sliver was what was left when fallen men tried to count them. Pieter thought of it more plainly. It was a sum that would not balance. A tuner was a clerk who hid the difference in a drawer nobody opened.
He laid the bones in two hours. Then he drew the Prestant, the eight-foot, the big principal whose largest pipes stood in the front for the city to admire, and began to tune it to the Octaaf, note by note, up from the bottom.
At G sharp he stopped.
He played it again with the E below. A G sharp tuned the Dutch way sits a pure third above E. Together they should have been still as water.
They snarled. The two notes ground against each other so fast and rough it set his teeth on edge, a sound like a saw stuck in wet wood.
He took his hand off the E and put it on the C above instead.
Pure. Clean and sweet and utterly still, a perfect third, the C and the pipe together like two hands folded.
Pieter sat with his fingers on the keys and the candle guttering and understood what he was hearing, and did not want to.
A G sharp is a third above E. An A flat is a third below C. On a harpsichord, on a lute, on any organ in Holland tuned the old way, they are the same black key, and they are not the same note. They are a sliver apart, the same kind of sliver as the one in the drawer. The organ had a key for G sharp. It had no key for A flat. There was no A flat anywhere in it.
The pipe was sounding A flat.
He told himself the obvious thing first. Somebody had put a pipe in the wrong hole.
He took the candle and climbed the ladder inside the case onto the walkboard behind the front pipes, where the air was cold and smelled of tin and wood glue, and found the G sharp of the Prestant by counting from the end. It stood where it should. On its foot, scratched into the metal with an awl, was the master’s mark for the note, gis, in the master’s own hand.
But it was not one of the new pipes. The metal was darker, the solder older and lumpier, and round the top a collar had been soldered on to lengthen it. Pieter remembered then. The master had kept pipes from five of the old stops when the old organ came out, because good metal was dear and old pipes sang sweeter, and his men had cut and collared them to fit. Below the gis there was an older mark, half rubbed away, scratched by some tuner a hundred years dead.
He held the candle close. It said as.
A flat.
So that was the explanation, and he held on to it. An old pipe, made once for some other organ as an A flat, cut down and collared to be a G sharp. Perhaps the collar was loose. Perhaps the old pipe remembered what it was made for, the way an old floorboard creaks where it was bent.
Then he took his brass rule from his coat and measured it against the master’s scale stick, where the length of every pipe in the Prestant was marked. Mouth to top. Twice, three times.
Exactly the length of a G sharp. To the line.
He took the tuning cone, a brass thing like a funnel with a point at one end and a cup at the other, and set the point in the pipe’s open top and pressed, to flare it and pull the note up into place. He felt the metal give. Before he climbed he had wedged the key down at the console with a slip of wood, the way a tuner alone always does, so the pipe was sounding all the while. The note rose. He heard it slide up to G sharp and sit there, true.
He lifted the cone away. The note slid down again, slowly, like a held breath being let out, and settled on A flat.
A pipe cannot do that. Its note is its length, and its length was G sharp. Pieter stood on the walkboard in the dark with the cone in his hand and knew two things that could not both be true, and both were.
The pipe was exactly as long as a G sharp. It was sounding a note the organ had no key for.
He went through the rest of the reasons the way the master had taught him to go through a fault, from the cheapest end.
Pipes on the same chest can pull each other. Two pipes close in pitch and standing close together will sometimes drag into one note, the way two clocks on one wall will come to tick together. He reached out and put his hands over the mouths of the pipes on either side, so that only the one pipe spoke. A flat.
The wind, then. If the wind was too strong, a pipe would sound sharp. He looked down through the gap in the case to the wind gauge on the music desk, lit by the candle. The water stood still. Not a tremor.
“Stop the wind,” he called.
Above and behind him the bellows sank. He heard it go, all of it, a long exhalation through the wooden trunks that went on longer than it should, and the organ went slack and empty around him. He stood in it. There was no sound in the church but his own heart.
“Give me wind.”
It came at once, and the wedged key sang again. A flat.
He listened then, properly, to the bellows. Joost trod them like a man climbing stairs, a thump and a creak and a gasp of air, uneven, always one board behind. What Pieter heard now was not that. It was a slow rise and a slow fall, in and out, with a pause at the top, even as a pendulum. It was the sound of something asleep, and breathing.
He climbed down from the case and took the candle up the stair to the bellows loft.
The loft was long and low under the roof and the bellows lay along it in a row, great wedges of oak and leather, each with a treading beam. The treader stood on one of the beams with his back to Pieter, in a hooded cloak the colour of wet slate, and as the beam went slowly down under his weight he stepped without hurry to the next.
“Who are you?” Pieter said.
The hood turned a little. Not enough. The candle showed the edge of the cloth and the dark inside it, and nothing in the dark.
“Wind.”
“Joost cannot write his own name. If he sent anyone he sent his boy, and his boy is eleven.”
“Then I am his boy.” The voice was patient. The man stepped to the next beam. “What are you doing down there?”
“Tuning.”
“What is tuning?”
Pieter almost laughed. “Deciding where the fault goes.”
“And where does it go?”
“Between G sharp and E flat. It’s called the wolf. Nobody plays there.”
The man stepped. The bellows behind him sank, breathing out, and the one under him began to rise.
“Somebody does now,” he said.
Pieter told him to stop. He told him the city had hired Joost and not him, and that he would report this to the koster and to the master, and that he wanted him off the beams. The man went on treading. Pieter went back down the stair, because there was nothing else he could do. The door was locked, and the night was long, and the examiners were coming in September.
At the bench he did what a careful man does with an impossible thing. He made a guess and tested it.
If the drawer was empty, if the sliver that should have been hidden in the wolf had come out of it, then the wolf should be gone. He put his left hand on G sharp and his right on the E flat above and pressed them together, the fifth no organist in Holland would ever play.
It was pure.
He had laid it himself two hours before so that it would howl. It did not howl. It stood in the church as still as the third had, wide and calm and lovely.
So the sliver had gone somewhere. And if he was right, the guess said something worse. It said that every fifth in the organ would now be pure, all twelve of them, and that twelve pure fifths would close the circle. That they would bring him back to the very C he started from, which every book and every string and every tuner since the Greeks knew they could not.
He had the master’s monochord in its case under the bench, a single string on a long box with the proportions marked along the bridge. He took it out and plucked it and moved the bridge, fifth by fifth, and wrote the stops down with a lead in the margin of his tuning book, and the string said what it had always said. Round the twelve, you overshoot. The sum does not come out.
Then he went round the twelve on the organ. C to G. G to D. D to A, and on, up the keyboard and down again an octave when he ran out of keys, every fifth pure, and the twelfth fifth closed. It came home to C. The same C. Not a sliver over.
The string was right. The organ was right. He sat between them with the lead in his hand.
Pieter did not believe in demons. He believed in proportion. He had believed, very simply and since he was a boy, that the order of music was the order of the world, and that the sliver left over was the small humble mark of men not being quite equal to it. Something in a drawer. Something a good clerk tidied away. He looked at the keys and drew every principal on the Hoofdwerk, eight-foot, four-foot, two-foot, the mixture, and he put his hands down on a plain chord of C, because he had to know what a world sounded like when the sum came out.
It was the most beautiful sound he had ever heard.
There was no beating in it anywhere. Every pipe lay against every other pipe like stone on stone in a wall with no mortar, perfectly, and the chord went up into the vaults and filled them and did not grow and did not fade, and he could have wept.
It was a moment before he noticed he could not hear himself breathing.
He could feel his chest move. He could feel the air in his nose. He did not hear it. He put his foot down on the pedalboard, on no note, just on the wood, hard, and felt the jar of it in his shin, and there was no sound of a shoe. He said his own name aloud. He felt his lips and his tongue shape it.
Nothing. The chord, and the vaults, and nothing.
The sum came out. There was no sliver left over. And there was no room in it for anything that was not part of the sum, not a breath, not a shoe, not a voice. Pieter had thought all his life that men were the ones who could not quite count the world. Now, with the sum done properly, he had to wonder whether men were what didn’t fit in it.
He opened his mouth and sang the A, felt it in his throat and his teeth, and heard nothing at all.
He took his hands off the keys. The chord stopped. His breath came back into his ears all at once, ragged and loud, and he heard himself gasp, and he had never in his life been so glad of an ugly sound.
Above and behind him the bellows went on breathing. In, and out, and the pause at the top.
“It wants to be heard on the day,” the treader said.
His voice came down quite clearly through the case. Pieter had heard nothing of himself inside that chord, but he had no doubt he would have heard the treader.
“In September,” the man said. “The whole city under it, singing a psalm. You have never heard a city sing in tune. Nobody has.”
Pieter stood. He looked up into the dark of the case.
“And what happens to the city?”
The bellows rose and fell.
“You can put it back,” the treader said, which was not an answer. “It has to go somewhere. Your master put it in the wolf. You can put it in the wolf too, and keep it there. Every time you tune, all your life. You will always know where it is. You will always hear it waiting.” A step, from beam to beam. “Or you can let them hear it once, all of them, in September.”
He did not say what that would cost the city. He had said what the other would cost Pieter, and Pieter understood that this was the only help he would get.
He thought about the master, and the examiners, and the tin. He thought about the chord, which he would never hear again, and how he would want to, every day, at every keyboard, for the rest of his life. He thought of Haarlem in September, the burgomasters in their pews and the fishwives in the aisles and Joost wheezing up the loft stair, all of them opening their mouths to sing, and none of them hearing their own voices or their neighbours’, only the organ, perfect, closing over them like water.
He climbed the ladder into the case with the cone.
At the G sharp he did not use the point. He turned the cone over and set the cup on the pipe’s open top and leaned on it with all his weight, and felt the soft old tin buckle and fold inward under the brass. A tuner closes a pipe a hair at a time. Pieter crushed it. He bent the top in until the note fell, and fell, and slid down past A flat to G sharp, and he held it there with the cone and his shoulder until the tin set. Then he went down to the bench and played the fifth to E flat.
It howled. The wolf came back into its drawer with a sound like a saw in wet wood, wide and wrong and alive, and all through the case he heard the other fifths fall, each one, back to being slightly narrow, slightly short of true, the four men breathing in a room.
Above him the bellows let out a long breath and stopped.
He heard himself breathing. He heard the cone knock on the tin. He heard his shoes on the walkboard as he went down, and they were the loudest, ugliest, most human sounds he had ever made, and he made as many of them as he could.
The koster found him at five asleep on the bench with the candle burnt out and his tuning book open at a page of sums. Joost had been in bed all night with a fever, his wife said, and had sent nobody, and had no boy.
The master came back on Saturday and found the G sharp of the Prestant crushed at the top like a trodden cup and was angrier than Pieter had ever seen him, and had a new pipe made. Pieter tuned it. He laid the bones again on the Octaaf, and put the sliver in the wolf, and it stayed there.
In September the examiners played for a week and signed. They praised the sweetness of the thirds. On the Sunday the whole city came and sang a psalm under the great organ, out of tune as a city always is, every voice a little sharp or a little flat of its neighbour, and Pieter stood at the back by a pillar and heard every one of them, and under all of them, from the drawer where he had put it, the wolf, waiting.
He tuned organs for forty years after that, in Haarlem and Leiden and Alkmaar and in villages whose names he forgot. He always laid the temperament himself and always the old Dutch way. And before he played a note he rang for wind and sat with his hands in his lap and counted the bellows breathing. If it came uneven, a thump and a creak and a gasp, he tuned. If it ever came even, slow and patient with a pause at the top, the way a sleeper breathes, he did not touch the keys. He sat and waited for morning with his own breath loud in his ears, and he never once climbed the stair to see who was treading.