The Ice Fair
By Candlelight Historical horror 17 min
Before you go in
- Drowning, including the drowning of a boy
- Bodies found under ice
- Guilt over a death, and a lie told to a grieving mother
The ice talked the whole four days of the fair, and nobody minded it but me.
You had the stall next to ours, Mrs. Mallory, so you heard it too. A long low groan under the boards when the tide turned beneath us, like a door in a big house opening a long way off. The watermen said it was the river complaining that it could not get out to sea. The gentlefolk laughed and stamped their feet to make it do it again. You crossed yourself, the first morning, and then you got used to it, as everybody did.
I never did. I had heard it before, and you know now where.
I want to set all of it down in order, because on Friday night, with the lantern in your hand, you asked me how I knew where to cut, and I could not say it to your face. I can write it. Mrs. Rudd always said I set a cleaner page than I speak.
We went down on the Tuesday, the first of February, when the watermen laid planks from Blackfriars stairs and started taking tuppence a head to walk on the river. Mrs. Rudd had the press carried down on a handcart, the little common press from the back of the shop in Water Lane, and we set it up on the ice in a booth of sailcloth and oars about a hundred yards out, on the street the crowd had already started calling the City Road. There were a dozen presses on the ice by noon. Everybody wanted a card that said they had been there.
You know how it went. A gentleman gives his name, I set it in the stick, capitals, and under it the lines we kept standing in the forme: Printed on the Ice, on the River Thames, February 1814. Mrs. Rudd inks, I pull, and the gentleman has a card for his mantelpiece for sixpence. The ink went stiff as tar in the frost, so we kept a brazier under the slab and the whole booth smelled of hot linseed. My fingers split on the type. I did not care. It was the best money the shop had seen since Mr. Rudd died.
You had your gingerbread and your hot codlins on the next pitch, and every morning you asked me the same thing, over the brazier, with your hands round a cup.
“Any word from the regiment, Ned? He’d write to you before his mother.”
And I said what I had said since the end of January. That Kit had talked of the drum all winter, that boys who go for soldiers do not write till they are sent somewhere, and that Spain was a long way. You always nodded. You always said, “Well. He’d want his gingerbread.”
The customer came at dusk on the Tuesday, when the lamps were being lit along the booths.
I did not see him come. He was at the board when I looked up from the case, a tall man in a long dark coat with a hood drawn so far forward that the lamp made nothing inside it. The crowd went round him the way water goes round a pile. Nobody bumped him. Nobody looked.
“A card, if you please,” he said. “One name. You will set it yourself.”
His voice was quiet and very courteous, the way old clergymen talk, and it seemed to come from nearer than the hood.
“Name, sir?”
“Thomas Lugg.”
I set it. He watched me do it, every letter, and when I had pulled it he took the card by its edges and did not look at it. He put a shilling on the board. It was wet. Not damp from the snow: wet, and so cold that it hurt to pick up, and so worn that the king on it was hardly there. A William, from before my grandfather’s time.
The ice groaned under us as he walked away. A long one. Mrs. Rudd said, “Somebody’s a bit flush,” and bit the coin, and swore at the cold of it.
I slept in the booth that night with the press, because Mrs. Rudd would not leave it to the watermen. Some time after three I woke to shouting from the Three Cranes end, and lanterns running.
They had found a man under the ice.
He was lying face up, about a foot down, and the ice over him was as clear as a window, the way it went in patches where the frost had come quick and still. The lanterns made him gold. He had his eyes open and his hands folded on his chest, and between his hands, flat against his coat, was a card. I could read it through the ice. I had set it.
Here is what I told myself, kneeling there with the watermen swearing round me.
A drunk had gone through. There were holes all over the ice where the watermen had cut to get water for the gin and the tea, and men went through them every night of the fair and mostly got hauled out. This one had not been hauled out. He had bought a card at dusk, drunk his money, gone through a hole, and the current had carried him under the clear patch. And the man in the hood was Thomas Lugg, and this was him, and he had looked older under his hood than he was.
That was the best I could do. I wanted it badly.
Then I saw his clothes. Knee breeches, and buckles on his shoes, and his hair tied back in a queue with a black ribbon, the way men wore it when I was a baby. Nobody wore a queue on the ice that week. And there was no hole. The ice over him was a foot thick and whole from the stairs to the middle of the river, without a seam in it.
Old Abel Twine came down the planks with a lantern and looked for a long time. Abel had worked a boat off Three Cranes since before the American war.
“That’s Tom Lugg,” he said. “Went through at Queenhithe, the winter of eighty-nine. Skating. I dragged for him three days.” He wiped his mouth. “Never found him.”
“It can’t be,” someone said.
“Don’t tell me,” Abel said. “I know his face. I drank with him.” He looked down through the ice. “Twenty-five year. He’s not changed a hair.”
They cut him out at first light with axes, and the Humane Society men carried him off to the dead-house at St Bride’s on a ladder. The card was still in his hands. I stood with the crowd and watched, and I could not get warm.
He came back the next afternoon, at the same hour, and put a coin on the board that was wet.
“A card, if you please. One name.”
I said we were closing. Mrs. Rudd said we were not, and pushed me back to the case, and said in my ear that a shilling was a shilling and the river would not wait for us to get rich.
“Ann Prentice,” he said.
I want to be honest about what I thought, because you will not understand the rest otherwise. I thought it was a trick. I had heard of the resurrection men in the Borough, who took bodies out of the burial grounds for the surgeons, and I thought somebody had dug up an old corpse and laid it under the ice to draw a crowd. There was talk all over the fair of the drowned man by Three Cranes; people were coming down the stairs to look at the place. And Mrs. Rudd had taken more on Wednesday morning than in the whole of the Tuesday.
I looked at her, inking, and I thought: she would not. And then I thought: she has a shop to keep and a dead husband’s debts.
So I set Ann Prentice, and I pulled it, and he took it by its edges and went. And that night I did not sleep. I sat up in the booth with the lamp out and watched the ice for anybody carrying a long bundle.
Nobody came. Nobody cut. At four o’clock the ice groaned under the booth, the long groan, and a minute after there was a cry from Queenhithe.
A woman, this time, under clear ice a foot thick with no seam in it. A gown cut high under the bosom, and a cap with lappets, and a card between her hands. An old woman from Bankside came down at dawn, someone having fetched her, and knelt on the ice and put her bare hands flat on it over the face, and said, “That’s my mother. That’s my mother,” over and over. She was not crying. She sounded glad. She said her mother had gone through in the hard winter of ninety-five, fetching water, and they had never had anything to bury.
Nobody digs up a body and lays it under a foot of ice that has no seam. I knew that kneeling there. Nobody had laid anything anywhere. The river was giving them back.
By the Thursday the whole fair knew. They led an elephant across below Blackfriars that morning, and I do not think half the crowd turned to look at it, because they were queuing at our booth.
Mrs. Rudd made a board for it. Names of the drowned, one shilling. They came down the stairs in black: a waterman’s widow from Wapping, a pair of brothers whose father went off a lighter in ninety-eight, a girl who could not have been twelve with a name written out for her on a scrap. I set them all. I pulled them all. Mrs. Rudd took the shillings and did not look at me.
The coroner’s officer came at noon, a stout man in a wet greatcoat, and pushed to the front of the queue with the two cards in a handkerchief. He laid them on our board side by side.
“These are your work, master printer?”
“Mine,” Mrs. Rudd said, before I could. “The boy sets. I own.”
“Two found drowned, two of your cards in their hands.” He looked at me, not at her. “And both dead before you were born, by the look of them, which is not a thing I have had to put in front of a jury before.” He wrapped the cards up again. “Who bought them?”
“A gentleman,” Mrs. Rudd said. “In a hood. Paid in coin.”
“Name?”
“He only ever gives other people’s,” I said, and the officer looked at me a while longer and wrote something in his book. The jury at St Bride’s said found drowned, both times, which was true.
But the watermen had started to look at me too. When I went for water, a man at the hole by the stairs said, loud enough, that the Rudd boy’s press was calling them up, and another said it was a wicked thing to print on the river at all, and spat on the ice by my boot. Abel Twine told them to leave off. Then he took me by the arm and said, low, “Who is he, Ned?”
“I don’t know.”
“Then don’t sell him any more.”
You came over in the afternoon with a bag of gingerbread, and you watched the queue for a while, and then you said, “Ned. Print me one for Kit.”
I could not answer.
“Not like that,” you said, and laughed at my face. “For the regiment. A keepsake, from his mam. ‘Printed on the ice.’ I’ll put it in with my next letter, he’ll show it all round the barracks.”
So I did. You stood there while I set it. C, H, R, I, S. Upside down and backwards in the stick, the way type always is, so that I read your son’s name wrong way round with my own fingers. I pulled it, and you took it and kissed it and put it in your apron, and I went behind the booth and was sick on the ice.
I tried to stop him. I want you to know that. When he came at dusk on the Thursday I was out of the booth before he reached the board, and I followed him instead.
He did not go towards the stairs. He went the other way, out past the last booths, past the swings and the skittle alley and the last tar barrel burning, into the dark part of the river where nobody walked, towards the middle and the old bridge. I kept forty yards behind with my hands in my armpits. I could hear the crowd behind me and the ice groaning ahead. He stopped where the ice was clear and black, and stood looking down at it with his hood bent, the way a man stands at a grave.
Then a lantern swung behind me and made me blink, and he was not there. Only the clear ice, and my own breath, and under the ice, nothing that I could see.
When I got back to the booth Mrs. Rudd had a shilling on the slab, wet, and a name written on the back of a handbill in her own hand. Josiah Crane. He had waited for me, she said. She had offered to set it herself and he had said no. He had said I would.
I set it. If I had not, I think he would have waited all night at the board, and I could not have borne that. He came back for the card within the quarter hour, though I never saw him cross the ice.
That night I sat up again. Nothing came up for any of the names in the queue. Not the widow’s husband, not the brothers’ father, not the girl’s. And nothing came up for Kit.
I sat in the dark and shook with relief, and I worked it out, the way you work out a page that will not lock.
It was not the press, and it was not me. I had printed his name myself, and the river had kept him. It was the man in the hood. Only the names he gave me. Only the cards he took away.
Then, a little after three, the groan, and Josiah Crane came up under the ice not twenty feet from our booth, a young man in a blue coat with brass buttons, and Abel knew him too: off a coal barge, the hard frost of oh-six.
Eighty-nine. Ninety-five. Six. I lay in the booth and counted on my split fingers. They were coming up in order. Every one later than the last. Every one nearer to our press.
I have to tell you now about the night of the twenty-seventh of January. I have been coming to it the whole of this letter, the way you walk round a hole.
The river was not frozen then, not properly. It was choked, floes as big as rooms jammed up against the old bridge, grinding and groaning, with black water between them, and boys went out on them at night for a dare. Kit and I went out from Blackfriars stairs with a lantern. I had a shilling of my wages in my fist, and I said it was his if he walked the floes to the Surrey side. I said it the way you say things at fifteen, so he would have to. He laughed at me and went.
He got a long way. I watched the lantern go out over the ice. Then the ice groaned, the long groan, and the lantern went down, and the light under the water was green for a moment, and then it was not.
I did not go after him. I want you to have that plainly. I stood on the floe at the stairs with the shilling in my hand, and then I dropped the shilling in the river, as if that would undo the dare, and I ran home to Water Lane and was in bed before the watch called four.
In the morning you came to the shop to ask if I had seen him. I said he had talked all winter of going for a soldier. I said there was a sergeant at the Black Lion taking boys. You believed me because you wanted to. So did I.
That is why I was sick behind the booth, Mrs. Mallory. That is why I never could look at you over the brazier.
On the Friday afternoon the man in the hood came to the board and put down a shilling.
It was wet and it was cold and I knew it. I had cut a nick in the rim of that shilling with the case knife on the day Mrs. Rudd paid it to me, so I would know it from the others. The nick was there.
“A card, if you please,” he said. “One name.”
I knew it before he said it.
“Christopher Mallory.”
I said no.
I said it so loud that Mrs. Rudd looked up from the slab, and the people at the board stepped back. The hood did not move.
“Then do not,” he said, in his old clergyman’s voice. “Tomorrow the river goes out. The wind is coming round, I think. What it has not given back by then it keeps.”
“What happens to him?”
“He goes to sea. He is not found.” The hood turned, just a little, towards your stall, where you were wrapping gingerbread for a child and laughing with its mother. “And she goes on writing to the regiment.”
I stood there with the stick in my hand. I want you to know every reason I had, so you can judge them. If I set it, you would have him to bury, as the old woman from Bankside had her mother. And you would know he never went for a soldier, and you would ask why I said he did. And Abel and the watermen, who knew he and I were thick, would ask who was with him on the floes. And Mrs. Rudd would turn me off, and nobody in London would take an apprentice who had let his friend drown for a shilling dare.
If I did not set it, you would go on writing to Spain for the rest of your life, and I would go on telling you that Spain is a long way.
I set it.
C, H, R, I, S, T, O, P, H, E, R. Wrong way round, with my own fingers. I locked the forme. I inked it myself, because Mrs. Rudd would not touch it. And when I laid the card on the tympan and brought the platen down and pulled the bar, the ice groaned under the press. Not under the river. Under us. Right under my feet, so close and so long that the type rattled in the case.
He took the card by its edges and went. He did not take the shilling back. I have it.
You know the rest better than I do, because you were there with the lantern. You know that it was not Abel who shouted, that night. It was me. That I had sat up in the booth until the groan came, at a little after three, and I took the lamp off its hook and went out of the booth, and put it down on the ice in front of the press, and looked.
He was right under us. He had been right under us the whole four days. Under the boards of the booth where I set my cards, a foot down, in his brown jacket, with his eyes open and your card between his hands, the one I set for him, not the one in your apron. Looking up at the place where I had stood.
You came, because I shouted for you and nobody else. And you held the lantern while Abel cut, and you did not make a sound, and when they lifted him out you asked me how I knew where to cut.
That is how.
The thaw came on the Saturday, as he said. The wind went round to the south in the morning and it rained, and by the afternoon the ice was black and soft and the watermen were shouting everybody off. Booths were going in. Mrs. Rudd went for the handcart.
He came one last time while I was alone with the press, in the rain. He put a coin on the board. It was dry.
“A card, if you please. One name.”
“Whose?”
He did not answer, and I knew, and I will not pretend I argued. I set it. E, D, W, A, R, D. My own name, upside down and backwards, in my own stick. I locked it in the forme. I reached for the ink balls.
The ice went with a crack like a gun. The booth tipped, and the press went over and slid away from me down the slope of the floe into the black water, forme and all, and I was on my back with Abel’s hand in my collar dragging me towards the stairs. When I looked round the hood was nowhere, and the press was gone.
It was never pulled. My name went into the river set in lead and locked up tight, the right way round for printing and backwards for reading, and it has never been printed. I do not know if the river needs it to be.
I am sending you the shilling with this. It was his. I owed it to him.
The watermen say the river will freeze again some winter, though Abel says the winters are not what they were. I have taken a room over Blackfriars stairs, on the top floor, where you can hear the water at night. If it ever groans again, I will hear it.