Beset

By Candlelight Psychological thriller 14 min

Psychological thrillers Sea horror

Before you go in
  • Starvation and scurvy aboard an icebound ship
  • Implied cannibalism, never shown
  • Killing of the sick, implied
  • Coercion by a group

Elias Brand took Aaron Kell a cup of water at four bells in the morning watch, and at breakfast the men talked about how well he had been buried.

It was said the way men say things about weather. Mr. Stott had read the psalm very decently. The ice had been kind, for once, and let them cut a proper grave. Somebody had carved the board, and it was a good board, and Kell’s mother would have been glad of it.

Elias sat with his bowl of burgoo cooling between his hands.

“Kell’s in his hammock,” he said.

The mess went on eating. Sandy Liddle, next to him on the bench, put a hand on his shoulder and left it there a moment, as a man might steady a cask on a roll.

“You were in the after hold all day yesterday,” Sandy said. “Setting up shakes. You came up past midnight with your lamp burnt out and your hands like wood. I doubt you knew your own name.”

“I took him water. This morning. Four bells.”

“You took somebody water.”

Elias left the burgoo and went forward, stooping under the beams, past the stove and the steaming line of stockings, to where the sick lay in the dark near the bows. Kell’s hammock was lashed up tight in the netting. The canvas was cold. On the deck below where it had hung there was a tin cup, dry.


The Harmony of Hull had been beset since the eleventh of September, in the middle ice of Baffin Bay, and it was now the last day of November, and there was no sun.

There would be none until February. The men had rigged a canvas housing over the whole of the deck against the wind, and under it the air was brown with lamp smoke and breath. The ship lay nipped between two floes as though in a pair of hands. Some nights the hands tightened, and the timbers made sounds no timber should make, and forty-eight men lay in their hammocks listening to find out whether this was the night they would all walk out onto the ice with whatever they could carry.

Elias kept the stores. It was the cooper’s part on the Harmony, because the cooper knew the casks, and the owners paid on his tally when she came home. He wrote it every evening at the cabin table in pencil, because ink froze.

30th November. Bread, 31 bags. Beef, 9 tierces. Pork, 7 tierces. Flour, 4 barrels. Oatmeal, 2. Molasses, 1 cask, part used. Coal, perhaps 6 tons. Lime juice, none. Allowance, two-thirds, drawn for 47.

He looked at the last figure for a long time before he wrote it.


The grave was two hundred yards off the starboard bow, where a pressure ridge had thrown up blocks of old blue ice. Elias went out to it with a lantern at what passed for noon, when the sky to the south turned the colour of a bruise for an hour and then gave up.

The path out was trodden flat by many boots. The grave was a proper grave, or as proper as the ice allowed: a long cairn of cut blocks, packed with snow, and at its head a board from a broken bread cask with the letters cut in deep and square.

A. KELL. 1836.

Elias crouched and put his mitten on the board. He had not been here. He was sure he had not been here. And yet the path was there, and the cairn, and he could see how it would have been, the men standing with their hats off in the cold and Mr. Stott’s voice going away over the ice. They that go down to the sea in ships. He could almost hear it.

That was the trouble. He could almost hear it.

When he got back aboard, there was fresh meat in the copper for the first time since October.

“Bear,” said Sandy, and grinned at him with bloody gums. “Tuesday. Stott had him off the port quarter, one ball. You slept through that too.”

Elias ate it. Everyone ate it. It was dark and sweet and a little tough, and afterwards the whole mess was quieter, the way men are quiet after a good meal in a warm place, though the place was not warm.

He did not ask to see the skin.


On the first of December the ice nipped.

It began a little after eight bells in the first watch, a long grinding under the starboard bow that went on and on, as if something enormous were being dragged along the keel. Then the deck lifted under their feet, and a beam in the ’tween decks cracked like a musket, and Mr. Stott was shouting for all hands, bundles and bags, and the men came up under the housing with their sea chests and their blankets and stood in the lamplight waiting to learn whether they would sleep aboard or on the floe.

Elias stood with his tool bag between his boots. Next to him was Flett, an Orkneyman who had been whaling since before Elias was born and who spoke, when he spoke at all, as though every word cost him a penny.

The Harmony groaned. The whole hull shivered, stem to stern, and every man there held his breath.

“Were you at Kell’s burying?” Elias said.

Flett did not take his eyes off the rail. “Aye.”

“What was it like?”

“The ice was kind,” said Flett, “for once. Let us cut a proper grave. Stott read very decent.”

They were the words from breakfast. Not words like them: the same words, in the same order, from a man who had not been at the table, because Flett ate in the second sitting.

“Who carved the board?”

Flett looked at him then, briefly, and away.

“You were stood next me,” he said. “Same as now.”

The nip eased toward four bells. The ice let go its grip with a long sigh and the deck settled, a little canted to port, as it would lie for the rest of the winter. The men went below with their bundles. Nobody spoke of it afterwards, the way nobody speaks of a thing that nearly happened.


On the third of December, doing the tally, he counted ten tierces of beef.

He counted again. He went down into the fore hold with the lamp and put his hand on each cask in turn, the way he had been taught at fourteen by old Waddington in the yard at Hull. Nine he knew. The tenth stood at the end of the tier, lashed with the others, and it was new.

The staves were shakes from the after hold, he could see that, the ones the Harmony carried knocked down flat to be set up for blubber on the whaling grounds. They had been set up well. The hoops were driven tight and even. The head sat in the croze as if it had grown there, and on it, scored with a race knife in the curling hand he had used since his apprenticeship, were his own initials.

E B.

He knelt with the lamp and looked at them for a long while. Brine had wept a little at the chime and frozen there in a white rind.

He looked at his hands. There were cuts across the heel of the right palm, the kind a hoop gives you when you are driving it cold and it jumps. He had thought they were from the shakes. When he closed his fist they stung, sharp and clean, as if there were salt in them.


“Who’s been in my shakes?”

Sandy was on his back in his hammock, one arm over his eyes. His legs had gone black below the knee in the last week, and a scar he had got at Greenland in ’thirty-one had opened again, as old scars did in the scurvy, as if the body could no longer remember having healed.

“You set that up Thursday night, after the nip,” Sandy said. “I watched you. You were at it till the end of the middle watch.”

“I don’t remember it.”

“I know you don’t.” Sandy took his arm away from his eyes. They were very clear in the lamplight, and very tired. “Elias. You’ve the only croze aboard. You’re the only man as can head a tierce that true. Who else would it be?”

“What’s in it?”

Sandy looked at him for a moment. Then he put his arm back over his eyes.

“Beef,” he said. “Write beef.”


He went aft to Mr. Stott instead.

The mate was in his berth with a candle and the captain’s log, which he kept now, because Captain Welburn had not been out of his cot since the middle of November. Elias stood in the door with the tally book.

“There’s a tierce of beef in the fore hold that wasn’t there on the thirtieth,” he said. “And there’s a burying on the ice I wasn’t at, and a bear I never heard shot, and no skin.”

Mr. Stott did not look up. He wrote something in the log, in the neat clerk’s hand that had got him his berth.

“The skin’s in the bread room,” he said. “Drying.”

“I’ve been in the bread room.”

“Then you’ve seen it.” Now he looked up. “You’ll write what’s in the hold, cooper. That’s all a tally is. The owners pay on it. What’s in the hold is in the hold, however it came there, and every man aboard will say so at Hull.”

“And Kell?”

“Kell died of the scurvy on the twenty-eighth of November, and he was buried on the twenty-ninth, and I read the hundred and seventh psalm over him with forty-six men standing by.” He turned the log round so Elias could read it. It was all there, in ink, which meant it had been written by the stove. “Forty-seven, if you count yourself. I’d count yourself, Elias. I would.”

He went to the bread room afterwards. There were bags, and a lamp hook, and ice on the ceiling. There was no skin.


10th December. Bread, 28 bags. Beef, 10 tierces, one opened. Pork, 7. Flour, 4. Oatmeal, 1. Molasses, part. Coal, perhaps 5 tons. Allowance, two-thirds, drawn for 47.

The men got better.

That was the thing he wrote nowhere. The gums stopped bleeding. Sandy’s black legs faded to yellow and then to something like skin. Men who had not been out of their hammocks in a fortnight came to the mess table and laughed at things. Captain Welburn was heard to ask for his boots. Mr. Stott wrote in the log that the scurvy was abating, thanks be to God and to the bear, and nobody said anything about the bear at all.

On the ice, the cairn with Kell’s board in it slowly vanished under drift.

In the middle of January the gums began to bleed again.


Elias heard it at the mess on the eighteenth, over the burgoo, and at first he did not understand what he was hearing.

“A fine clear morning for it,” said the cook. “You could see the stars right down to the ice.”

“Stott read very decent.”

“The lad’s mother would have wanted the psalm. They’re chapel folk up in Shetland.”

Magnus Isbister was sitting at the end of the bench.

He was sixteen, the youngest aboard, a thin Unst boy with no English when he had shipped and not a great deal now. His gums had gone the colour of liver. He was holding his bowl in both hands, and he was smiling, uncertainly, at each man as he spoke, the way a boy smiles when he thinks the older men are having a joke on him and he wants them to know he doesn’t mind.

“That’s me,” he said. “I’m here.”

“Aye, lad,” said the cook, very kindly, and went on eating.

Elias put down his spoon.

He saw it then, all at once, the way you see a cask is out of true only when you sight along the whole of it. He had not lost the day in the after hold. He had taken Kell water at four bells, and at breakfast the men had already been remembering the burying. Kell had been in his hammock while they remembered it. He had been in it when the mess agreed he was on the ice. The agreement had not come after. It had come first.

Nobody had decided anything. Nobody would ever have to. By the time it happened, it had already happened, and they had all been there, and it had been decently done.

Magnus caught his eye down the length of the bench. The boy’s smile went, a little at a time, as if something in Elias’s face had told him the joke was not a joke.

Elias looked away first.


He did not sleep that night. He lay in his hammock with his eyes open in the dark and listened to the ship.

At two bells in the middle watch he heard feet going forward, soft, in stockings. Several men. Something heavy dragged a little on the planking and then was lifted. He waited until the sound had gone, and then he got down and followed it, past the stove, which had been banked, past the sick, to the fore hatch, where a lamp was burning below.

He went down the ladder.

The fore hold was cold enough to make his teeth ache. Mr. Stott was there, and the cook, and two of the Orkneymen whose names he could not now remember. Sandy was there, sitting on a tierce with his hands between his knees. On a shake laid across two casks, as neatly as he would have laid them out himself, were his own tools: the adze, the driver, the croze, the race knife. The salt barrel had been opened and its lid set to one side.

There was a hammock on the deck between them, lashed.

Nobody seemed surprised to see him. Mr. Stott held out a lantern.

“Hold the light, Elias,” he said. “Same as last time.”


He went up instead.

He went up the ladder and through the ’tween decks and out under the edge of the canvas housing onto the open deck, into cold so great it was like being struck. There was no moon. The stars were very close. The ice went out on every side of the Harmony as far as he could see and farther, grey and white and black, to a horizon he could not make out, because there was no light for it. Somewhere to the north the pack groaned, a long way off, like a beast turning over in its sleep.

He could walk. There was nothing to stop him. He could climb down onto the floe and walk, south, toward a sun that would not come up for three more weeks, and in an hour or less he would sit down, because every man who walked out onto the ice sat down in the end, and then it would not matter what he remembered.

He stood at the rail until he could not feel his hands.

When he turned round, Sandy was at the edge of the housing with a blanket over his shoulders.

“Come down,” Sandy said.

“Is it the boy?”

Sandy did not answer that.

“Tomorrow,” he said, “we’ll all have been at the lad’s burying. It’ll have been a fine clear morning, and Stott will have read the psalm, and you’ll have cut the board, because you’ve the best hand for letters. You’ll have been there, Elias. You’ll have stood with your hat off in the cold, same as the rest of us.” He came closer, carefully, as though Elias were a man on a yard in a gale. “Or you won’t. And then some morning soon, it’ll be yours we’re remembering. And it’ll be decent, I swear it. I’ll see to that myself.”

“That’s a kindness, is it?”

“It’s the only one there is.” Sandy held out the blanket. “It’s six weeks to the sun.”

Elias looked out once more at the ice.

Then he went down, and took the lantern, and held it.


19th January. Bread, 22 bags. Beef, 10 tierces, two opened. Pork, 6. Flour, 3. Oatmeal, none. Coal, perhaps 3 tons. Allowance, half, drawn for 46.

20th January. Beef, 11 tierces.


They buried Magnus Isbister at noon on the twentieth, when the sky to the south went the colour of a bruise. The ice let them cut a proper grave. Mr. Stott read the hundred and seventh psalm, and forty-five men stood by with their hats off, and Elias Brand stood among them and found that he knew the words, all of them, and was saying them.

He had cut the board. He remembered cutting it. The letters were deep and square.


The pack opened in April, and the Harmony came home to Hull in the second week of May with thirty-nine men aboard and nine written in the log as dead of the scurvy, all buried decently on the ice.

At the owners’ warehouse on the Humber bank the clerk took the tally book and went through the hold with it, cask by cask, and it balanced. Every bag, every barrel, every tierce. The owners’ agent, a fat pleasant man in a brown coat, turned the pages twice and said that in twenty years he had never seen a beset ship’s book so exact, and that the cooper was to have a guinea over his lay.

Elias took the guinea. He took the tally book too, when they were done with it, and he kept it afterwards in a drawer in his house in Dagger Lane, and did not look at it.

There was nothing false in it. That was what he could not forgive it. Of everything aboard the Harmony that winter, the men and the log and the mate and the psalm and his own two hands, the book was the only thing that had never been at a burying, and it agreed with all of them.