The Porter
By Candlelight Slasher horror 19 min
Slasher stories Psychological thrillers
Before you go in
- Murder, of a woman in her sleep and of a man pushed from a moving train
- Period racism, and a Black worker blamed for white passengers' deaths
- A man discharged from his work for something he did not do
There was one pair of shoes too many in my car at two in the morning, on the first night out of Oakland, and I shined them, because that was the job.
You asked for names, and for what was done to us. I will give you both before I am through. But a name means nothing without the car around it, so I will start with the car.
She was the Ellsmere, twelve sections and a drawing room, twenty-six berths, and in July of 1893 she ran through from Oakland to Chicago on the Overland Flyer, full to the last upper with people going to the Fair. I had been a porter nine years. I had a clean car and a quiet one, and I was proud of both, the way a man is proud of the only things that are entirely his. At nine I made down the berths. By eleven the curtains were drawn, green and heavy, and the lamps were turned low at each end, and the heat sat in the car like one more passenger who would not get off. Cinders came through the window screens all night. You could taste the desert.
The shoes came out under the curtains in pairs. At one o’clock I walked the aisle and gathered them into my basket and carried them to the smoking room at the end of the car, where I kept my kit, and I did them there under the lamp. Blacking, brush, cloth, spit and the heel of my hand. I did not need to mark them. I knew every pair in my car by the first night of any run, and I knew these: the mining engineer’s boots from lower 6, resoled twice and proud of it; the schoolteacher’s little lace shoes from upper 9; the old gentleman’s gaiters from lower 12. Mr Pratt in lower 3 set none out. He told me the first afternoon he would not have a man work on his account at that hour.
That same afternoon he had asked me my name.
You will understand what that meant, so I will not dress it. Every porter on every line was George, after Mr Pullman, the way a dog is called after the man who owns it. Mr Lyman Pratt, buttonhooks and notions out of Cincinnati, leaned in the door of the smoking room with his sample case at his feet and said, “What do they call you at home?” and I told him, and he said, “Samuel,” and from then on he used it. He tipped a half-dollar for a pillow. He asked if I had a family. I told him about Clara, and our girl, and how they would be at Wells Street to meet the train.
At two I came back down the aisle with the first of the shoes, and outside lower 4 there was a pair of good button boots that had not been there at one.
Lower 4 was a lady travelling alone, a widow from Sacramento in grey silk. When I made down her berth she had told me she would keep her boots by her, thank you. She had a bottle of laudanum on the window ledge and a fan she never put down.
I stood in the aisle with my basket. The car swayed. Somebody snored behind a curtain. I could smell the blacking on my own hands.
Then I took the boots to the smoking room and shined them, because a pair left dull in my car would have been a complaint against my name, and I put them back under her curtain before five, unbuttoned, the way they came.
At the call for breakfast her curtain did not move.
I called twice, softly, the way you do for a lady. Then Mr Haskell came. He was the Pullman conductor, who had charge of all the sleepers on the train, and he did not like to be fetched. He put his hand through the curtain, and took it out again, and stood a moment looking at nothing. Then he said, “Heat.”
We were past Elko by then. The telegraph went ahead of us, and she was taken off at the next stop in a blanket, and her trunk after her, and the berth was stripped and made up fresh, and by noon there was a family from Reno in it, eating oranges.
Mr Haskell spoke to me in the vestibule.
“It takes the old ones and the stout ones,” he said. “Every July. She’d been at that bottle. It’s nobody’s fault, George, and it won’t be anybody’s fault if you keep your mouth shut about it till Chicago. You keep your car, and I’ll keep the train.”
I said yes, Mr Haskell.
I want to set down what I thought, because it was a reasonable thing to think, and I thought it hard.
A woman alone in July, in a car like an oven, with laudanum by her pillow. It happens. I had carried two dead passengers off in nine years and neither of them was anybody’s fault. I wanted it to be the heat more than I have wanted most things. You know why. There was a dead white woman in my car, and the only man whose work took him between the curtains at night was me. If it was the heat, it was nobody. If it was anything else, it was going to be me, whatever the truth was, because I was the one already standing there.
So I tried it the other way. Perhaps she woke in the night and set the boots out after all. Perhaps she changed her mind and was ashamed to ring.
But when they took her off I saw the boots, set side by side under her berth where I had left them. They were buttoned. Every button, to the top, close and neat, as though somebody meant to walk in them. I had put them back open. You cannot do up a button boot like that without a hook, and she had not been in them, and she was not going to be.
Half the ladies on that train carried a buttonhook in their bags. I told myself that. It did not help.
On the second day we stood an hour at Ogden while the cars went over to the Union Pacific, and that night we crossed Wyoming in the dark.
The cattleman in lower 11 never set his boots out. He was a big, sunburned man who had boots stolen once at Winnemucca, he said, and he slept with them on the floor of his berth by his hand. I collected the shoes at one. Nothing outside lower 11.
At two I came back down the aisle, and his boots were standing in it. Cracked across the toes. Set square to the curtain. And the aisle smelled faintly of blacking, though there was none in the aisle but what was on my hands.
I did not touch them. That was my whole plan, and I was proud of it for nearly a minute. If somebody wanted those boots shined, they could stand there dull until doomsday, and whatever came of it would not come through my hands. I went back to my stool at the end of the car and sat where I could see them.
At twenty past two a hand came out between the curtains of upper 9, and Miss Fry, the schoolteacher, whispered, “Porter? I’m so sorry. Is there water?”
I brought her a cup from the cooler at the far end. It cannot have been four minutes. She had heard someone in the aisle, she said, and she was sorry, she knew it was foolish, she could not sleep in this heat. She thanked me. She was the kind of lady who looked at your face when she thanked you, and I noticed that she was looking at mine, and that she was turning something over.
When I came back down the aisle the cattleman’s boots were shined. Not well. Fast and heavy, the way a man does it who has watched it done. The blacking was still tacky on the welt. I went into the smoking room, and my brush was lying on my kit, not in it, and it was damp.
I told myself it was a joke. Some young fellow in an upper who had watched me at it and thought it would be comical to see the porter’s face. That was the best thing it could be, and I wanted it badly. But a joke wants somebody to laugh, and every curtain in that car was shut, and nobody was laughing. Whoever had done it knew where I kept my kit and how long a cup of water takes. They had been watching me work, the way you watch a clock.
Down the car the end door was banging. I went through to the vestibule and the outer door was unlatched and swinging on the night, and the dark went by outside like water. I latched it. I came back and stood at lower 11 with my hand up to the curtain, and I said, “Sir?” and nobody answered, and I did not open it.
I think about that more than anything else. I had my hand on the curtain.
In the morning the berth was empty and his hat was on its hook. A section gang found him beside the track west of Rawlins in his stocking feet. The telegraph called it a fall. His boots were in my aisle, shined.
On the third day the car began to look at me.
It was not one thing. It was a gentleman stopping talking when I came by with the towels, and starting again when I had passed. It was a lady drawing her girl’s hand back from the arm of the seat as I leaned in to make it up. It was the family from Reno asking Mr Haskell, in my hearing, whether the porter had to come through at night.
At breakfast Miss Fry made it worse, and she meant only good by it. She said, clearly, to the whole table, “The porter was up at two, he brought me water. Weren’t you, porter? You must have seen the poor man go out.”
I said no, miss, I did not see him go.
Every face at that table turned towards me, and then away.
Mr Haskell had me into the vestibule again. “A drunk man takes air between the cars and goes over,” he said. “Happens on every road in the West. But you were up and about, George, and now the whole car knows it. Tonight you’ll sit in the smoking room and you’ll come when you’re rung for, and not before. You understand me?”
I said yes, Mr Haskell.
Mr Pratt found me after, at the water cooler. He put his hand on my shoulder. He was the only passenger in that car who would have touched me in front of the others, and I was grateful, and I am telling you so because it is true.
“They’re frightened, Samuel,” he said, low. “Frightened people want a name, and yours is the one they’ve got. Don’t let it trouble you. I’ll speak for you at Chicago. Where did you say your wife will be?”
“Wells Street. At the gate.”
“Good. And what time do they let you sleep?”
“Three hours, sir. After four.”
“Then sleep, man,” he said, and gave me another half-dollar, and nodded down the car towards lower 7. “And keep an eye on that one. Never says a word. I’ve seen his kind on the road.”
Lower 7 was a thin man in a black suit who had looked at me, I realised, a good deal. I had not marked it until Mr Pratt said it. After that I could not stop marking it.
At North Platte that evening a man got on who was not on the diagram.
I know the diagram because I checked it after. Mr Haskell kept it, a sheet with every berth and every ticket sold, and there was nobody from North Platte. But he came up the steps in the last light, a tall man in a long linen travelling coat with the hood drawn up, which nobody does in July, and Mr Haskell walked past him in the aisle as if he were a seat. He went into the smoking room and sat on my bench. He asked me for a glass of water, and I brought it, and he did not drink it.
At ten, when I had made down the last berth and came in to sit where I was told, he spoke to me. He did not lift his head.
“They will ask you what you saw,” he said. “Decide now what that was.”
I said, “Sir?”
He said nothing else, then or ever.
I did not stay in the smoking room. I sat on my stool in the doorway of it, which is not the same as the aisle, and which I could have argued to Mr Haskell if it came to arguing, and I watched the car.
I watched lower 7. Mr Pratt had put him in my head and he would not come out. The curtains swayed together all down the car, green on green. The lamps were low. The heat had not broken. At one I did not gather the shoes. Let them complain.
You will want to know how a man watches a whole car and still misses it. I will tell you exactly, because it is the part I have gone over most. I was looking at the curtain of lower 7. It moved, the way a curtain moves when somebody turns over behind it, and I leaned forward to see if it would open. It did not. And the smell of blacking came to me down the aisle, faint and sweet and oily, the smell of my own hands, and I looked along the car, and outside lower 12, ten feet from my stool, where I had been looking a minute before and was not looking now, the old gentleman’s gaiters were standing in the aisle.
He had not set them out at eleven. I had seen him take them into his berth.
I did not touch them. I went down on my heels at his curtain and said, “Sir. Sir, did you put your shoes out?”
A long while. Then his voice, thick and far off. “Go away, George.”
He was alive. I could have wept. I sat down on the floor of the aisle with my back against his berth, which no porter does, and I made up my mind I would sit there till Omaha if I had to.
Mr Pratt came down the car in his shirtsleeves. He must have heard me. He crouched by me, easy, the way he did everything.
“Trouble, Samuel?”
I told him. Not all of it. The gaiters.
He looked at them a while. “I’ll sit with the old fellow,” he said. “You go and wash your face. You look like death.”
I said I was all right, sir. I said it was my car.
He smiled at that as if I had pleased him. “So it is,” he said. “Then I’ll have a cigar.” And he went on up the aisle past me, towards the smoking room, and I heard the door.
I sat. The car ran on. And after a minute I saw that down at the other end, under lower 3, Mr Pratt’s sample case was standing half out into the aisle, where he must have pulled it to get his cigars. Anybody going to the cooler in the dark would go over it. I have put passengers’ things straight a hundred thousand times in my life. It is not a thing you decide. I got up and went down the car to push it under, and the catch was not fastened, and it fell open at my feet.
It was what he said it was. Buttonhooks in rows on a card, a hundred of them, steel and bone and silver. Thread. Hooks and eyes. Tins of blacking, a dozen, the same make as mine. And under the card, a little book in black oilcloth, the size of my tip book, that was the only thing in there he was not selling.
I opened it because I had already seen the blacking. I want to be honest about that. A porter who opens a passenger’s book can be put off at the next water tank. I opened it.
It was lines of a neat hand, years of them. A date, a car, a road, a name.
September 1881. Golconda. C. and A. William Bates. Disch.
April 1884. Carrara. Penn. Henry Lyle. Disch.
August 1889. Sylvanite. Burlington. Thomas Greer. Disch.
More than I could read with my hands shaking. Car names I knew from the yards. Porters’ names, real names, not George, and after every one of them that same short word.
At the bottom of the page, in the same ink, already dry: July 1893. Ellsmere. S.P., U.P., C. and N.W. Samuel Ward. And then a space.
I knelt there in the aisle and everything he had ever said to me turned over and showed its other side. What do they call you at home. Where will your wife be. What time do they let you sleep. Keep an eye on that one. I’ll sit with the old fellow. Every kindness had been a question, and every question had an answer, and he had needed every answer he got. Nobody else in that car had cared to know my name. He was the only one who needed it, because an inquiry has to have somebody to write down.
And the shoes. I had thought they were a warning, a cruel one, set out for me to find. They were not for me to find. They were for me to handle. He set them out so my hands would be on every pair, my blacking on every welt, and when I would not do it he did it for me with my own brush.
I closed the book. I put it back under the card the way I found it and fastened the catch and pushed the case under the berth, because that is what a porter does with a thing that is not his. Then I stood up and looked down the car towards lower 12.
His curtain was open. The berth was empty. The gaiters were gone from the aisle.
I ran. I am not ashamed of it. Past the curtains, past lower 7, where a face looked out at me white and was gone. Outside the linen locker, by the smoking-room door, a pair of shoes was standing side by side, and I knew them before I was near them.
They were my own. My good black shoes that I kept wrapped in the locker for the day off, for taking Clara and our girl to the Fair, because Clara had written that she meant to see Mr Douglass at the Haytian building and I was not going to stand beside him in my work shoes. They were set out square to the locker door, and they had been shined to a mirror, better than I ever shined them, and the smell of blacking was thick enough to taste.
The smoking room was empty. The man in the linen coat was gone, and his glass of water stood full on the ledge, not a mouthful out of it.
The end door was banging.
In the vestibule the noise was everything. The iron plates grinding under my feet, the canvas of the diaphragm working like a lung, and the outer door hooked wide open on the dark, and the dark going past at forty miles an hour, the smell of it, hot corn and dust. Nebraska. The old gentleman was standing in the doorway in his nightshirt and his stocking feet with Mr Pratt behind him, holding him up under the arms like a friend who has had too much, and the old man’s head was nodding. Whatever he had been given to sleep on, it was not laudanum from his own bottle.
Mr Pratt looked round at me. He did not let go.
“Samuel,” he said, kind as ever. “Go and sit down. You never left your stool. In the morning you’ll have done his gaiters, and you’ll have your good shoes on, and Clara will be at Wells Street at the gate. You’d like that.”
I could not take hold of him. You understand me. A coloured porter who lays hands on a white passenger in the dark, with a dead woman and a dead man behind him already, does not reach Chicago, or if he reaches it he does not reach it long. And if I took hold of the old man and he went out of my hands into the dark, then it was my hands. Mr Pratt knew all of that. He had it written down in a book.
So I did the one thing a porter must never do.
The emergency valve is on the bulkhead just inside the end door, with a handle you could hang your hat on, and in nine years I had never touched it except to dust. I took it in both hands and pulled.
The air went out of the line with a scream I can hear now. Every wheel under that train locked at once. The floor came up and threw me into the door frame. The car behind us slammed into ours, and all down the Ellsmere people were crying out and falling, and the lamps went out. Mr Pratt went backwards into the canvas and lost his hold, and the old gentleman came down on the plates at my feet, and I got my arms round him and held on while the whole train shuddered and screamed and shoved itself to a stop in the middle of the corn.
Then it was quiet. Hissing. Somebody sobbing. Crickets, if you can believe it. A great many crickets.
I had the old man. I did not have Mr Pratt. He had gone back past me into the dark car while I was holding on, and I did not see him go, I only felt the air of it. A minute later, through the window of the far door, against the stars, I saw a man step down from the other end of the Ellsmere with a case in his hand, and walk out into the corn, not hurrying, the way a drummer walks to his next town.
When the lanterns came, the old gentleman was sitting on the floor of the vestibule in his nightshirt, and I was kneeling beside him, and my good shoes were outside the linen locker for anybody to see.
He did his best by me, I think. He said what he remembered. The porter had been at his curtain in the night. The porter had been talking about his shoes. He did not remember anything after that until the porter was holding him.
Mr Haskell asked about Mr Pratt, and a brakeman said the drummer had got down to see what was the trouble, and Mr Haskell said, “Then he can walk to Omaha,” and that was all the looking anybody did. A drummer is not a crime. We lost forty minutes.
At the inquiry in Chicago they asked me what I saw. I had decided, the way the man in the linen coat told me to. I said Mr Lyman Pratt of Cincinnati, and his book, and the names in it, and my own name at the bottom in his hand. I said it twice, slowly. A clerk wrote while I talked. When they read it back it said that the porter had stopped the Overland without cause, in the night, after interfering with the passenger in lower 12, and had made accusations against another passenger who was not present to answer them.
I was discharged at the Company’s offices on Michigan Avenue that afternoon. Clara and our girl waited at the gate for two hours in their good things for a man who had already been taken off the run. I never rode again. I did other work, and I will not trouble you with it.
That was thirty-two years ago. I am sixty-six. I would have let it lie, I think, if you had not sent round your list.
You asked for porters discharged for cause, and the old men gave you their names, and you printed them so we could see the shape of what was done to us. I have read it three times. I know the shape. A death in a hot car, called the heat. A fall between the cars. An inquiry. A porter let go. It is there on the Santa Fe and the Pennsylvania and the Illinois Central, years apart, men I never met, and the last of it is from last year.
So here is mine, for your list, plainly.
My name is Samuel Ward. I was a Pullman porter nine years, on the through run from Oakland to Chicago, in the car Ellsmere. I was discharged in July 1893 for stopping a train. There is a book somewhere in the world with my name in it in another man’s hand, and a name in that man’s book ought to be written down somewhere else as well, by the man it belongs to.