The Anatomy Lesson

By Candlelight Body horror 16 min

Plague and medical horror

Before you go in
  • Public dissection of an executed man, described with restraint
  • Execution by hanging
  • Fear of being buried or opened while alive
  • Loss of control over one's own body

The theatre over the Little Meat Hall was so cold that Jacob could see his own breath on the dead man.

It went out of him in a white plume and lay across the chest under the lantern and was gone. He had lit the brazier an hour before dawn and it had done nothing yet but stink. Below the boards the butchers were opening their stalls, and the smell of the trade came up through the cracks, blood and sawdust and frost, so that the room was full of meat before the lesson had begun.

The guild’s man had brought the body at dusk the day before, on a handcart with a sail over it, from the scaffold on the Dam in front of the new Town Hall. Black Jan, the crowd had called him. A tailor from Diest in Brabant who had come home from the Indies with money and spent it, and then had taken a knife into a cloth shop on the Nieuwendijk. Twenty-two years old. He was spared the gallows field at the Volewijk, where the hanged were left for the crows across the IJ. The surgeons had asked the magistrates for him, and the magistrates had given him, and tomorrow, which was now today, the new praelector would open him in front of everyone in Amsterdam who could pay at the door.

Jacob had been servant to the surgeons’ guild for six years. He swept the theatre and fetched the instruments from the guild chamber in the Waag and boiled the bones for the cabinet, and in the spring he would sit his examination, and if Doctor Deijman spoke for him, he would be a master and never sweep anything again.

This was Deijman’s first lesson. Jacob had shaved the dead man’s face for it himself.

He drew the sheet down to the waist and began to wash the body with a sponge and a basin of water so cold he had to break a skin of ice on it first. He worked as he had been taught, from the face downwards, the way you clean a table. The rope had left a dark groove under the jaw and up behind one ear. The hands were a tailor’s hands, a callus on the right forefinger from the needle.

He lifted the left arm to wash beneath it, and stopped.

The skin in the hollow of the arm was warm.


Not warm as a room is warm. Warm like a sleeping child, when you lift it from the bed. Like bread an hour after it has come out of the oven.

Jacob put the arm down and stood back from the table and breathed for a while, watching his breath go white.

He was a careful man. It was why the guild kept him. He thought it through as he would have checked a count of instruments.

The brazier. It was behind him, a yard away, and it was barely alight. The body had lain all night in the cellar under the stairs, against the wall it shared with the bakehouse next door, and the bakers fired their ovens at three. A body against a warm wall for half a night might keep something of it in the deep places, under the arms, between the legs, where the flesh folds over itself.

He wanted that to be true. It was a sensible thing, and it would mean that nothing needed saying.

Then he did what a surgeon’s servant does, and checked. He pressed two fingers under the jaw beside the rope’s mark and waited. Nothing. He took the brass basin, emptied it, wiped it dry on his apron and held its bright bottom to the dead man’s lips for a slow count of thirty. No mist. He lifted an eyelid with his thumb. The eye was dull, filmed over like a fish on a slab below.

Dead, then. Dead a day and a half.

He put his hand back under the arm. It was warmer than before.


Gijsbert Calkoen came up the stairs at eight, stamping snow off his boots, a big fair surgeon with red hands and a laugh you could hear in the street. He was to assist the doctor today, and hold the parts as they came out.

“Christ, it’s colder in here than on the Dam,” Calkoen said. “Is he ready? Is he pretty?”

Jacob told him.

Calkoen did not laugh. He came and put his own hand flat on the dead man’s chest, and held it there, and his face went still. Then he grinned, which was worse.

“Well. Have you heard of the English girl? At Oxford, five or six years back. They hanged her, a servant girl, and gave her to the anatomists, and when they opened the coffin she was rattling in her throat. They bled her and warmed her and put her to bed with another woman, and she lived. There’s a pamphlet. She married, I think.” He took his hand away and wiped it on his coat. “Doctor Deijman would not thank us for a miracle on his first day.”

“He’s dead, sir. I’ve tried the basin. And the pulse.”

Calkoen bent over the face and pinched the nostrils shut and held them, and watched the mouth. He thumbed the eyelid up as Jacob had done and looked for a long moment at the clouded eye.

“Yes,” he said. “Dead as the Volewijk.” He straightened. “You’ve had him by the fire.”

“The fire is behind me, sir. He was warm before it was.”

“Then he’s a warm-blooded fellow, and he’ll be cold soon enough once the doctor has the lid off him.” Calkoen looked round the empty benches, rising in their rings towards the roof, and rubbed his red hands together. “Don’t get fond of him, Jacob. Old Aris used to sleep beside them to keep the rats off. He watched over Tulp’s man in thirty-two, all three nights, and he never got warm again after. He’d sit in July with his coat on. Died at Easter, blue as a mussel.” He laughed now, at last. “Lay the knives out. Long ones first.”


The bell went at ten.

Jacob had rung it himself from the stair, the guild’s brass handbell, and the people came up past him with their stuivers ready and their breath smoking. Students from the Athenaeum with their notebooks. Two of the burgomasters’ men in good black. Apothecaries, a preacher, three women in furs who had come to say they had come, and the usual men from the taverns on the Zeedijk who would pay a day’s wage to see a man they had watched hang opened like a herring. A painter sat at the very top with a board on his knee and a stick of chalk. The benches filled ring by ring until the theatre was a bowl of faces leaning in, and every one of them breathed out white, so that a low cloud lay over the room under the roof beams, lit gold by the candles.

Doctor Jan Deijman came in last, in black, with a white collar and his hat on, and stood at the head of the table. He was thin and exact and thirty-six years old, and Jacob, who had laid out his instruments for him at practice dissections of dogs, saw that his hands were not quite steady.

Deijman spoke in Dutch for the crowd and in Latin when he wanted the students to know he could. He named the man and his crime. He said that the body of a malefactor, given up by justice, became by the mercy of the magistrates a book in which God’s craftsmanship could be read. Then he held out his hand without looking, and Jacob put the knife into it, and the doctor opened the belly from the breastbone down.

The steam came up out of the body like the breath of a horse.

It rose thick and white into the candlelight, a column of it, higher than the doctor’s hat, and spread out under the roof into the low cloud of the crowd’s breath. Somebody in the third ring said a name of God out loud. One of the women in furs stood up. Calkoen, at Deijman’s shoulder, had gone the colour of tallow.

And the blood ran. Not much. Dark, but it ran, in a slow sheet over the side, and dripped onto the boards.

Deijman did not look up. He waited, with the knife held up a little, while the theatre went quiet. Then he said, in Dutch, to all of them, “You see that nature is slow to let go of her heat. The inward parts keep it longest. Galen says as much. This is the vital warmth, which is the last thing to leave a man.” He turned the blade in the light. “We are fortunate to have him so fresh.”

The crowd breathed out. A man laughed. The woman in furs sat down.

Jacob stood at the foot of the table with the basin and watched the steam still rising, and knew how long the man had been dead, and knew that the belly had been warmer than the arm.


The lesson went on until the candles were low. The doctor took out the liver and the stomach and the long grey ropes of the gut and laid them in order on the board and named their uses, because the belly goes first in a lesson, before it spoils. By the end the steam had thinned to a shimmer. The people went down the stairs talking, pleased, many of them promising to come again tomorrow for the head.

When they had gone, Jacob went to the doctor at the window, where Deijman was cleaning his hands in a bowl.

“Doctor. He was warm at dawn. Before the fire. He’s warmer now than he was then.”

Deijman dried his fingers one by one on a cloth. He did it slowly. Jacob understood that he was being shown that the doctor’s hands were steady now.

“Do you know what the guild has spent on candles for this lesson?” Deijman said. “On the bell, the benches, the beer for the officers? The magistrates gave us this man. The court hanged him. He is dead by every law in the Republic. What is warm in him is not our concern.” He folded the cloth. “You have been a good servant, Jacob. I mean to speak for you at your examination. Tomorrow we open the head. Keep the rats off him.”


The servant slept in the theatre during a lesson. Rats came up from the meat hall, and there were men who would pay for a hanged man’s hand or a strip of his skin to cure a fever, and the executioner’s boy sold poor sinner’s fat for stiff joints and would have liked more of it. Jacob made his bed on the lowest bench with two blankets and the guild’s old cloak, and put the lantern by the table, and fed the brazier.

He could not get warm.

It had started in his hands, at the lesson. A numbness, as though he had been holding snow. Now it had climbed to his wrists. He held them over the brazier until the hair on the backs of them crisped, and could not feel the heat, only see the hair curl. He put them in his armpits. His armpits were cold.

He told himself what every anatomist knew. The cold of the dead gets into the hands. The vapours of a corpse are cold and wet and they enter by the skin. That is why surgeons drink. He had a little gin in a stone bottle for the night, and he drank some, and felt it go down like water.

At midnight he got up and took a tallow candle and went to the table. He wanted to know, the way he had wanted to know at dawn.

He let a drop of hot tallow fall onto the dead man’s chest, above the opening, on the clean skin.

It stayed a drop. Clear and wet, shining, like a bead of water. It did not set.

He held out his own wrist and let a drop fall onto it.

It went white at once, hard and dull as a fish scale. He had not felt it land. He scraped it off with his thumbnail and there was no red mark beneath.

He stood holding the candle and breathed out, slowly, to steady himself, and watched for his breath.

There was nothing. No plume. The lantern light lay on the air between him and the table, and his breath went into it and did not show.

Over the dead man’s mouth, faint, a hand’s breadth above the lips, a little mist was hanging in the cold.


He walked home. He did not decide to; he found himself on the stair, then on the ice of the Kloveniersburgwal, his feet loud and numb, the cloak round him and no warmth in it. The canals were frozen white from wall to wall and the moon was on them. He passed the Waag, dark, the guild’s windows shuttered over the paintings. Nobody stopped him.

Margriet woke when he got into the bed and screamed, because he had touched her.

“God, Jacob. You’re like a stone.” She sat up and lit the stub of candle and took his hands and looked at them, white to the wrists, and pressed them under her arms against her skin, and held them there, and he could not feel it. She put her ear on his chest. She was quiet for a long time.

“It’s so slow,” she said. “Your heart. It’s like something in the next house.” She looked at him with her hair over her face. “Don’t go back there. Send the boy from the corner. Say you’re sick. You are sick.”

He said he would not go back. He lay in the bed with her body against his back and her arms round him, and he stared at the dark and could not stop thinking of the theatre, the warm table under the lantern. He knew, as a dog knows where the fire is, where the warmth in the city was. It was not in this bed.

Before it was light he got up. Margriet was asleep. He did not wake her. He told himself it was the examination, and Deijman’s word, and that a servant who did not come on the second day of the doctor’s first lesson would never be a master of anything. All of that was true.

He went back because it was warm there.


The body had not been touched. The brazier had gone out. In the grey light from the high windows the mist above the mouth was clearer than it had been by candle, a thin breath, rising and falling.

Jacob put his palm flat on the chest, as Calkoen had done.

It was warm as a man asleep. And under his palm he felt the warmth draw at him, the way the cold sea draws at your legs when you wade, a pull out of his hand and up his arm, and for a moment he could not lift it away. He had to put his other hand on the table and push.

He stood back, holding his wrist.

He thought of the sponge going over the skin, his hands on the face as he shaved it, his arm under the shoulders when he turned the man for the doctor, his whole body on the bench beside the table all the night. Every time he had touched it, it had been warmer after. Every time, he had been colder. Old Aris, in his coat in July. Three nights beside Tulp’s man.

It was not keeping its heat. It was being given it.

It was taking his.


The crowd for the head was twice the size. Word had gone round the taverns that the hanged man bled, and the people sat on the stairs when the benches were full, and stood in the doorway, and the cloud of their breath under the roof was so thick that the candles burned in it as if in a fog.

Jacob held the tall candle at the head of the table, as the servant did for the head. From there he was closer to the dead man’s face than anyone. When the crowd went quiet, he could see the little mist come and go above the lips. Nobody else was close enough. Calkoen stood with his back to it, ready to take the crown of the skull. Deijman was looking at the crowd.

Then Deijman looked at him.

He had seen it. Jacob knew he had. The doctor’s eyes went to the mouth, and to Jacob’s hand on the candle, white as wax to the wrist, and back to Jacob’s face, and they were perfectly calm.

“Jacob,” the doctor said, in a voice the front rings could hear. “Is there something you wish to say to the guild before we proceed?”

He could say it. He breathes. The whole theatre would hear. The lesson would stop. The burgomasters’ men would send for a physician, and the body would go to the grave whole, and warm, and whatever was in it would go on being warm. And Jacob would sit by his own fire in July in his coat.

Or he could hold his tongue, and it would be over by noon.

He thought it through, exactly, the way he counted instruments. The court had hanged this man. The law said he was dead. His belly lay empty on the board under a cloth. No man lives with his belly empty. Whatever was warm in him was not a man, and it was not Jacob’s affair to say what it was.

“No, Doctor,” Jacob said.

He handed Deijman the saw.

He did not watch the sawing. He watched the candle flame, and listened, and the sound went on longer than he wanted, and the crowd did not breathe at all. Then Calkoen lifted the crown of the skull away in both hands like the lid of a pot.

The heat came up out of the opened head in one breath. It rose straight into the candlelight and into Jacob’s face, and without meaning to, because he had held his own breath too long, he breathed in.

It went into him warm. It filled his chest like broth. It went down his arms and into his hands, and his hands burned, burned as frozen hands do in front of a fire, so that he nearly dropped the candle and had to grip it in both fists while the pain went through his fingers like needles. He gasped. His breath went out of him white, a great plume of it, across the table and into the cloud of the crowd.

On the table, under his candle, the dead man’s face had gone grey. The mist above the lips was gone. When Calkoen, frowning, laid the back of his hand against the cheek, he took it away quickly, and wiped it on his coat.

“Cold as the IJ,” he said, under his breath, and then louder, cheerful, to the doctor, “Cold at last, sir.”

Deijman nodded, and bent to his work, and said in Latin that they would now observe the coverings of the brain.


They kept the body three days, as the magistrates allowed. On the second of February Jacob sewed what was left of Black Jan into a canvas shroud, and walked behind the cart to the Zuiderkerkhof, and stood at the edge of the poor ground while the gravediggers broke the frost with picks. He was warm the whole time. He was warm in the wind. He took his gloves off and put them in his pocket.

The painter who had sat at the top of the theatre was paid to make a picture of the lesson for the guild chamber in the Waag. Jacob was not in it. Servants are not.

In the spring he sat his examination, and Doctor Deijman spoke for him, and he was made a master.

He was never cold again. He slept with the shutters open in February. Margriet said he burned like a stove, and that she was glad, mostly.

But he talked in his sleep, she said, and he never used to. He talked in a voice from somewhere south, soft at the edges, the way they talk in Brabant. He asked for his mother, whose grave Margriet had stood at in Edam. Twice he said the name of a town, and she asked the neighbours, and none of them had heard of it, and Jacob told her he had never been there, which was true.

It was called Diest.