Six in the Chat

By Streetlight Psychological horror 11 min

Psychological horror Technology horror

Before you go in
  • Social exclusion and gaslighting
  • A parent's death from illness, mentioned
  • Memory loss

The message arrived at 21:14, while Priya was on the booking site with her card in her hand, paying the deposit on a cottage in the Peak District that slept five.

Hollie added Elliot Marsh.

Her phone buzzed four times before she had finished typing the security code. By the time the booking confirmation came through, the group chat had forty new messages, most of them in capitals.

ELLIOT MARSH. AS I LIVE AND BREATHE.

where have you BEEN

Hollie how did you find him???

facebook stalking obviously. he’s in bristol. he has a DOG

the bench is complete!!!!

The group was called Bench Crew, after the bench by the science block at St Anselm’s where they had eaten lunch every day for three years. Hollie, Tash, Meg, Sam and Priya. Nineteen years of birthdays, two weddings, one divorce, a funeral. Priya had been in the chat since it was a text thread on a Nokia.

She scrolled up. A photo of a man about her age, broad, a little bald at the crown, grinning on a beach with a spaniel. A voice note from Tash that was just screaming. Sam: mate. MATE.

Elliot Marsh: Hello you lot. Hollie found me. I’ve missed you so much it’s actually embarrassing.

Priya typed who? and looked at it for a long time, and deleted it.


She messaged Hollie on her own.

sorry being thick. who’s Elliot?

The two ticks went blue almost at once. Hollie was typing. Stopped. Typing.

lol stop

Then a voice note. Hollie’s voice, warm and slightly drunk, the television on behind her. “Pri. Elliot. Bench Elliot. He carried you to the nurse when you fainted at sports day. You were sick on his shoes. You made him a card.” A laugh. “You can’t have forgotten Elliot, he was literally your favourite.”

Priya had fainted at sports day in Year 10. She remembered the heat coming up off the track and the sky going white at the edges. She remembered Sam carrying her, his elbow hard against her ear, the nurse’s room that smelled of TCP, Sam’s ruined trainers afterwards, and making Sam a card with a cartoon of the trainers on it.

She played the voice note again. Carried you. Your favourite.

She wrote back ha obviously, sorry, long day, and put the phone face down on the table, and did not pick it up again until she had washed the pans.

Then she rang Sam. Sam was the safe one to ring. Sam never remembered anything, so he never argued about it.

“Random question,” she said. “Sports day, Year 10. When I fainted. Who carried me?”

“Is this about Elliot?” He sounded amused and then, when she did not laugh, less amused. “Pri, I was on the relay. I was on the other side of the field. I saw it from the bend.” A pause. “You were sick on his shoes. He kept them. He said they were a trophy.”

“I thought it was you.”

“Me?” Sam laughed properly then. “I couldn’t carry you now, let alone then. I was about five foot two.” Another pause, longer. “You all right? Hollie said you were being weird.”

Hollie said. So they were talking about it. About her.

“I’m fine,” she said. “Tired.”

“Get some sleep,” Sam said, kindly, the way people said it to her in Year 11.


Elliot remembered everything.

That was what made it hard. Over the next week he was in the chat every evening, never too much, never showing off, easy and specific. He remembered Tash’s hamster funeral. He remembered Sam’s terrible band. He remembered that Meg’s mum drove a Micra with one green door. He remembered things about Priya.

Pri! I still owe you a tenner from the Reading Festival thing, don’t think I’ve forgotten.

Pri, does your mum still do the samosas? I think about those samosas at least once a month.

Pri, I was so sorry to hear about your dad. I know it was years ago. I just never said.

She had never told anyone in the group that she and her mum had gone to Reading Festival for one day in 2006 and left at three because her mum hated the toilets. It had not seemed worth telling. It had not seemed like a thing anyone would know.

She replied with laughing faces. She replied thanks E, that’s kind. She watched herself do it, and it felt like watching someone else fill in a form in her handwriting.

“Tash,” she said on the phone on the Thursday, trying to sound idle. “Have you still got the prom photos? The table one?”

“Oh my God. Yes. Hang on.”

It came through while they were still talking. The round table in the function room at the hotel, June 2007, balloons and a bad backdrop. Six of them. Hollie in blue. Tash in the silver dress she had borrowed from Priya. Meg, Sam, Priya with her hair ironed flat. And beside Priya, his arm along the back of her chair, a big boy with a soft face and a clip-on bow tie, grinning at the camera as if he had been waiting all night for it.

“God, look at Elliot,” Tash said. “Wasn’t he sweet?”

“Yeah,” Priya said. “He was.”


Her mum’s house in Caversham still had every photograph anyone had ever taken, in albums with sticky plastic pages that crackled when you lifted them. Priya went on the Sunday, for lunch, and said she wanted to look at old pictures, and her mum was so pleased that Priya felt guilty.

The prom photo was on the third page of the 2007 album. The same table, the same balloons. Her mum had bought a print from the school photographer for twelve pounds and never let anyone forget it.

Five of them. Hollie, Tash, Meg, Sam, Priya.

Beside Priya, an empty chair. A dark jacket hung over the back of it, the kind boys wore to prom and took off the minute they were allowed.

“Mum. Who was sitting there?”

Her mum leaned over, glasses pushed up on her head. “I don’t know, beta. One of your lot. You were all in and out of those chairs all night.”

“Do you remember a boy called Elliot?”

Her mum thought about it. She was a careful woman who did not like to say no to things. “There were a lot of boys,” she said. “That was a bad year. You weren’t here half the time, even when you were here.”

It was what everyone said. Priya had been sixteen when her dad was diagnosed and seventeen when he died, and Year 11 was a smear of hospital car parks and revision she did not remember doing. The GP had given her something to help her sleep, and she had taken it for too long. You were away with the fairies that year, Hollie said at birthdays, fondly. We carried you.

So maybe it was her. Maybe the gap had a boy in it.

She took a picture of the empty chair before she put the album back.


It was Meg who told her to say something.

“Just be honest,” Meg said. “He’d rather know. It’ll be worse if you pretend and then get something wrong at the cottage.”

So on the Tuesday night Priya wrote it out three times and sent it to the group.

ok this is embarrassing. E, I’m so sorry, but I genuinely don’t remember you. I think that year’s just gone for me. It’s not personal x

The ticks went blue, all of them, within a minute. Nobody typed.

Then Tash: Pri that’s not funny

Then Sam: is this a bit?

Then nothing for four minutes, which in that chat was a very long time.

Then Elliot: Hey, it’s completely fine. Honestly. That was an awful year for you and I was just some lad on a bench. I’m not going anywhere. We can make new memories at the cottage! x

Hollie hearted it. Meg hearted it. Tash hearted it. Sam wrote legend.

Nobody replied to Priya. Her message sat above Elliot’s with its blue ticks, like something said at a party that everyone had agreed not to have heard.

Ten minutes later Hollie messaged her privately. Pri did you book the cottage for 6?? just checking xx

She had booked it for five. She opened the site. According to the listing, the cottage had six bedrooms. It had always had six bedrooms, although she had spent an evening choosing it because it slept five. She changed the booking. It cost her forty pounds.


The diary was in the loft at her mum’s, in a box of school things marked PRIYA DO NOT THROW in her dad’s capitals.

She had not gone up for it. She had gone up for her own prom things, some stupid idea about the jacket on the chair. She found the diary instead, a Forever Friends one with a broken lock, Year 9 into Year 10.

September, Year 10: Sat on the bench today!!! Hollie said I could. There’s five of them and now me. Tash lent me her lip gloss. I don’t think Jess minds.

October: Jess doesn’t come to the bench any more. Nobody says anything. It’s like she moved house but she’s still in our form.

November: Asked Meg about Jess. Meg said Jess who. I think she was being mean. I don’t think she was being mean.

Priya sat on the loft boards in the light from the hatch and read it twice.

She did not remember a Jess. She did not remember sitting on the bench for the first time, or asking, or being let. She remembered the bench the way she remembered her own front door, as a thing that had always been there. There had always been five of them. Hollie, Tash, Meg, Sam and Priya.

There’s five of them and now me.


The school had an alumni group on Facebook, mostly reunion adverts and photos of teachers who had died. There was a Jessica Rowe in the member list, in Reading, in a fleece, holding a cat.

It took Priya an hour to write something that did not sound mad.

Hi, this is out of the blue. I was at St Anselm’s 2002 to 2007. Were you ever friends with Hollie Grant, Tash Bell, Meg Doyle and Sam Qureshi? We used to sit on the bench by the science block.

The reply came the next morning.

Hi! Sorry, I think you’ve got the wrong person. I didn’t really have a group at school. I mostly sat in the library. Good luck with your search x

Priya read it at the bus stop, and again on the bus.

Then a second message, a minute after the first.

Funny, someone asked me the same thing years ago. A girl. I never answered her, I thought it was a wind-up.


The cottage was stone, cold and lovely. Elliot arrived last, on the Friday evening, with the spaniel and two bottles of Crémant and a cake he had actually made, and in the doorway he put the bags down and hugged Priya before anyone else.

“Pri,” he said into her hair. “It’s so good to see you.”

He smelled of cold air and dog. He was exactly the man from the photo, bigger than she had pictured, gentle with his hands. She waited to feel something, a door opening, a click. She felt a stranger’s coat against her face.

He was so easy to like. That was the worst of it. He laughed at Sam’s jokes before the end. He knew where Tash liked to sit, and got there second so she could have it. After dinner he did Mr Hendry, the chemistry teacher, the voice and the lean and the hand on the hip, and everyone screamed.

Priya did Mr Hendry. She had done Mr Hendry at every birthday for nineteen years.

“God, E, you’ve still got it,” Hollie said, wiping her eyes.

Then they told the sports day story. Elliot coming across the field with Priya in his arms. The shoes. The card. Priya waited for her own part in it, and it was there, but small. She fainted, she was carried, she was sick. She was the thing that happened to Elliot.

Sam leaned across. “Any of that coming back yet, Pri?”

Everyone looked at her. The fire cracked. Elliot looked at her too, kindly, the way you look at someone at a funeral who has not cried yet.

She could have got the diary out. It was in her bag upstairs. She could have put her phone on the table with the empty chair on it, and read out Jess’s messages, and watched their faces go polite. She knew exactly how it would go. She had been on the other side of it once, in a Forever Friends diary, writing I don’t think she was being mean.

“The card,” Priya said. “I remember the card.”

Elliot’s face opened.

“It had my shoes on it,” he said. “With stink lines.”

“With stink lines,” she said, and everyone laughed, and she could see it. The felt tips spread on her bedroom carpet, the green one running out, the trainers taking shape. They were big trainers. They were not Sam’s. They had never been Sam’s.

She did not know when that had happened. Whether it had been there all along under the other version, or had just arrived, warm and complete, the way a room fills when you open a door. She sat with her glass and the fire on one side of her face and could not find the join.


In the morning Hollie posted the photos in the chat.

The one from dinner was the best. Hollie had propped her phone on the dresser and set the timer, and they had all crammed round the end of the long table. Tash with her eyes shut. Sam mid-word. Meg leaning on Elliot, and Elliot with his arm stretched along the back of the chair beside him.

The chair was empty. Priya’s green parka hung over the back of it.

She had been in that chair. She remembered Hollie saying Pri, squeeze in, and the wood of the seat through her jeans, and Elliot’s arm warm behind her neck.

Nobody commented on the chair. Tash sent hearts. Meg sent crying faces. Elliot wrote: Best weekend in years. Same again next year, all of us x

Priya looked at all of us for a long time. Then she typed same again and a heart, and sent it.

Downstairs she could hear them in the kitchen. Elliot’s laugh, then everyone else’s. The spaniel’s claws on the flagstones. Hollie at the fridge, counting eggs out loud, one each, that’s five, that’s everyone.

Nobody corrected her.

Priya’s message sat under the photograph with two grey ticks. She watched it while the kettle boiled downstairs, and while the pan went on, and while they sat down to eat. The ticks stayed grey.