Bread for Haarlem

By Candlelight Historical horror 11 min

Ghost stories

Before you go in
  • Siege famine and starvation
  • Deliberate withholding of food from the dying
  • Death, mostly off the page

The clerk chalks the number on my door at midnight, and tonight it is forty-one.

Coster does it with his back to me, as if the door were a slate at school. He leaves the flour on the step: one sack, tied at the neck with the town’s red cord, and a smaller bag of pea meal. I weigh the lot before he has reached the corner. The Heeren send a baker exactly enough, and a baker who says otherwise had better be able to prove it.

Forty-one loaves, then. A quarter pound each, if a quarter pound is still the word for what comes out of my oven. Rye flour gone grey with bran. Pea meal. Linseed crushed on Dirck’s old stone until the paste shines. I work until the church bell gives four and my arms are white to the elbow. I count the loaves into the basket twice, touching each one, because the last time I counted only once a woman went home with nothing and did not come back.

At first light I open the hatch.

They are already there, as they are every morning, standing along the Anegang with their backs to the wall where the sun will reach first. Nobody pushes anymore. Pushing costs strength. I hand out a loaf and say the name if I know it, and I know almost all of them.

Forty. Forty-one. The basket is empty.

There is still a man at the hatch.

He is one of Gerrit the cooper’s journeymen, I think, though his face has changed the way all our faces have changed, the skin gone tight over the bone and loose everywhere else. He looks at the empty basket. I start to say something, that I will speak to Coster, that it must be a mistake. He does not wait for it. He nods to me, the way you would nod to someone you pass on a bridge, and walks away up the street.

He does not argue. That is the part I cannot stop turning over while I sleep.


The next night the door says forty.

Somebody has died, then, and I do not ask who. I bake forty. I count them twice. In the morning there are forty-one at the hatch, and the last is a woman from the Begijnhof side with a shawl over her head, and she looks at the empty basket and goes.

I tell myself what anyone would tell herself. I am tired. I am hungry. I sleep in the day with the shutters closed and wake not knowing which bell I heard. A tired woman loses count. I count on my fingers now, under the sill, one finger for each loaf, like a child.

The third morning it is thirty-nine and forty.

The fourth it is thirty-nine again, and forty at the hatch.

When Coster comes at noon for the tally I tell him. He is a small man with good boots, which nobody has anymore, and a ledger he holds against his chest.

“The count is wrong,” I say. “Every day. One more than you chalk.”

“Then your count is wrong.”

“I count twice.”

“Then count three times.” He writes something. “The Heeren give flour for the living, vrouw Pieters. Not for the living and one.”

“Then somebody is coming twice.”

He looks up at that, and for a moment he seems almost interested. “Is that what you think?”

“What else?”

He closes the ledger. “If a loaf goes missing from your basket,” he says, “the Heeren will want to know where. Bakers who sell the town’s bread hang at the Grote Markt. You have seen it.”

I have seen it. In April, a man from the Smedestraat, with his scales hung round his neck.

“I have never sold a crumb.”

“Then there is nothing to worry about.”

He goes. He has not asked me where I keep my own flour, and I am so grateful for that I have to sit down on the step.


I will explain the rye once, and then not again.

When the Heeren took the town’s grain into the church in January, Dirck was a week in the ground, and I gave them his whole store but half a sack. The half sack is under the oven floor, beneath the third tile from the wall, wrapped in oilcloth. It is good rye. I have not touched it. I tell myself I am keeping it for the end, whatever the end is, for the day the Spaniards come over the wall and there is nothing left to share. I tell myself a great many things.

A woman with a sack under her floor does not trust her own count. That is the truth of it.


The fifth morning I set a test.

I keep a dish of soot by the hatch, and as I hand each person a loaf I touch their thumb to it. Nobody asks why. They are too tired to ask, or they think it is some new rule of the Heeren’s.

Thirty-eight loaves. Thirty-nine people.

The last is a boy of perhaps ten. I look at his hands. They are clean. He has had no bread from me, today or any day this week.

So nobody is coming twice. The extra is new every morning, and the extra is always someone I know.

Aefje Claes lives two doors down and has been old for as long as I have been married. She stands in the line every morning with a basket over her arm that she never puts anything in. That afternoon I go and sit with her in her doorway. We share nothing, because neither of us has anything to share.

“Count them with me tomorrow,” I say. “The ones at my hatch. Stand across the street and count.”

“What for?”

“Because I get one more than Coster. Every day.”

Aefje looks at me for a long time. Her eyes have gone milky at the edges.

“You count the told,” she says.

“The what?”

“The told.” She says it as if I had asked her what a spoon was for. “You don’t count them. It isn’t done.”

“Who told them? Told them what?”

She picks at the empty basket. “They know to go last. It’s manners. They don’t make a fuss, and nobody makes a fuss for them.” She puts her hand on my arm. “You work nights. You didn’t see it start.”

“See what start?”

But Aefje has decided the conversation is finished. She asks me, instead, whether I have heard anything from the pigeons.


It is the ninth of July when the pigeon comes down on the church roof, and by the afternoon everyone knows what it carried. The Prince’s army came across from Leiden in the night to break the Spanish camp at the Haarlemmerhout, and the Spaniards were waiting for them, and it is over. There is no army now. There is only the wall.

That night the door says thirty-four.

Four in one night. The bells have stopped ringing for the dead; there is no one spare to pull the ropes. Coster brings less flour than thirty-four needs, and when I say so he shows me the ledger and the Heeren’s seal, and the seal is right, and the flour is what the flour is.

In the morning there are thirty-five at the hatch.

I know now to look at the doors as I walk to the bakehouse before dawn. Most are only doors. On some, low down by the step, where the rain does not reach, there is a small chalk cross. The cooper’s journeyman’s door had one. The boy lives at the end of the Anegang and his door has one. I look at the woman at the back of today’s line and I know without asking that her door has one too.

She waits. I have nothing. She nods and goes.

I have stopped eating my own loaf. I tell no one. I put it under the sill and when the basket is empty I hand it to whoever is last. The first time, the old man I give it to stares at it as if it were a coin I had dropped. Then he takes it and goes quickly, holding it inside his coat.

On the second day of this, Coster is standing across the street when I do it.

He waits until the line has gone. Then he comes over and leans on the hatch.

“That was your own,” he says.

“It was mine to give.”

“Nothing is yours to give.” He says it quite gently. “When you feed the told, you take from the counted. The Heeren’s flour is for those who can still hold a pike on the wall. You understand me? Every loaf that goes to the back of your line is a loaf a man on the Kruispoort does not have.”

“Then who told them?”

“They are told.”

“By whom?”

He looks at the chalk on my door. Thirty-three, in his own neat hand.

“Somebody must decide,” he says. “The Heeren cannot. The Heeren have a town to hold. They give me a number. I give you the number. It is only a number, vrouw Pieters.”

“And the names?”

He does not answer. He does not need to. I have watched him chalk my door every night for seven months, and I know his hand.


That night he is late.

I wait for him in the doorway, and when I hear his boots I step out so that he has to stop. He has the ledger under his arm and the chalk in his fingers. I take the ledger from him. I do not know why he lets me. Perhaps he is too tired to stop anyone doing anything.

I hold it up to the lamp in the bakehouse window.

The Anegang, the Begijnhof side, the lanes to the Spaarne. Names in columns, and the dates beside them, and down the whole of June and July a line through one name every evening, drawn with a ruler. The cooper’s journeyman. The woman in the shawl. The boy, whose name was Wouter. Each one struck the night before I stood at the hatch and watched them go home with nothing.

The last line on the page is fresh. The ink has not sunk into the paper yet.

Griet Pieters, widow, baker, of the Anegang.

“Why?” I say.

Coster takes the ledger back. He closes it carefully, the way I close the oven door.

“Somebody smelled rye in your bakehouse,” he says. “On the morning of the pigeon. Good rye, baked. Not the Heeren’s.”

I baked one small cake from it. One. For Aefje, because she had stopped getting up from her doorway, and I could not look at her. I had forgotten. I truly had.

“A baker who keeps her own flour,” Coster says, “does not need the town’s.”

“So I am told.”

“So you are told.” He looks at the street, where most of the doors are already dark. “Or I can put another name. Nobody reads the names. The Heeren read the number.” He waits. “Aefje Claes is eighty years old, vrouw Pieters. She will not see the Spaniards come in either way.”

I do not answer him. He chalks thirty-two on my door, very neatly, and walks away up the Anegang, and I can hear that he is not hurrying.


The third tile from the wall comes up with the edge of the peel.

The oilcloth has sweated. The rye beneath it is cool and dry and smells the way bread used to smell, the way the whole street smelled on a Saturday before the Spaniards came. It is more than I remembered. Half a sack is a great deal, when you have not looked at it for six months.

I do not measure. I bake until the sack is folded flat on the table. The loaves are too big and too dark and some of them split along the top, and the smell goes out under the door and down the Anegang in the dark, and by the time I open the hatch the whole street is standing there, because the whole street knows.

I give a loaf to everyone. I do not count. I give Aefje two. I give a loaf to a woman whose door has a chalk cross and she stands holding it and weeping, and I give her another, and I keep on until there is no one at the hatch and the basket is empty and the table is empty, and I sit down on the bakehouse floor with my back against the warm oven and my arms white to the elbow.

At noon the Heeren’s men come for the oven. They are polite about it. They seal the door with wax and a cord.


It is the twelfth of July. They say the Heeren are talking with the Spaniards about terms, and nobody believes the terms will be kind, and nobody has the strength to be angry about it.

The bread comes from the Grote Houtstraat now, in a handcart, and Coster hands it out himself from my old hatch. I watched the chalk go up on my door at midnight: thirty, in his neat hand. There is a small cross beneath it, low down by the step.

I take my place along the wall with the others. Nobody pushes. I know every face in the line and I know the order of it now: the counted in front, and the told behind them. There is only one of us told today.

Aefje is halfway down the line with her empty basket. She looks back once, and her milky eyes pass over me the way they pass over the wall, and she turns round again. It isn’t done.

I count them, all the way up to the hatch. I cannot help it. My fingers move against my skirt.

Twenty-nine. Thirty. The cart is empty.

One finger is still raised against the cloth. I look at it for a while. Then I fold it down.

Thirty.

Coster looks at me across the empty cart, and I nod to him, the way you would nod to someone you pass on a bridge, and I do not argue. For the first time in ten days, my count and his are the same.