The Duke Comes in Winter
By Candlelight Historical horror 12 min
Psychological horror Plague and medical horror
Before you go in
- An historical epidemic, and mass death
- People sealed inside a building and left to die, including children
- A parent complicit in it, witnessed by their child
- The dead deliberately erased from a written record
- Memory loss and unstable identity
The first person to see the Duke was old Willem Vos, and by the following morning he had given three different descriptions.
To his wife, he said it had been a young man.
To the baker, he said a woman.
To Hendrik Meijer, who kept the burial register for the parish, Willem said he could not remember.
“Not the face,” Willem muttered. “I remember the coat.”
They stood beside the churchyard wall where the snow had hardened into grey ridges. Willem’s sheep had left thin tracks along the road, but there were no other footprints.
“What kind of coat?”
“Yellow.”
Hendrik looked at him.
“Yellow?”
“Mustard. Or gold.”
“You said black yesterday.”
“I said no such thing.”
“You told your wife the stranger wore black.”
Willem stared at the church. The bell hung still above them.
“I don’t remember saying that.”
Hendrik closed his notebook.
“Then there is nothing to write down.”
Willem caught his wrist. His hand was surprisingly strong.
“There is.”
“What?”
“He asked me how many.”
Hendrik waited.
“How many what?”
Willem’s fingers loosened.
“I don’t know.”
The winter of 1716 had sealed the village of Roodeveen beneath ice.
The canal froze first. Then the marsh. Then the shallow wells behind the eastern houses. By January, the road toward Utrecht had disappeared beneath snow so smooth that from the church tower it seemed the village had been cut from the country around it.
There were eighty-seven people in Roodeveen.
Hendrik knew because he counted them.
He counted births. He counted marriages. He counted deaths.
Names entered his register in black ink, one beneath another, each given a date and a cause where one could reasonably be named.
Consumption. Fever. Childbed. Accident. Old age.
Hendrik trusted numbers because numbers did not remember incorrectly.
People did. People changed things. Numbers remained where they had been placed.
His father had taught him that.
His father had been dead sixteen years.
On the second day, three children saw the Duke standing on the frozen canal.
They came running into the square before noon, shouting over one another.
“He has red hair.”
“She doesn’t have hair.”
“His face is burned.”
“You’re lying.”
“Am not.”
Hendrik caught the oldest by the shoulders.
“One at a time.”
The boy, Pieter, swallowed.
“There was someone on the canal.”
“Doing what?”
“Standing.”
“Where?”
“By the old storehouse.”
That silenced the adults nearby.
Hendrik felt it before he understood it, a small tightening in his stomach.
The old storehouse had not been used since he was a child. Its roof had partially collapsed. One wall leaned toward the canal. The doors had been sealed with iron nails years ago.
“Did this person speak to you?”
Pieter nodded.
“What did they say?”
The boy glanced at the other children.
“He asked which house you lived in.”
Hendrik’s grip tightened.
“Me?”
“He said the man who writes the dead.”
Someone behind Hendrik laughed nervously.
Hendrik turned. No one admitted to it.
“Anything else?”
Pieter nodded again.
“He said you counted wrong.”
Hendrik went to the storehouse that afternoon.
He told no one.
The snow reached halfway to his knees on the old path. Wind moved through the reeds beside the canal with a dry scratching sound.
He had not stood this close to the building in years.
As a boy, he had thought it enormous.
Now it seemed small.
That disturbed him more.
The timber had blackened with age. Snow had gathered inside the holes in the roof. The double doors remained shut beneath a rusted chain.
Hendrik examined the ground.
No footprints.
He almost laughed.
Children lied. Willem drank. Nothing had happened.
Then someone knocked from inside the storehouse.
Three times.
Hendrik did not move.
There was a pause.
Three more knocks.
He stepped backwards.
The final knock came alone.
Hendrik stared at the doors.
“Who’s there?”
Nothing.
He waited.
The wind moved through the reeds.
“Who’s inside?”
A voice answered from directly behind him.
“Nobody.”
Hendrik turned so violently that he slipped.
A person stood perhaps fifteen paces away.
Hendrik would later remember a man. He would be certain of it.
Tall, perhaps thirty years old, pale from the cold, wearing a dark green coat with brass buttons. No hat. No gloves.
But when Hendrik tried to remember the face, he could only remember individual pieces.
A narrow nose. Dark eyes. Pale lips.
Not how they fitted together.
The stranger looked at the storehouse.
“Nobody is inside anymore.”
Hendrik got to his feet.
“Who are you?”
“You know.”
“I do not.”
The stranger smiled.
Not pleasantly. Not cruelly either.
It looked like the sort of smile one gave to someone who had made an obvious mistake.
“The children call you the Duke,” Hendrik said.
“Do they?”
“Why?”
“I haven’t asked them.”
“What do you want?”
The stranger looked toward him.
“To count.”
Hendrik felt cold beneath his clothes now.
“Count what?”
“The dead.”
“I keep the parish register.”
“I know.”
“Then you know the number.”
“Do I?”
Hendrik said nothing.
The stranger walked toward the storehouse.
There were still no footprints.
Hendrik saw that clearly. He saw boots touching snow. He saw weight pressing down. But when each foot lifted, the surface beneath it remained smooth.
Hendrik stepped back.
The stranger stopped at the chained doors.
“How many died here?”
“None.”
The answer came too quickly.
The stranger touched one of the iron nails.
“None?”
“This was a grain store.”
“Was it?”
“Yes.”
“Then why did your father nail people inside it?”
Hendrik could not breathe.
The stranger turned.
For one second, Hendrik thought the face belonged to his father.
Then it did not.
“Who told you that?”
The Duke smiled again.
“You did.”
Hendrik ran.
He did not remember returning to the village. He remembered entering his house. He remembered locking the door. He remembered standing with both hands against it while his wife, Anna, asked what had happened.
“Nothing.”
“You look ill.”
“I’m fine.”
“You are shaking.”
“It’s cold.”
She watched him.
Anna had known him for nineteen years. She knew when he lied.
She did not press him.
That was worse.
At supper, their daughter spoke about the stranger.
Sara was fourteen and had seen the Duke near the mill.
Hendrik dropped his spoon.
“You spoke to him?”
“Her.”
Anna looked up.
“Her?”
Sara nodded.
“She was old.”
Hendrik stared at his daughter.
“How old?”
“I don’t know. Sixty.”
“Hair?”
“Grey.”
“Coat?”
“Blue.”
Hendrik stood.
Sara flinched.
“Did she speak to you?”
“Papa.”
“Did she?”
“Yes.”
“What did she say?”
Sara looked at Anna. Then back at him.
“She asked if you ever told me about the winter people.”
The room went silent.
Anna’s expression changed.
“What winter people?”
Hendrik sat slowly.
“No one.”
Sara frowned.
“She said there were twenty-three.”
The spoon slipped from Hendrik’s fingers.
Anna looked at him.
“Hendrik?”
“There were not twenty-three.”
He stopped.
His wife said nothing.
Hendrik could hear the kitchen fire. He could hear Sara breathing.
Anna’s voice became very quiet.
“Twenty-three what?”
Hendrik looked at the table.
“Nothing.”
He was eleven years old again.
The fever had arrived in February.
Travellers first.
Eleven families, moving west after work had failed farther inland. They had wagons, children, bundles of blankets, two sick men.
Roodeveen refused them lodging.
Hendrik remembered his father standing in the square.
Just for the night, the travellers had begged.
There are children. It will freeze.
Hendrik’s father had spoken with the pastor. Then with the miller. Then with six other men.
The storehouse was empty. They could sleep there. Until morning.
Hendrik remembered carrying a bucket of water to them.
A woman had thanked him. Her daughter had been younger than Sara.
By morning, one traveller had died.
By evening, another was coughing blood.
The village panicked.
Someone said fever. Someone else said plague.
Hendrik’s father ordered the doors closed.
Only for one day.
Then two.
Then five.
Food was pushed through a gap in the wall.
The sick screamed. Then the healthy screamed.
Hendrik remembered hands reaching beneath the door.
He remembered his father hammering another plank across it.
There had been twenty-three.
Hendrik had always known that.
They remained inside for eleven days.
When the doors were finally opened, nine were alive.
The parish register listed six deaths that month.
Not fourteen.
Six.
Hendrik’s father had explained it years later.
They were not parishioners. There were no family names. No records. No priest had known them.
Numbers mattered only when one could prove them.
Six had died of fever.
Eight had simply never arrived.
Hendrik had copied his father’s register when he took over the position.
Six deaths.
Not fourteen.
At midnight, the church bell rang.
Once.
Hendrik woke.
Anna turned beside him.
“What was that?”
He sat up.
The bell rang again.
“Stay here.”
A third time.
Hendrik dressed.
By the sixth ring, people were opening their doors.
By the eighth, half the village stood in the square.
No one climbed the bell tower.
Hendrik knew because he could see the stairs through the open church doors.
Nine. Ten. Eleven.
Someone began praying.
Twelve. Thirteen.
Hendrik whispered, “Stop.”
Fourteen.
The bell went silent.
Nobody moved.
Willem Vos looked at Hendrik.
“How many?”
Hendrik said nothing.
Willem stepped closer.
“How many died in that storehouse?”
“You were there.”
“I was twelve.”
“So was nearly everyone.”
“How many?”
Hendrik looked around the square.
Faces he had known his entire life. The baker. The miller’s widow. Pastor De Wit. His own wife.
Some knew. Some suspected. Some had been children. Others had been told never to ask.
“Fourteen,” Hendrik said.
The pastor shook his head.
“No.”
Hendrik looked at him.
“You know.”
“Your father told us six.”
“My father lied.”
The pastor’s face hardened.
“Careful.”
“Fourteen died.”
Willem whispered, “And nine survived.”
Hendrik turned toward him.
Willem was crying.
“I saw them leave,” the old man said. “After.”
“You never told me.”
“They didn’t leave.”
Hendrik felt the square tilt beneath him.
“What?”
Willem covered his mouth.
“The men took them back inside.”
No one spoke.
Hendrik heard Anna behind him.
“Who?”
Willem looked toward the older villagers.
“The ones who survived were sick.”
Hendrik stared at him.
“No.”
“Your father said if they left, they would tell people.”
“No.”
“They were weak.”
“Willem.”
“I saw the cart.”
Hendrik grabbed his coat.
“You said nine walked away.”
“That is what your father told everyone.”
“Where are they?”
Willem began shaking.
“Under it.”
The church bell rang again.
Everyone screamed.
They tore open the storehouse before dawn.
The chain broke easily.
The doors did not.
Six men pulled until the old timber cracked and the hinges came loose from the wall.
The smell inside was only damp wood and rot.
Nothing waited for them.
No bodies. No stranger.
Just broken barrels, straw, and collapsed beams.
Hendrik almost wept with relief.
Then Sara said, “There.”
At the rear wall lay an iron ring.
Hendrik remembered it.
He had forgotten it for thirty years.
A trapdoor.
The men lifted it.
Beneath was a shallow storage pit.
Bones lay inside.
Nine skulls.
Anna turned away.
Someone vomited.
Hendrik stared down.
There were small bones among them.
One skull belonged to a child.
The pastor whispered something about burial.
Hendrik barely heard him.
On the wall above the pit, someone had scratched words into the timber.
Most had faded.
One sentence remained readable.
HE SAID YOU WOULD COME BACK.
Hendrik stepped closer.
“Who wrote this?”
No one answered.
Then Sara spoke.
“Papa.”
He turned.
The Duke stood outside.
Except this was not the person Hendrik had met.
This was a child.
Perhaps eight years old.
Barefoot in the snow.
White clothing.
Black hair cut unevenly across the forehead.
Hendrik looked at Sara.
“Do you see that?”
Sara’s face had gone pale.
“See what?”
“The child.”
“What child?”
Hendrik turned back.
The Duke remained there.
Smiling.
Hendrik walked outside.
“Who are you?”
The child tilted its head.
“Why do you keep asking?”
“What do you want?”
“You know.”
“No.”
“Count.”
“We counted.”
“Did you?”
“Twenty-three came. Fourteen died. Nine were killed.”
The child smiled.
“That’s twenty-three.”
“Yes.”
“No.”
Hendrik felt his stomach drop.
The Duke looked past him. Into the storehouse.
“Count again.”
Hendrik did not want to.
He went back to the pit.
Nine skulls.
He counted twice.
Nine.
Then the bones from the first deaths. They had been moved years ago to the churchyard.
Fourteen dead in the first eleven days.
Nine afterward.
Twenty-three.
All of them.
Hendrik closed his eyes.
“No one left.”
Behind him, the child said:
“Then who told you what happened inside?”
Hendrik opened his eyes.
No one moved.
Willem stared at him. The pastor stared at him. Anna stared at him.
And something old shifted inside Hendrik’s memory.
A woman.
The first night.
Thanking him for the water.
Her little girl beside her.
Then another memory.
Later.
After the doors had been opened.
Someone holding his hand.
Running through snow.
His father’s voice behind them.
Hendrik had always remembered watching from the village road.
But suddenly he remembered looking back.
From the canal.
Toward Roodeveen.
His hand inside the hand of someone he did not know.
He remembered his father shouting his name.
He remembered hiding beneath blankets.
He remembered returning three days later.
Or perhaps he did not.
Hendrik touched his face.
Anna came closer.
“Hendrik?”
He stared at her.
“How old was I?”
“What?”
“When the fever came.”
“You said eleven.”
“How do you know?”
“You told me.”
“Who told me?”
Anna looked confused.
“My father.”
Hendrik turned to Willem.
“You knew me before.”
Willem stepped backwards.
“Of course.”
“Did you?”
“Hendrik.”
“Did you?”
Willem began crying again.
“I don’t know.”
Hendrik looked toward the Duke.
The child was gone.
In its place stood an enormous man at the end of the road.
Bareheaded.
A white beard down to his chest.
A red military coat.
One hand resting on a walking stick.
Hendrik blinked.
Now it was a woman.
Then someone too far away to identify.
Then nobody.
Three knocks sounded from inside the storehouse.
Everyone heard them.
Three more.
Anna took Hendrik’s hand.
One final knock.
Hendrik looked down at their joined fingers.
His wife’s hand felt familiar.
His own did not.
That spring, Roodeveen buried twenty-three sets of remains.
Hendrik entered every name he could recover into the parish register.
For those without names, he left blank spaces.
He resigned his position shortly afterward.
The final entry in his handwriting was not a death.
It had no date.
No cause.
Only a sentence written across the bottom of the page.
There were eighty-seven people in Roodeveen before the Duke came.
Beneath it:
There are eighty-seven now.
Someone later crossed out the second sentence.
No one knows who.
The burial register survives.
So does a letter written by Pastor De Wit several weeks later in which he describes the events of that winter.
The pastor never mentions a child.
He never mentions a man in a green coat.
According to him, the stranger who came to Roodeveen was a very tall woman dressed entirely in white.
Willem Vos, questioned years afterward, insisted there had never been a stranger at all.
Anna Meijer wrote that she saw a small grey dog waiting outside the storehouse each morning.
Sara Meijer refused to discuss Roodeveen for the rest of her life.
Hendrik left no account.
His name appears once more in the parish records.
Not in Roodeveen.
In a village almost eighty kilometres south.
A baptism.
Seven years earlier.
The child was called Hendrik.
The parents’ names are unknown.
Beside the entry, in different ink, someone later wrote two words.
The Duke.