Headcount

By Streetlight Folk horror 14 min

Psychological horror Folk horror Sea horror

Before you go in
  • Drowning, including a death recalled from the past
  • Hypothermia and dangerous cold-water exposure

Liesbeth had counted heads for fifteen years, on school trips and at swimming pools and once, memorably, in the Rijksmuseum, and she had never once come back with more children than she had brought.

At the quarry she came up with one more every morning.

The first time, it was nine brass tags on the board and ten heads in the water. She stood waist deep on the shelf of gravel below the jetty, breathing the way Hanneke had taught her, short and hard through the mouth while the cold closed around her ribs like a hand, and she counted the way she always counted, left to right, lips moving. Hanneke’s white cap. The two sisters in orange. Kees, bald and pink, already far out. Gerda doing her slow grandmother breaststroke with her chin held high. Ten.

She counted again. Ten.

The sun was not up. The water was the colour of a slate roof and the far bank was a line of alders with mist lying in them. The tenth head was out past Kees, where the quarry floor dropped away to the old pit face, and it was not moving. Not treading water. Just there, dark and smooth, the way a seal’s head sits in a harbour.

“Hanneke,” she said. “Is someone swimming from the other side?”

Hanneke turned in the water and looked at her, and then did not look where Liesbeth was pointing.

“Count the board, love,” she said. “Not the water. Come on, in you go, or you’ll never go.”


The board was the first thing you saw in the clubhouse. It hung by the door, a long plank of black wood with forty iron hooks screwed into it in five rows, and it had come from the lamp room when the quarry closed in 1971. Every member had a brass tag with a number stamped through it. You hung your tag before you went in and took it off when you came out. A tag left on the hook meant a body in the water. It was the most sensible thing Liesbeth had seen in a long time, and she had said so on her first morning, and the sisters had laughed and said she sounded like a teacher.

There was one tag with no number. It had no hook of its own either. It hung from a nail at the end of the top row, and every morning Hanneke unlocked the clubhouse, put the kettle on, and hung that disc on its nail before anyone else hung theirs.

“Whose is that?” Liesbeth asked, the second week.

“The quarry’s,” Hanneke said, as though she had asked whose the kettle was.

Liesbeth waited for the joke. Kees was pouring coffee into the thermos cups and he did not look up.

She was forty-one and new in town, and she had learned in the staff room that the fastest way to stay new was to ask questions with the wrong tone. So she laughed, and hung tag nineteen, and went down the jetty in her dryrobe with the frost creaking under her feet.

Ten heads. Nine tags, and one disc with no number.

She told herself it was the cold. Everyone said the cold did things to you in the first month: your eyes watered, your hands went stupid, you forgot your own address in the car. The water was six degrees in November and falling. She told herself it was a buoy, left from some diving club, though she could never find it when the light came up. She told herself it was a local from the estate beyond the alders who liked to swim alone and did not want to pay the thirty euros, and that was the explanation she liked best, because it had a person in it.

On the Saturday she did not swim. She had a cold, a real one, and she stood on the jetty with her phone and took a photograph while they were all out.

Nine tags on the board. She counted ten in the water.

The photograph showed nine. She zoomed in until the heads were grey smudges, and there were nine of them, and past Kees there was only a ring on the water, spreading, as if something had just gone under.


She learned about last out without anyone explaining it.

It was the end of the swim, the light up, the sisters already in the clubhouse shrieking about their feet. Gerda climbed the ladder. Hanneke climbed the ladder. Liesbeth came out behind them, her skin scarlet and burning, and took her tag off the board, and when she came back out with the thermos, Kees was still in the water.

He was not swimming. He was floating on his back near the end of the jetty, arms out, looking at the sky. The others stood on the boards in their robes with towels over their arms, and none of them called to him. They were watching the water past him. Liesbeth counted. Kees, and one.

“He’ll get hypothermia,” she said.

“Shh,” said Gerda.

They waited. Liesbeth counted the minutes because she could not help it. Four. Six. Kees’s lips went from pink to grey. At eight minutes his breathing changed, and Hanneke’s hand tightened on the towel until her knuckles went white. At nine minutes the tenth head went under. There was no splash. It lowered, the way a lift lowers, and the water closed over it and was flat.

Kees swam to the ladder. Hanneke and Gerda hauled him up by the arms, got the towels on him, walked him to the clubhouse between them like a drunk. Inside, Hanneke took the unnumbered disc off its nail and put it in her pocket, and said, “Out,” to nobody.

Liesbeth said, “What was that?”

“Kees likes a float,” said one of the sisters, and gave her a biscuit.


On the first of December she was slow. She had been up marking until two, and she was the last one along the jetty and the last one in, and for once nobody swam beside her. She went along the east wall where the alders hung over, further than she meant to, because her body felt warm in the cold, loose and strange. When she turned, the others were small at the ladder, and Kees was floating at the end of the jetty with his arms out.

She swam back slowly. By the time she reached the shelf, Kees was climbing out and the jetty was empty, and she heard, from the clubhouse, Hanneke’s voice say, “Out.”

The water behind her made a small sound. Not a splash. The sound of something surfacing.

She did not look. She was cold and late for school and she had not understood a word of any of it yet. She went up the ladder, took tag nineteen off its hook, and was in the car with the heater roaring when she heard Hanneke shouting her name on the jetty. She thought something had been left behind, a glove, a sock. She drove away.

That night she ran a bath.

She ran it hot and got in with a glass of wine and her marking on the closed lid of the toilet, and she lay back and closed her eyes. When she opened them the water had gone grey. Not dirty. Grey in the way the quarry was grey, with a fine silt moving in it that had not come from her. It was cold. She had run it hot and it was cold, and it was cold from the bottom up, from under her, and something in the grey water brushed along the back of her calf, slow, the way a hand brushes past you in a crowd.

She got out so fast she broke the glass.

She sat on the bathroom floor in a towel for an hour with every light on. When she finally pulled the plug, the water went down with a sound she had never heard a drain make, a long swallow, and left a line of grit around the tub like a tide mark.

She did not sleep. She lay with the bathroom door shut and the chair against it, and at four in the morning she could hear the pipes behind the wall, full and ticking, as if water was waiting in them.

At half past six she was at the quarry. Hanneke was on the jetty in the dark, alone, with her arms folded. She did not say good morning.

“Your tag was still on the board,” she said. “I said out, and you were still in. It came back up for you, and you came out with it still up.”

“I don’t know what that means.”

“No.” Hanneke looked at her. “That’s my fault. I should have told you. Somebody should have been beside you.” She turned toward the clubhouse. “He’s going in now. It comes back to the water if there’s someone in the water to come back to. He’ll stay until it’s done. You’ll stand here and watch him do it, because you owe him that.”

Kees went in at a quarter to seven. Liesbeth stood with the towels. The tenth head was not out past the pit face this time. It was close to the jetty, closer than she had ever seen it, directly below where she stood.

It did not go down at nine minutes. It did not go down at fifteen. At nineteen minutes Kees stopped answering when Gerda called to him. At twenty-two it went under, and they had to go in after him, the three women, up to their chests, and drag him to the ladder by his arms. His skin was the colour of candle wax. The ambulance came down the gravel track with its lights on and no siren.

At the clubhouse door, Hanneke took the unnumbered disc off its nail and held it in her fist.

“Out,” she said, and her voice broke on it.


Gerda told her. Not Hanneke. Gerda asked her to come to the clubhouse on the Wednesday afternoon, when nobody swam, and heated pea soup on the two-ring stove and put a bowl in front of her and waited until she had eaten some.

“My brother Jan swam here,” Gerda said. “Everyone did, then. It wasn’t a club. It was just the Put. Kids from the estate, men after work. You’d swim across and back and go home.”

“And someone drowned.”

“People always drowned in quarries. Cold water, deep water, old machinery down there. That’s what the papers said.” Gerda turned her spoon over. “Jan didn’t drown here. Jan drowned in his bed. February 1986. My mother found him in the morning, with his hair wet and his mouth full of grit. The pathologist said water in the lungs. He said it was quarry water, he could tell by the silt, and he couldn’t say how. The bed was dry.”

Liesbeth put her spoon down.

“He’d gone swimming alone that morning,” Gerda said. “Before work. That’s all. He was the last one out because he was the only one in.”

“How many?”

“Seven, that we knew of. Over twenty years. Always winter. Always someone who’d swum alone, or stayed in late, or got out last. Always at home.” She looked at the board. “After Jan, some of us started coming together. We hung tags because the old men from the quarry said that was how you kept count, down there. The count had to come out right. And someone always stayed in until it went down.”

“Kees.”

“Kees for eleven years. Hanneke for fourteen before that. Me for six, before my heart.” Gerda smiled a little. “It goes down quick for a stranger. A minute, two. It doesn’t know you, so it loses interest. But it learns you. Every winter it stays up a bit longer for the ones it knows. That’s the trouble.”

Liesbeth heard it and did not want to understand it, and understood it.

She thought of Hanneke at the school gate in September, collecting her grandson from Liesbeth’s class. The first week. You’re the new teacher. You look like a swimmer. She thought of the sisters, the biscuits, the teasing, the way they always swam around her on the way out, one on each side and Kees ahead. We keep the new ones in the middle. She had thought that was kindness. It had been kindness. It had also been them keeping her where the tenth head could get a good look at her, and see a stranger.

“You needed someone it didn’t know,” she said.

Gerda did not deny it. She reached across the table and put her old dry hand on Liesbeth’s wrist.

“We needed someone,” she said. “That’s not the same as not wanting you.”


She told Hanneke no.

She said it in the car park on the Friday, with the engine running, the window down four inches. She said she was sorry about Kees. She said she would not be coming on Sunday for the solstice swim, or any swim, and that they should close the quarry, fence it, tell someone.

“Tell who?” Hanneke said.

“The council. The police. I don’t know.”

“And say what?”

Liesbeth had no answer. Hanneke nodded as if she had expected none.

“The solstice is the longest night,” she said. “It’s always worst after the longest night. It comes up closer. It stays up longer. The new one does last out that morning, that’s how it’s always been done, because it’s the one morning a stranger matters most.” She stepped back from the car. “Kees is still in the hospital. So I’ll do it. Don’t worry. I’ve done it before.”

Liesbeth drove away. She did not sleep on Saturday night. At four in the morning she was listening to the pipes. At six she was in the car.


It was not yet light when she got there. The frost on the jetty had been broken by footprints, and there were eight tags on the board and a disc on its nail. Everyone was already out, huddled on the boards in their robes, and nobody turned when she came down the path, because they were all looking at the water.

Hanneke was floating at the end of the jetty with her white cap and her arms out.

The tenth head was a metre from her.

“How long?” Liesbeth said.

“Sixteen minutes,” said one of the sisters. She was crying.

Hanneke’s face was not pink. It was not grey. It had gone past grey into a kind of yellow, and her mouth was open and her eyes were half closed, and she was drifting, very slowly, toward the thing beside her, the way a boat drifts toward a quay.

“Pull her out,” Liesbeth said.

“If we pull her out with it up,” Gerda said, “it goes home with her.”

“She’ll die in the water.”

“Yes,” said Gerda. “Or in her bed.”

Liesbeth looked at the tenth head. From here she could see it was not a seal, and not a buoy, and not a swimmer from the estate. She could not see a face. It was turned toward Hanneke, and it had been turned toward Hanneke for fourteen years.

She took her coat off. She did not take anything else off. She went down the ladder in her jeans and her jumper, and the cold hit her so hard she forgot to breathe, and then she remembered, short and hard through the mouth, the way she had been taught. She swam out. It was twenty metres. Her clothes were full of water and dragged at her like hands. She put herself between Hanneke and the head and trod water there, facing it.

It turned.

It was very close. There was a face, she would think later, though she would never be able to say whose, or what age, or whether it had been a man or a woman. It was the colour of the water. The eyes were open under the surface film, and they looked at her the way people look at someone new on a train, with no interest at all, no recognition, a flat and patient nothing.

Behind her, the sisters had Hanneke by the arms.

The face looked at Liesbeth for a long time. It might have been a minute. She counted, out of habit, and lost count at forty, because her jaw was shaking too hard to move her lips.

Then it lowered, the way a lift lowers, and the water closed over it, and was flat.

She swam back. They pulled her up the ladder. Somebody put a robe on her, somebody put a cup of something into her hands, and Hanneke was on the boards wrapped in four towels with Gerda rubbing her feet, and Hanneke was alive, and looking at her.

In the clubhouse, Liesbeth took the unnumbered disc off its nail. It was cold and heavier than it looked.

“Out,” she said.


In January they painted her name on the wall, in white, under Kees’s. There was a small party. Kees came, thinner, with a stick. He shook her hand for a long time and did not say anything, and she understood that he would not be going in again.

She did last out every morning after that. She told herself she would stop at the end of the season.

The rule was that you did not count. You counted the board, not the water. But Liesbeth had counted things her whole life, and she kept a notebook in the glovebox, and on the drive home each morning she wrote down how long it had taken to go down. She did not show anyone.

One minute fifty. Two minutes ten. Two ten. Two forty. Three minutes. Three thirty.

In the second week of February she took her class to the swimming baths in town, as she did every year: twenty-six children on a coach with their towels rolled under their arms. The pool was bright and warm and smelled of chlorine, and nothing in it had ever been cold.

She counted them in the shallow end, left to right, lips moving, the way she always had.

Twenty-seven.

She counted again. The twenty-seventh was at the deep end, by the steps, not splashing, not moving. Just there, dark and smooth, the way a seal’s head sits in a harbour. Turned toward her, the way it had been turned toward Hanneke.

The swimming instructor blew the whistle. The children went up the steps in a shrieking line and out to the changing rooms, and their teacher, who never went in with them, took off her shoes and her socks and walked down the steps in her clothes into the warm water, and stood in it up to her waist, and did not look at the deep end, and began, with her lips moving, to count the minutes.