Episode Nine
By Streetlight Psychological thriller 11 min
Psychological thrillers Technology horror
Before you go in
- The murder of a teenage girl, discussed but not shown
- A suicide, referred to
- Public accusation and online harassment
- Alcohol and memory loss
The tips always came in between two and four in the morning, and Mo had learned to read them the way you read a stranger’s face on a night bus: quickly, for the one thing that is wrong.
Most were nothing. A psychic in Leeds. A man who knew it was the vicar. A woman who had dreamed about the dyke. He read them standing up in the kitchen with the fridge door open, because the fridge light was the only one that did not wake the neighbours, and he deleted them, and he went back to bed.
This one came in at 02:40 on Tuesday, from an address that was just numbers.
Episode nine. Here’s your tip.
You left the Anchor at 23:10 on 14 November 2009. Five minutes after she did. You told your listeners you walked home. You didn’t. Your brother’s car was outside the pub and it wasn’t outside at midnight.
Your phone went quiet at 23:37. It came back at 01:14. Ninety-seven minutes nobody can account for.
The Shell on the ring road is eleven minutes from the Anchor by car. The Fen Road dyke is six minutes past it.
Run it Thursday, or at six on Thursday morning it goes to the Lincolnshire Echo and the Mail.
He laughed, once, at the fridge. It was a good one. It had the rhythm. Somebody had been listening properly.
Then he read it again, and stopped laughing at your brother’s car, because he had never said a word about Samir’s car to anyone, on air or off it, in seventeen years.
Low Tide had done eight episodes and four hundred thousand listeners on the death of Kerry Lowe, seventeen, who walked out of the Anchor in Holmfleet at five past eleven on a Saturday night in November 2009 and was found five days later face down in a drainage dyke off the Fen Road. Nobody had ever been charged. Mo had grown up two streets from her. That was the hook. He said it in the first minute of episode one, in the voice Jas called his confessional voice: I was there that night. I was in the pub. I didn’t know her well. I walked home, like everyone did.
Episode nine was due to drop at six on Thursday. It was meant to be the finale. It was meant to be a careful, sorrowful summing up, with a long section about Dean Kirwan.
He sat on the edge of the bed with his laptop and opened his old Twitter account for the first time in a decade.
@mohaddad_ 14 Nov 2009 23:37 last orders, heading off x
@mohaddad_ 15 Nov 2009 01:14 cant sleep. what a night
He had walked home. He knew he had walked home. It was two miles, he had been nineteen and drunk on snakebite, he remembered being sick in the bus shelter on Marsh Lane. Ninety-seven minutes was not strange for two miles drunk. Ninety-seven minutes was a normal night.
He wrote that down, in the notebook he used for episodes, as if it were a fact about someone else. Walked. Sick, Marsh Lane. 97 mins plausible.
Then he looked at the words your brother’s car for a long time.
Jas rang at eight, because he had forwarded it to her at three.
“Is it true?”
“I walked home.”
“Then it’s a troll. A clever one.” He could hear her typing. “Mo, it’s actually good, though. Structurally. Could we use it?”
“Use it how?”
“Read it out. Show people how easy it is. You take anyone’s night and you lay it over the case and it fits. It’s a whole episode about method.” She stopped typing. “Unless it’s true.”
“It isn’t true.”
“Then we’re fine. Sleep on it. The ad reads are locked for Thursday, so whatever we do, we do it by Wednesday night.”
He rang Samir at lunchtime. His brother was at work, somewhere loud, a warehouse, and he had to shout.
“November ’09? The Kerry Lowe night? You’re asking me now?”
“I’m checking something for the show.”
A long pause, full of forklift alarms.
“You had the car,” Samir said.
“I walked home.”
“You had my car, Mo. You begged me for it. You said you’d drive back from the Anchor and pick me up from Leanne’s at midnight, and you never came, and I walked four miles in the rain. I put it on Facebook, I was that angry. You’d left it on the drive with the seat right back and a full tank. I always remembered the tank, because you never filled it in your life.”
Mo sat very still at his desk.
“Why are you asking me this?” Samir said. His voice had changed. “Mo. Why are you asking?”
“No reason.”
“You fancied her,” Samir said. “Kerry. For years. You told everyone you didn’t know her well. You said it on the podcast, I heard you. Why would you say that?”
Mo ended the call.
He found Samir’s Facebook post on the second try. It was still public. 15 Nov 2009, 01:02. walked 4 miles in the pissing rain cos my idiot brother didnt show. never lending him the corsa again.
Dark blue Corsa. He could see it now, the way you see a thing once someone has named it. The dent in the passenger door. The air freshener shaped like a pine tree.
He could not see himself in it.
He drove to Holmfleet at five on Wednesday morning, before he could decide not to.
His mother was asleep. He let himself in with the key under the pot and went up the loft ladder with his phone torch in his teeth. The boxes were where they had always been, labelled in her careful capitals. MOHAMMED, SCHOOL. MOHAMMED, 2008 TO 2010.
In the second box, under a sixth form jumper and a stack of CDs, was his old wallet. Brown, cracked, the one he had lost interest in and never thrown away. Inside it, a provisional licence with his nineteen-year-old face, a Blockbuster card, four pounds in coins, and a thermal receipt folded in half, gone pale almost to nothing.
He unfolded it in the torchlight.
SHELL FEN ROAD SERVICES 15/11/09 00:52 UNLEADED 16.39L £20.00 CASH
He knew that time. Everyone who had listened to Low Tide knew that time. He had built most of an episode on it.
From the transcript of Low Tide, episode four, The Ninety Minutes:
At 00:52, a young man with dark hair buys twenty pounds of petrol, in cash, at the Shell on the ring road. The cashier says he kept his head down. He never looked at her once. She says he was driving a dark hatchback, maybe a Corsa. Now. Dean Kirwan drove a black Corsa. Dean Kirwan left the Anchor at twenty past eleven and his mum says he was home at quarter past one. That’s ninety minutes nobody can account for. I’m not saying anything. I’m just telling you what’s in the file.
He had said Dean’s name forty-one times in that episode. Jas had counted, afterwards, when the Kirwans’ solicitor wrote. Dean had lost his job at the port. His wife had taken the children to her mother’s. Eighteen months after episode four went out, Dean Kirwan had been found in his car on the sea wall with the engine running, and Mo had done a short, sorrowful update about it, in the confessional voice, and the downloads had gone up.
He sat on the loft boards with the receipt in his hand.
The young man with dark hair at the Shell had never been Dean.
He waited for a memory. The forecourt lights. The cashier. Twenty pounds in his hand, his head down. Why would he keep his head down? Why would he fill the tank? He sat there until his legs went numb, and nothing came, only the bus shelter on Marsh Lane, the sick, the cold, walking, which he now understood he might have borrowed from some other night entirely because it was the kind of thing that happened on nights like that.
He replied to the email from the car, in his mother’s street, with the engine off.
Who are you?
The answer came in four minutes.
You know my name. You said my son’s forty-one times.
Pauline Kirwan picked up on the first ring, as if she had been sitting beside the phone. She had a smoker’s voice and a Holmfleet accent he had spent years sanding out of his own.
“I didn’t say you did anything,” she said. “I want you to understand that. I haven’t said you did anything at all.”
“Then what is it?”
“It’s your method, love. I listened to all eight. Twice. I took notes. You say you walked home, on your own programme, so that’s on the record. Your little tweets are on the record. Your Samir put it all over Facebook about his car. The garage is in the file. I just laid it all out the way you do.” She drew on a cigarette. “It fits, doesn’t it? It fits you better than it ever fitted Dean. I’m not saying anything. I’m just telling you what’s in the file.”
He almost told her about the receipt. It was in his jacket pocket. He could feel the fold of it against his chest.
“What do you want?”
“I want you to read it out. My tip. On your finale. I want four hundred thousand people to hear how easy it is. And I want you to say his name one more time, properly, and say you were wrong.” A pause. “Or I send it to the papers and they do it for you, and they won’t be as kind as I am.”
“And if I do it?”
“Then I’m done with you,” she said. “That’s all I want. I’m tired, Mohammed. I just want to be done.”
She did not know. He understood that with total clarity, sitting in the car. She had built it out of his own words and guessed at the rest, the way he had with Dean, and she had guessed right about the one thing that mattered, and she did not know it.
He recorded at eleven on Wednesday night, in the cupboard under the stairs he had lined with foam.
He did the first version in one take. It was very good. He read Pauline’s tip in full. He walked his listeners through it, step by step, and showed them how each piece was true and how none of them proved anything, how you could take any young man’s night and lay it over a dead girl and make it fit. He said Dean Kirwan’s name, and said he had been wrong, and said sorry to Pauline, and his voice cracked in the right place. It was brave. It was the most honest thing he had ever made.
He played it back with his headphones on and his eyes closed.
It was exactly as honest as episode four. Every sentence in it was true. It just left one thing out, and the thing it left out was in his jacket pocket, and he knew precisely how the silence around it would sound to a listener who did not know, because he had built a career on silences like that.
He deleted it at twenty to two.
The second take was harder. He had to stop several times. He read Pauline’s tip. Then he told them about Samir’s car, and the seat pushed right back, and the full tank. Then he took the receipt out of his pocket and read it into the microphone, every line, the time, the amount, the word CASH. He said he had been the young man at the garage. He said he had used that man against Dean Kirwan for forty minutes of episode four and it had been him. He said he did not know why he had filled the tank. He said he did not remember the Shell, or the Fen Road, or anything between the Anchor and his bed, and that the walk home he had described in episode one might never have happened.
He said he had photographed the receipt and emailed it to the cold case unit at Lincolnshire Police, which was true, because he had done it before he pressed record, so that he could not take it back.
He said, “I’m not saying anything. I’m just telling you what’s in the file.”
He scheduled it for 06:00 and sat in the kitchen with the fridge door open until it went.
By seven, eleven thousand people had listened.
By half past, the comments had started, and they were not what he had braced for. They were not angry. They were busy. His listeners were good at this. He had taught them.
Someone had overlaid his tweets on a map of Holmfleet. Someone had found the old bus timetable for Marsh Lane and proved there had been no shelter there until 2011. Someone had pointed out, quite gently, that nobody fills a borrowed car to the brim unless they want the gauge to read the way it did when they took it. Someone had drawn it all as a red line, looping out from the pub, through the forecourt, down the Fen Road to the dyke and back, with a small neat circle at every time he had given them.
He read the red line with his coffee going cold. It was careful. It was generous in places, and fair. It was better than anything he had ever made.
And as he followed it, something he could not stop happened in him, slowly, the way a photograph comes up in a tray. He began to see it. Not remember. See. The forecourt lights, very white. His own hand putting a twenty on the counter. The windscreen, and the dark past the end of the headlights, and the dyke where the Fen Road bends.
He did not know whether he was remembering it, or whether four hundred thousand people had just finished doing to him what he had done to Dean, and filled the gap for him so well that it had become his.
He sat in the kitchen and tried to find the flaw in their account, the way he had trained them to. He was still trying when the police rang the bell.