Scare Actor
By Streetlight Slasher horror 18 min
Slasher stories Psychological thrillers Night shift horror
Before you go in
- Murder, and bodies displayed as props
- Stalking
- A friend who goes missing
- Being disbelieved by people in charge
You asked the old cast for a favourite memory of Hollow Pines, and mine is the night the work lights came on.
You attached last year’s cast photograph to your email, so we would remember who we were. I am in the second row, in my apron, with my mouth open in the scream I was proud of. I want to tell you about the room I stood in for four seasons, because you are opening it again next October and somebody should.
The Butcher Barn was the last room of the walk-through. Guests came in groups of six, holding each other’s coats, out of the corridor of hanging plastic sheets and into the fog. The strobe was on a beam over the cutting table, white, ten flashes a second, so everything moved like a flip book. The scent machine by the door puffed every ninety seconds. Cheryl bought the cartridges online, a smell called Rotting Meat, and the first weekend every season it made me gag, and after that I stopped noticing it.
I was the Butcher’s Wife. Grey makeup, a stained apron, a cleaver made of foam. I hid in a scare box beside the table, a plywood closet with a slot to watch through, and when the group reached the middle of the room I came out of it screaming. Beside the table, on a meat hook through a harness under his shirt, hung Hank.
Hank was the prop corpse. Grey skin, mouth open, head on one side. Guests loved him. Phones were not allowed in the barn and they took them out for Hank anyway. Every night somebody said he was the most realistic thing they had ever seen, and every night I said, in character, “He was a good husband,” and they screamed again.
On the second-to-last Friday, a group came through with a man in it who did not scream.
He was in a plain grey sweatshirt and jeans. No makeup, no mask, which on a haunt in October makes you stand out more than any mask. When I came out of the box he did not flinch. The others ran for the exit, where Marcus was waiting with the chainsaw, and the man stayed by the hook and looked up at Hank.
I stepped out of the dark to move him along. You never touch a guest. You lean in close and you breathe.
He did not look at me. He looked at Hank’s face, with his head on one side, the way Hank’s was.
“He’s better this year,” he said, and went.
An hour later he came through again, with a different group. Same sweatshirt. Same stop at the hook. When the group was at the exit I asked a girl at the back, out of character, whether the guy in grey was with them.
“Ew, no,” she said. “He was just, like, there.”
I radioed it in at the break. The cast radio at Hollow Pines was a joke line. Somebody was always calling a code red in the corn, which meant nothing, and somebody else was always doing a ghost voice. When I said a man in grey had come through the barn twice with two different groups, three people made the ghost voice at once.
Cheryl came and found me at the hot chocolate tent. Cheryl Bauer had owned the farm for nineteen years. She wore a fleece with the farm’s logo on it and she knew every actor’s name and their parents’ names.
“Grey sweatshirt? That’s Eddie,” she said. “Eddie Krall. Season pass. He’s been coming since forever, he’s harmless. He does removals for a funeral home over in Wadsworth, so I guess this is his idea of a vacation.” She squeezed my arm. “Every haunt has an Eddie, hon.”
Here is what I told myself, and I want you to see that it was reasonable.
Every haunt does have an Eddie. The guy who comes alone, who has a season pass and knows the rooms better than the new actors do, who stands too close and says your scare was better last year. They are lonely, mostly. They are the reason places like Hollow Pines stay open. And I wanted it to be that, badly, because there were two weekends left, and Cheryl had promised me a reference for a job at one of the big parks if I finished the season, and because the cast was voting for best scare on closing night and the fifty dollars was going to be mine.
So I tested it. At the next break I walked down to the exit, where the photographer took every group’s picture in front of the We Survived sign. Season pass holders wore a black wristband instead of the orange one. I asked her whether a man in grey had been through with a black band.
“Eddie?” She laughed. “Eddie’s always here.”
That should have been the end of it. A real pass, a real name, a woman who had known him for years.
He came through a third time at half past eleven, with a family from Brunswick. When I came out of the box he did not look round. He was looking up at Hank.
“Your second scream’s better than your first,” he said.
On the way out, the father of the family told me in a whisper, so his kids would not hear, that the guy had joined them at the corn maze and they had assumed he was staff.
I went to the photo board after close. Each night’s pictures went up on a corkboard by the exit and on the farm’s page. Groups of six, faces wet with fake blood from the chainsaw room’s spray, everybody laughing. I found the family from Brunswick. I found the girl who said ew. I found the first group.
He was in none of them. He came through my barn three times and he never once came out of the exit.
On the Saturday I told Marcus.
Marcus Webb ran the chainsaw at the exit. He was the reason guests screamed twice in a row, because they thought they were out and then they were not. He was twenty-six and he laughed at everything except, it turned out, this.
“Three times,” he said. “And never in a picture.”
“He goes back through the corn,” I said. “He has to.”
Marcus pulled his goggles down round his neck. “Tyler used to say something like that. About a guy in the maze.”
Tyler Fenn had played the scarecrow in the corn. He was nineteen, a lanky kid from Lodi who had chipped a front tooth on the hay wagon hitch the first weekend and shown everybody, grinning, as if it were a medal. In the middle of September he quit. By text, to the group chat, after close on a Saturday. Nobody thought anything of it. Kids quit haunts. It is cold and it is late and they find out their girlfriend wants them home.
After close that Saturday, Marcus went into the corn to look.
I was in the barn, wiping the table down. At a quarter to one the radio said, in Marcus’s voice, “Code red in the corn. Code red in the corn.”
Everybody laughed. Somebody did the ghost voice. Somebody said Marcus had finally lost it.
I keyed my radio and said, “Marcus, where are you?” and the line was full of people laughing.
He did not come back to the hot chocolate tent. His car was gone from the cast field when I walked out at half past one. At two in the morning, in bed with my phone, I watched the group chat light up.
im out. this place is too much. peace
Everybody sent him hearts. Somebody sent the ghost emoji.
Marcus never said peace. Marcus texted like an English teacher, with capitals and periods, and he signed off with his initial. I scrolled up through the chat, back past three weekends of jokes and lost car keys and who has my wig, to the middle of September.
im out. this place is too much. peace
Tyler.
On the Sunday I drove to Cheryl’s house.
She made me coffee and listened, which she was good at, and at the end she put her hand over mine on the table.
“Kids quit, Dana. Every year. They text because they don’t want to face me. Marcus has been saying he was too old for this since August.”
“He doesn’t write like that.”
“People write different when they’re quitting.” She said it kindly. She meant it. “His car’s gone. He drove home.”
I called the sheriff’s office from her driveway, the non-emergency number. The woman was patient. A twenty-six-year-old man had sent a text saying he was quitting a part-time job, and his car was gone, and I was not family. She took my name.
I drove past Marcus’s apartment in Medina that night. His car was not in the lot.
When I got home I looked up Tyler. I had never followed him; he was a kid from the corn, and I was the old lady of the barn at twenty-four. His last post was from the first weekend of the season, a selfie in his scarecrow makeup, straw sticking out of his collar, grinning so you could see the chipped tooth. Underneath, friends had written things in September. Bro where u at. You good? Nothing since. He had not answered any of them.
I sent him a message. I said it was Dana from the barn, and that I hoped he was okay, and that Marcus had quit too.
The answer came at ten past two in the morning. I was awake. I watched the three dots for a long time before it arrived.
all good. just done with that place
Then, a minute later, while I was still holding the phone:
how’s hank
I had not mentioned Hank.
I did not sleep much that week. I worked the desk at the clinic on Monday and Tuesday and made two mistakes with appointments, which I never made. I kept the chat open. I kept looking at the two texts, one above the other, if you scrolled far enough, the same three lines in the same small letters, as if one person had typed them both.
I had an explanation ready every night at three. It went like this.
Kids copy each other. Marcus had seen Tyler’s text in September. Marcus was embarrassed about chasing a season-pass holder through a cornfield at one in the morning and he quit the cheap way, the way the last kid quit, and he would turn up at Thanksgiving with a new job and a sheepish face. That explained the car. It explained the words. It did not explain the radio, code red in the corn, in his voice, at a quarter to one, and then nothing. But code red in the corn was a joke. That was the whole point of it. If he had meant it he would have said something else.
That is what I was afraid of, under all of it. That he had meant it, and that he had used the only words we had, and we had laughed.
On the last Friday, he came back.
I was in the box when the strobe stuttered. That is how I knew, the first time, before I saw him. The strobe on that beam was old and ran off the same circuit as the fog machine, and when somebody opened the side door by the breaker panel, the one marked Staff Only, the draught and the load did something to it. Ten flashes a second became three, then a long dark, then ten again. Everyone who worked that barn knew it meant somebody had come in the side.
When the flicker steadied, he was standing by the hook.
No group. Nobody in the plastic sheets behind him. Just the grey sweatshirt in the fog, the white light going on and off on it, and his head on one side.
I stayed in the box. I watched him through the slot.
He reached up, and I thought he was going to touch Hank, and that is a rule too, nobody touches the props. He did not touch him. He adjusted the shirt collar, the way you straighten a child’s collar before a photograph, and stepped back to look.
“Don’t let them move him,” he said, to the room. “He’s just right.”
The next group came through the sheets screaming at nothing, and when I came out of the box, he was gone.
I did not do my scare properly for the rest of the night. I looked at Hank instead.
I had worked beside him for four seasons. I knew him the way you know your own kitchen. Last year his hands were latex, cheap gloves stuffed with foam and painted grey, and one thumb had split at the seam, and we had taped it. I had taped it. I looked at his hands now, in the strobe, between groups.
No seam. The fingers hung in a loose, heavy curl. The nails were real nails, short, one of them torn. On the back of the left hand, between the knuckles, there were a few fine dark hairs.
I told myself Cheryl had bought a new Hank. Silicone. They sell them, for haunts, for films, and they are expensive, and they look exactly like this, down to the hair. “He’s better this year,” the man had said. Of course he was better, if he was new. I wanted that so much that I asked her at the midnight break, standing by the tent with my hands round a cup.
“New Hank?” Cheryl laughed. “Honey, I’m not made of money. Same Hank since 2009.”
After close, when the barn was empty, I took the stepladder from the props corner and climbed up beside him.
The fog had settled. The scent machine puffed. I had smelt it for four weekends and not noticed it, and now I noticed it, and under it there was something it was made to imitate.
I turned on my phone’s flashlight. I did not want to. I made myself.
Hank’s mouth was open, the way it always was, in the scream the guests photographed. Grey lips. Grey gums. And in the top row of his teeth, at the front, one of them was chipped. A small clean corner gone, the shape of a wagon hitch.
I did not scream. I want you to know that. In that barn a scream was the most ordinary sound there was. I climbed down. I walked out through the plastic sheets and across the yard and into the office, and I made Cheryl come with me.
She came because she was kind. She held my hand on the way across the yard, the way you hold the hand of someone who has had a shock.
The hook was empty.
The harness was gone. On the cutting table, under the strobe, someone had left a square of cardboard written on in marker, in neat capitals.
HANK OUT FOR REPAIR.
Cheryl looked at it a long time. Then she looked at me.
“One of the boys must have taken him down for the hook arm,” she said. “It’s been squeaking.” She did not ask who. “Dana. Go home. Sit out tomorrow, you’ve done enough this year.”
“It’s Tyler,” I said.
She put her arms round me. She said she knew it had been a hard season. She said Tyler had texted her personally, in September, to say sorry, and did I want to see it. I did not.
I worked closing night. I want you to understand why, because Cheryl begged me not to.
There was nobody else who would be looking.
Hank was back on his hook when I got there at six. One of the crew said he had been hanging when he came in, good as new, and wasn’t that nice of somebody. I did not look at Hank’s face. I did my makeup in the cast trailer and I went to the deputy who worked the parking field every October, a heavy kind man in a yellow vest, and told him that the prop in the Butcher Barn was a dead boy called Tyler Fenn.
He listened. He said he would walk over and take a look once the field cleared, around midnight. He said it the way Cheryl had said it, gently, as if I were the thing that needed looking at.
I did the whole night. I came out of the box screaming for two hundred and forty people, and every one of them screamed back, and some of them photographed Hank, and one boy told his girlfriend he was the most realistic thing he had ever seen. I said, “He was a good husband.” I did not look at him once.
At midnight the music stopped. The cast went to the bonfire in the cast field for the vote. On closing night you strike your own room; that is the rule, Cheryl’s rule, so the barn is ready for the crew on Sunday. Somebody shouted from the tent that I had won the fifty dollars. I said thank you into the radio and kept taking down the plastic sheets.
The work lights were off. Only the strobe was on, and the red exit sign, and my phone propped on the cutting table with the flashlight on.
The deputy did not come.
At twenty past twelve, the strobe stuttered.
Three flashes. A long dark. Ten.
He was standing between me and the plastic sheets, with his head on one side.
I knew the room better than he did. That was the one thing I had.
In the dark between flashes I stepped back, and back again, and my hip found the edge of the box, and I went into it and pulled the panel shut. Plywood. A slot at eye height. The smell of my own makeup and old fog.
Through the slot, the strobe made him a flip book. By the table. Nearer. By the hook, looking up at Hank. Nearer.
I had the radio on my belt. I thought about the radio and I thought about code red in the corn, and Marcus’s voice saying it, and everyone laughing.
I thought about what the room could do. There was an air cannon under the table that I could fire with my foot, a blast of compressed air that made grown men fall down. There was the drop panel at the back of the box, onto the corridor behind the barn wall, where I went out to pee during breaks. I could be the Butcher’s Wife. I could come out of the dark screaming, the way I had for four years, and he would not flinch, because he had never flinched, and then I would be outside the box with him.
He stopped in front of the slot.
I could see his sweatshirt, grey, and the strobe on it. I could hear him breathing, slow, the way you breathe in a room you like.
“Best room on the farm,” he said, close to the plywood. “I told them that every year.”
I could scream. A scream in the Butcher Barn on closing night was the best sound in Ohio. The cast at the bonfire would hear it, and they would cheer.
There is one word on a haunt that is not a joke. Every guest is told it at the ticket booth. If you need to get out, you say it, and the actors drop character, and somebody comes and walks you to the exit with the lights up. At Hollow Pines the word was Mercy, and Cheryl’s rule was that if it came over the cast radio, from anyone, for any reason, the work lights went up across the whole farm and every actor took off their mask. In four seasons I had never heard it on the radio. Nobody joked with it. People had been fired for less.
An actor does not say it. An actor is the reason other people say it.
I keyed the radio. I put my mouth against it so he would hear only a whisper through the plywood.
“Mercy,” I said. “Butcher Barn. Mercy.”
The work lights at Hollow Pines are the kind they use on highway jobs at night. Twelve of them on poles, across the corn and the yard and the barns, and when they come on together the whole farm goes white and flat and ordinary, like a parking lot.
I heard them come on, a heavy clunk from the breaker shed, and the barn filled with light through every crack in its walls. The strobe was nothing in it. The fog was nothing. I pushed the panel open and stepped out of the box, because there was nowhere left to hide in that much light, for either of us.
He had not moved. He was standing beside the cutting table among the props, very still, with his hands at his sides and his head on one side, as if he were one of them. Two plastic pigs, a rubber arm on the block, Hank on his hook. And a man in a grey sweatshirt, holding his breath, waiting for the light to pass over him the way it passed over everything else in that room.
It did not pass over. Everybody came. Actors with their masks pushed up on their foreheads, the girl from the photo booth, Cheryl in her fleece, the deputy in his yellow vest with his hand on his belt, and they stood in the doorway with the plastic sheets in their fists and looked at the barn under work lights for the first time.
They looked at Hank. Nobody said he was realistic.
The man breathed out. He looked round at all of them, mildly, the way you look at an audience that has arrived late. Then he walked out of the side door by the breaker panel, the Staff Only door, not fast, and the deputy went after him and stopped him halfway across the parking field, where he stood with his hands up in the white light as if he were having his picture taken.
They found Marcus before one, when the deputies walked the corn under the work lights. He was on the scarecrow post where Tyler used to stand, in Tyler’s straw hat. The guests had walked past him in the dark all Saturday night. Some of them have pictures.
Cheryl sold the farm in the spring. You know that part.
So that is my memory. You asked for a photograph for the booklet as well, so I went through the old exit pictures, the ones the farm put online every season. It took a week.
He is in every season since 2014. Not in many pictures, never more than one or two in a year, always at the edge of the group, in grey. Each time he is standing beside one of the cast. Somebody who wandered into the exit shot to photobomb, a scarecrow, a girl with a rubber axe. I found their names in old cast lists. Every one of them quit that season, by text.
In last year’s, on closing night, he is standing beside me. I am in my apron, laughing at something off camera, and he is looking at the side of my face with his head a little on one side, the way he looked at Hank.
I am the only one in those pictures who never quit. I have thought a lot about why. I think he was in no hurry with me. On that first Friday he looked up at Hank and said he was better this year, and I took it as a compliment to the props. I had worked on my scream all summer.
You will need a Butcher’s Wife next October. Tell her the word on her first night. Tell her not to get too good.