The Tooth-Drawer

By Strange Light Dark fantasy 17 min

Dark fantasy

Before you go in
  • Body horror: teeth, gums and bodily change
  • Being trapped inside a living creature
  • Death of a parent, and human remains

Dragons talk in their sleep, and in Hollin somebody always writes it down.

The dream-takers sit in the Kept Halls all night on high stools with their ink frozen half solid, and when one of the old dragons murmurs, they take it down. On Quarter Days the takings are read out in the square under the Anvil, and the Queen’s council argues over what they mean, and the farmers listen for anything about rain. Most of it is nothing. Old names. Weather on mountains that fell into the sea before Hollin was a kingdom. Long lists of what was eaten, and when, and how it tasted.

Hild Fell brought me Hessely’s taking on the morning the griffin came. She stood in my doorway in her fur hood with the paper held out flat on both hands, the way you would carry a dish that was too hot, and she did not come in.

“Third Hall,” she said. “Last night. Second hour.”

I had been up since four with my jaw. I grind my teeth in my sleep. All tooth-drawers do, it is a joke in the trade, and most mornings I wake with an ache from my ear to my chin and a grit on my tongue like fine sand, which is my own teeth, worn away a little more. I read the taking with one hand pressed to the side of my face.

It was the usual. Ice. A river with a name in the old tongue. Something about a ship that tasted of tar. And then, in Hild’s square, careful hand, on a line by itself:

Wren. Little wren. Come and sit with me.

My mother called me that. Nobody else ever has. She went to the Halls when I was twelve, and I have not heard it since, except in my sleep, which does not count.


Here is what I told myself, and I told it to Hild too, standing in the doorway with the paper shaking.

Dragons are mimics. Everybody knows it. The old ones can do a cow, a landslide, a lark, a dying horse. My mother drew Hessely’s teeth for twenty-two years. She talked the whole time she worked, as we all do, because a silent mouth wakes and a talking one keeps dreaming. Twenty-two years of my mother’s voice in that mouth, saying little wren this and little wren that, because she talked about me, she talked about me to everyone. Of course Hessely could do it. A jay can say your name if it hears it enough.

I wanted that to be true so badly that I could taste it.

Hild let me finish. Then she said, “I’ve taken Hessely for forty-one years, Wren. She has never once used that voice.” She looked past me, up at the mountain. “Not until you started going into her this spring.”

The griffin was on my roof by then, scraping at the scale tiles with its back claws and screaming for its meat. A griffin brings the Queen’s letters in Hollin, and a letter from the Queen by griffin means it is late already. I paid the bird a leg of mutton and broke the seal.

Hessely had moved in her sleep. The first time in sixty-three years. One foreleg had shifted the length of a man, and the chain the kingdom put on her as a courtesy, links like cartwheels, had pulled its staple a hand’s breadth out of the rock. The dream-takers said she was surfacing. The hall-master said it was the tooth. The Queen said: draw it, before the barley feast, by whatever means the warrant allows.


You have to understand how big she is, or none of it will make sense.

The Third Hall is cut into the Anvil four hundred feet deep, and Hessely fills it the way a cat fills a basket, curled, nose to tail, her tail going on down into the dark where the mountain is hot and nobody has followed it in ninety years. She came down off the high ice nine centuries ago to die, as they all do, and Hollin gave her a hall and kept her asleep, and she has been dying ever since. Her warmth goes up through the flues and heats the terraces, so that lemons grow at the snowline. Her shed scales roof half the city. Her hide is the colour of slate after rain, green-black, every scale the size of a shield and rimmed with lichen, and in the creases of her neck there are ferns growing, and ember-moths live in the ferns and drift up off her in the lamplight like sparks off a forge.

Her breath comes every forty of my heartbeats. You hear it before you feel it: a long roar, low, like a furnace door opening at the bottom of a stair. Then the heat. Then the smell, which used to be hot stone and sulphur and was now, that summer, something else as well. Sweet. Rotten. You could smell it in the upper town on a still day, and people said the Kept were dying at last, and other people told them to hush.

On her horns hang nine hundred and six bronze bells, one hung every midwinter since the Halls were cut. When she breathes they ring.

The hall-men had her jaw propped the day before I went in to look. They do it with a jaw-post, an oak trunk shod with iron at both ends, that ninety men walk in on poles while the hall-singers keep her under. You can see the singers in the gallery all through a drawing, twenty women humming the low hall-song, never stopping, two at a time stepping out to drink while the rest carry it. That song is the reason nobody in Hollin can hum without someone telling them to stop.

I went in with my salamander lantern on a pole. It is a live salamander in a cage of brass gauze, the size of my hand, and it burns white and does not eat the air. You cannot take a flame into a dragon’s mouth. Her breath would take it back.

Standing on Hessely’s lower lip is like standing on a quay. Her front teeth rise in a fence on either side of you, yellow as old ivory, each one taller than me and ridged like a column. Her tongue is a grey-blue hill, ridged and slick, as wide as a threshing floor, and it moves in her sleep the way a sleeper’s hand moves on a blanket. The roof of her mouth is ribbed like a cellar vault, and it drips. Everything drips. The heat comes up from her throat in a red dark that goes down like a well, and from down there, from the bottom of the well, comes the dream-murmur, which is not a sound so much as a shaking. You feel it in your feet. You feel it in your teeth.

The molar was at the back on the left, where the gum rises like a ploughed bank. It was the size of a door. It had been white once, and it was black now and brown, soft at the edges like a rotten log, and there was a hole in the crown of it as big as a bread oven, and the sweet smell came out of the hole in waves.

I talked while I looked. You always talk. I said the things my mother taught me to say, and things I say to my own pillow, and I said, “Hold still, old girl. Hold still for me,” while I knocked on the black crown with the butt of my chisel to hear how deep the rot went.

From the bottom of the well, in the dream-murmur, my mother answered.

“I am holding still, Wren,” she said. “I’ve held still for you for nineteen years.”


I felt it in my teeth before I heard it. That is how a dragon’s voice reaches you inside the mouth: through the bone, up through the soles of your boots and your shins and your hips and your spine into your jaw, so that the words are in your own teeth before they are in your ears. My mother’s voice. Not like it. Hers. The little catch she had on the w. The way she said my name as if it were a joke between us.

A jay can say your name. A jay cannot answer you.

I came out of Hessely’s mouth too fast and fell off her lip, and the hall-men caught me. Tamsin, my apprentice, who is fourteen and sharp and frightened of nothing yet, asked me what the rot was like. I told her it was deep. I told her we would draw it in three days. I did not tell her anything else.

That night I ground my teeth so hard I woke myself. There was blood on the pillow. And at the back of my jaw on the left, behind the last of my own molars, where there has never been anything but gum, there was something hard and new, coming up through the flesh.


The barber in the lower town had me sit in his chair by the window and put his thumb in my mouth.

“Wisdom tooth,” he said. “Late, but they do. My wife got one at forty. Salt water and patience.”

I wanted that too. A late tooth is a small, stupid thing. It happens to barbers’ wives. I went home and rinsed with salt water and tried to be patient, and I looked at it in my hand mirror with the salamander held up to my mouth.

It was not a wisdom tooth. It was ridged, the way Hessely’s are, in long columns. It was warm. Not warm like the rest of my mouth. Warm like a stone that has been in the sun. And it grew. A fingernail’s breadth the first day. Another the second. On the third morning I bit down on my breakfast spoon to stop myself crying out, and when I took the spoon out of my mouth there was a dent in the pewter, deep and clean, the shape of a tooth that should not be there.

So I ran.

I am not proud of it. I left the tools in the Hall and the warrant key on my table and I took the mule road down the Anvil before it was light, with Tamsin asleep and the hall-song going on behind me in the mountain, and I went down to Brennock, in the lowlands, where nobody keeps dragons and the only teeth anybody draws are the ones in people.

It was worse away from her. That is the only way I can say it. The new tooth throbbed the whole way down the mountain, and it throbbed towards the Anvil, the way a lodestone swings to the north, so that I could have pointed to the Third Hall with my eyes shut by the ache in my jaw. In Brennock I took a bed at an inn and lay awake grinding my teeth until my jaw locked, and I sat up at midnight with my mouth stuck open and the tooth singing in it like a struck bell.

On the second night the ground moved. A long, slow shudder through the floor of the inn that set the jugs walking on the shelves. In the morning a carter came in from the north road and said the whole face above the Kept Halls had come down in the night, a quarter-mile of it, and the bells were going in the city, all of them, the way they ring for the Kept.

She had moved again. More than a foreleg this time.

I went back. I would like whoever takes this down to know that. Nobody fetched me. I paid my bill and walked back up the Anvil on my own feet, grinding my teeth the whole way.

Hollin was ringing when I came in through the Low Gate. Every bell in the city, the temple bells and the gate bells and the little bells the scale-roofers hang on their ladders, all going at once and none of them together. The rockfall had taken the north road and six houses with it, and there were people in the square in their nightclothes, holding their children’s scales. Every child in Hollin is given a scale at seven, shed from one of the Kept, to keep under the pillow, and in a bad night you see them all come out, the size of dinner plates, held up in small hands like shields.

They knew me. Everyone in Hollin knows the tooth-drawer. A woman I had never met stepped out of the crowd as I passed and touched two fingers to her own jaw, at the back, on the left, and then to her lips. Then a man did it. Then a dozen. It is an old courtesy, older than the Queen’s family, and I had seen it done to my mother a thousand times when I was small, and I had always thought it was for luck.

Nobody had ever done it to me before. They did it all the way up through the city, with the bells going and the lemons on the terraces shaking on their branches, and nobody said a word.


The warrant roll lives in a chest in the hall-master’s room, and nobody reads it, because it is only names.

Thirty-one tooth-drawers since the Halls were cut. My mother’s name, Maud Tanner, is the thirtieth. Mine is the thirty-first, in a newer ink. Every entry before mine ends the same way, in the same old formula, four words and a date: went to the Halls.

I told myself what Hollin tells itself. It is a hard trade. A jaw-post slips. A dragon swallows in its sleep. Thirty tooth-drawers in nine hundred years, dead at their work in the Halls, and the kingdom too polite to say how. That is all the words mean.

But the dead are buried in Hollin. Even the ones the Kept take, we bury what is left. I went through the burial book in the temple afterwards with Tamsin holding the lamp, every page, and there is not one tooth-drawer in it. Not one in nine hundred years.

Then I took down the tooth-books. Every Kept dragon has one, a ledger of its teeth, written up by the hall-master after every drawing, with the size of each tooth and its state and whether it is sound. Hessely’s runs to six volumes. I found the black molar in the last one, when it was not black. It is entered as new. Erupted, in the old word: grown in fresh, at the back on the left, in the autumn of the year I was twelve. A dragon nine centuries old, growing a new tooth the size of a door, in the same month my mother went to the Halls.

I went back through the others with my finger on the lines. Old Morrow in the First Hall, who has no eyes. Saradine in the Fifth. The Twins. For every tooth-drawer on the roll who went to the Halls, within the year, in one of the seven tooth-books, a great molar is entered as new.

Thirty of them. I counted twice.


In the morning I went into Hessely’s mouth with Tamsin waiting on the lip and the hall-song going and the salamander burning white on its pole, and I began cutting the rot away from the base of the black molar so the chains would bite. You always clear the rot first. It is like digging out a stump.

My chisel struck metal.

I cleared it with my fingers. The rot came away soft and warm and sweet, like the inside of an apple left on a windowsill, and under it, set in the brown dentine of the tooth as if the tooth had grown around it, there was a ring. Copper, with a twist in it. My mother’s. And through the ring, white in the white light, small and neat as a chicken’s bone, a finger.

I cut more away. I could not stop. I cut until I could see the shape that the rot followed, down through the crown and into the root: the curve of a back, the tuck of knees, an arm folded under a head. The way a child sleeps. The way my mother slept, on her side, with her hand under her cheek.

From the bottom of the well she said, “Don’t cry, little wren. It isn’t so bad. It’s warm.”

I came out of the mouth on my hands and knees. Hild was at the foot of Hessely’s lip, on her stool, with her pen in her hand and her ink steaming. She had heard it. She had taken it down.

“You knew,” I said.

“Teeth that size are grown, Wren,” Hild said. “They aren’t born.” She did not look at me. She looked at her paper. “She asked your mother to stay, too. Maud told me so. The night before.”

“Asked her.”

“They always ask. They can’t take a thing that won’t come.” Hild capped her ink. Then she did look at me, and I saw that she had been afraid of me for a long time and had hidden it well. “And she’s asking you. I can hear it in your mouth. You grind like she does.”


We drew the tooth that night, because the Queen had said before the feast and the feast was in two days, and because Hessely’s foreleg had moved again in the afternoon and taken the chain’s staple clean out of the rock.

Ninety hall-men on the capstan. A hogshead of poppy-milk poured over her tongue from the gallery in a white waterfall. The hall-singers in two ranks, forty of them now, humming so low it made my eyes water. Tamsin on the lip with a horn to call the capstan. The great tongs, which the royal smiths call a pelican, slung on chains from the roof of the hall, and me inside the mouth fixing the jaws of them round the root of my mother.

I talked the whole time. I told Hessely about the lemons on the terraces. I told her about the inn in Brennock and the jugs walking on the shelves. I told her about the spoon. And from the bottom of the well my mother talked back, quietly, the way she used to when she sat on my bed, about nothing. About snow. About a ship that tasted of tar.

Tamsin blew the horn. The capstan turned.

The chains came up taut and sang. The tooth groaned in its socket. Then it gave all at once, with a sound like a tree coming out of wet ground, and the pelican lifted it out over my head and up between the fence of the front teeth into the light of the hall, black and huge and turning slowly on its chains, and the hall-men cheered, and the singers did not stop. From underneath, with the light of the hall behind it, I could see her in it. A darker shape in the brown, curled, like somebody asleep behind a dirty window. Then it swung away out of the mouth and was gone.

The voice did not go with it. From the bottom of the well, she went on talking about snow.

Where the tooth had been there was a hollow in the gum. Raw and red and steaming in the salamander light, as warm as a bed someone has just got out of. It smelled of bread and blood. The new tooth at the back of my jaw ached towards it, the way it had ached towards the Anvil all the way down the mule road. I looked at the hollow. It was the length of a woman lying on her side with her knees drawn up. It was my length.

Then Hessely ground her teeth.

The sound came up from under me, through the gum, through my boots, into my own jaw, the grinding of millstones the size of houses. The jaw-post groaned. And my own teeth ground with it. I could not stop them. My jaw was working on its own, in time with hers, grinding, the new tooth at the back of it hot as a coal, and over the top of all of it the hall-song faltered, and somebody screamed my name from the lip.

The jaw-post was bending. I could see it from where I knelt, the great oak trunk bowing like a bow, the iron shoes screeching on her teeth. At the front of the mouth the fence of teeth was coming down, slowly, the light of the hall narrowing between them, and Tamsin’s small shape against the light, and the lip so far away, forty yards of slick, ridged tongue away, rising under me like a wave.

“Lie down, little wren,” my mother said. Not from the well. From the hollow. From right beside my knees. “It’s the only place the teeth don’t meet.”

I could have run for it. I want whoever takes this down to know that, too. Forty yards. I might have made it.

I lay down.


It is warm. It is not so bad. It is dark, but she talks, and I can talk back, and the grinding has stopped, and I do not grind my teeth any more.

I will tell it again, from the beginning, so somebody writes it down. Dragons talk in their sleep, and in Hollin somebody always writes it down.


Taken down from the sleeping speech of Hessely, in the Third Hall, over the four nights following the drawing, in the second hour, by Hild Fell, dream-taker.

The jaw did not open again for nine days. When the hall-men brought the post in, the hollow at the back on the left had closed over with new gum. Hessely has not stirred since. The barley feast was held in sun.

The voice is new to the record. Between sentences it grinds its teeth.

The drawn tooth, by the custom of the warrant, was given to the tooth-drawer’s heir. The warrant passes to Tamsin Rook, aged fourteen. She asks that it be noted she has been waking with an ache in her jaw.