The Cloud-Whale

By Strange Light Dark fantasy 17 min

Dark fantasy

Before you go in
  • Hunting and killing of a sentient animal, with blood
  • Crew members falling to their deaths
  • Loss of self and voice
  • Exploitation of a disability

The Guild surgeon rings a small bronze bell beside my left ear, then beside my right, and watches my face instead of listening.

She has ink on her cuffs and a ledger open on her knee, and she writes something in it, and blots it, and turns the book so I cannot see. Then she shakes my hand and tells me I am fit to sign. Everybody on the quay at Haldersund gets the bell, Halvard tells me afterwards, carrying my sea-chest up the gangway for me as if I were a child. It is luck. It is older than the Guild. You do not ask about luck.

I am nineteen, and I have never been off the Spire. My father lights the lamps on the Guild Stair, three hundred and eleven of them, every evening of my life, and every one of them burns whale-oil with a flame as blue as a cornflower and no smoke at all. That oil is why I am here. I won the spring-iron at the quayside shooting three years running, and the Kittiwake needs a harpooner, and the Guild pays a first-voyager a full lay.

There is one law aboard a whaler that is older than all the others. Nobody sings. Nobody hums, nobody whistles, nobody so much as taps out a tune on the rail. The bosun gives his orders with a wooden rattle and his hands. The old hands say a whale can hear a tune through forty miles of cloud, and come to it, and that a whale that comes to you is not the same as a whale you go to.

On the first morning out, with the Spire gone to a grey thumb behind us and the Cloudsea flat and white to the end of the world, I put my hands on the shrouds and feel them humming. A deep, slow thrum, in the bones of my palms, like a plucked string the size of a street. The pennant at the masthead hangs dead. There is no wind at all.

I ask Halvard what it is.

He looks at my hands on the rope. He looks at them for a long time.

“Lungs settling,” he says. “Take your hands off, lad. And keep your mouth shut.”


I should tell you what she is, the Kittiwake, because you have only ever seen them from the Stair, small and far off, coming in at dusk.

She is a whaler of the Haldersund pattern, black spruce keel, a hundred and forty feet, and she floats because above her deck, in a net of tarred rope, there are five great bladders called the lungs. They are the cured stomachs of whales, each one as big as a chapel, and they are full of breath: the light gas a whale makes in its own body to swim in the sky, drawn off when it dies. The lungs creak all day like old leather, and sweat, and smell of violets and hot pennies. Under the keel, forty fathoms down on chains, hangs the hellpot, the iron tryworks where the blubber is boiled, because no flame is ever lit above the keel. Not a pipe. Not a candle. On a ship full of breath you eat cold and work by daylight, and at night the only lamps are the whale-oil lanterns sealed in glass, which burn without air.

We sail eleven days on the edge of the Cloudsea before we see a whale. The hum in the lines comes and goes. I learn not to touch them.

Then the lookout in the crow-basket, which hangs under the hull so he can see along the face of the cloud, beats on his rattle until it breaks.


You have to understand how big they are.

The cloud ahead of us bulges. That is the first thing: the flat white floor of the world bulging up into a hill, a hill a quarter of a mile long, and the hill goes on rising, white pouring off it in falls and rivers, until it is not a hill but a back. The cloud slides off it the way water slides off a seal. Underneath is grey-blue skin, and the skin is clear at the flanks, like horn held up to a lamp, and inside it there are lights. Lift-sacs, Halvard says at my shoulder, glowing, the size of houses, a whole lit street of them going away inside her, and through her I can see the sun come and go.

Gardens grow on her. Weed and moss and long grey beards of lichen hang from her sides a hundred feet down into the cloud. Skuas ride on her, thousands, and lift off screaming when she moves, and things like crabs the size of dogs scuttle in the moss and drop off her into the cloud and climb back. Then she blows. A column of white goes up from her head, higher than our masts, and hangs there, and comes down over us as snow. Real snow, in high summer, on our faces and in our mouths, tasting of salt.

Her eye goes by us, gold, the size of a cartwheel, and it looks at the ship.

“Lanternback,” Halvard says. “A cow. Thirty years since anybody saw one that size.” He grips my arm. “Captain says low, mind. Not the lung-mark. Low on the throat, under the jaw. She likes them low.”

I ask why.

“Holds them better,” he says, and does not look at me.


We go after her in the gigs. Six oars to a boat, each oar a long vane feathered like a wing, and over each boat its own small lung on a short net, so the gig hangs in the air under it like a lamp under a cloud. I kneel in the bow with the spring-iron, which is a whalebone bow on a stock as long as I am, cranked back by two men, with the iron’s line coiled in tubs behind me. Every man aboard has tied a twist of his own hair into the luck-splice at the head of that line. Mine is the newest.

She is feeding, drifting, her great mouth open on the brit, the little bright shrimp that hang in the cloud and glitter like dust in a sunbeam. We come in under her jaw. The throat is a long grooved pouch of skin, pale as the inside of a shell, wider than our boat is long, and I put the iron in it where Halvard pointed, low, and pull.

The bow goes with a crack like a door slamming. The iron goes into her throat to the shank.

She does not dive. She goes forward, all at once, so fast the line screams out of the tubs and smokes on the loggerhead, and the gig is snatched after her through the cloud. Sleigh ride, they call it, and it is: white, white, then sun, then white, the boat skidding on nothing behind four hundred feet of whale, the men whooping with their teeth shut so that not one note gets out of them.

Then she stops.

The line goes slack. The gig drifts. Ahead of us in the cloud there is only a shape, a great dim shape, hanging still.

And the rowers stop rowing. All six of them. At the same moment, as if somebody had touched each one on the shoulder. They turn their faces towards her. Halvard is at the stroke oar, and his mouth is open, and his eyes are full of water.

I hear nothing. That is what I need you to understand. I hear the wind, a little. Very high up, at the very top of my hearing, I hear something like a wet finger going round the rim of a glass. That is all.

But the line in my hands is shaking. Not with her pull. With a slow, deep thrum, the same thrum as the shrouds on the first morning, stronger, so strong it goes up my arms into my chest and my teeth.

Halvard closes his eyes. He opens his mouth wider.

And out of Halvard’s mouth comes a sound I can hear.


It is low. It is so low that I feel it more than I hear it, in the planks of the boat under my knees, and it is not a man’s voice. It is long, and it bends, and it goes on longer than a man has breath for. It is her voice. He is answering her in her own voice.

Then the bowman beside me does it. Then all of them.

We get back to the Kittiwake because I take an oar and the others row with me without seeming to know they are doing it, still singing, their faces turned back towards her. We bring the line aboard and make it fast to the great post at the bow, and the ship takes the strain, and the whale hangs out there in the cloud two hundred yards off our bow, held by my iron in her throat, not diving, not dying.

Singing.

That night the whole crew sings with her.

Here is what I tell myself first, because it is what everybody on the Spire knows about whalers. When a whale is struck in the lift-sacs, breath leaks out of her, and breath is a strange gas. Men who breathe too much of it go giddy, and their voices go odd, high or low, and they laugh at nothing. Breath-drunk, they call it on the quays. The iron went in near her sacs. The wind is setting from her to us. The whole crew is breath-drunk, and it will blow over.

I want that so badly I can taste violets in my mouth just thinking it.

So I try it. I go to the bow, downwind of her, where the breath would be thickest, and I stand in it and breathe deep until my head goes light and the cloud tips. My voice goes thin when I say my own name aloud. But I do not sing. I do not want to. And when I look back down the deck, the men singing loudest are the ones right aft at the stern, a hundred and forty feet from her, where the breath has thinned to nothing and the air is as clean as the Spire.


On the second day the singing does not stop for work. That is worse than I can say. They work, and they sing while they work, the whole low bending song, and they do it in time with her. When she stops for breath they stop. When she goes on they go on. Their mouths open wider than mouths should, and the sound that comes out goes into the planks and the rope and my hands, and the lungs overhead buzz with it like drums.

Captain Aud Kessel stays in her cabin. I knock, and she does not answer.

I go to the cook’s boy, Tobi, who is eleven and brings me my bread, because he is the smallest thing on board and I think he will be the last to go. I take him by the shoulders.

“Are they singing?” I ask him. “Tobi. Tell me. Can you hear them singing?”

Because I have started to think it is me. That I am sick. That I have cloud-fever, and they are only standing at the rail, and I am the one who has gone strange. I had the ear-fever as a small boy, my father says, a whole winter, and was never quite right on the left side after. Perhaps I have it again. Perhaps it is in my head.

Tobi looks up at me. His mouth opens. And out of it comes her voice, so low that I feel it through his shoulders into my hands, an answer, a long one, and his eyes are wet and kind and very far away.

I let him go.

That evening Sten the cooper climbs the rail at the bow. He does it carefully, the way you climb a stile. He stands on the rail with one hand on a stay and he sings, and then he lets go of the stay and steps out off the rail into the cloud, still singing, and goes down into it, upright, with his arms a little spread, slowly at first and then not slowly, until the white closes over him.

Nobody looks round. Nobody stops.


I do what you do on a ship when everything else has gone. I do the routines.

I go up into the lung-net with the gauge and read the pressure in all five, and write it in the log, because the mate has stopped writing in the log. I vent number three, which is swelling with the cold. I go round the deck and trim the steering vanes by hand, one at a time, because there is no one to do it with me. I check the line at the bow post every hour, and every hour it is humming under my hands. I talk while I work. I talk to my father, out loud, about the lamps on the Stair, the three hundred and eleven of them, which order he lights them in, how he whistles on the way down and stops himself at the Guild door. I talk so that there is one voice on this ship that is not hers.

I tell myself she will die by the morning. A whale with an iron in its throat does not live long. When she dies she will stop, and they will stop, and Halvard will sit on a coil of rope and rub his face and ask me what day it is.

In the morning she is still singing.

Four more are gone in the night. The Kittiwake is heeling to the bow with her weight on the line, and the lungs are straining, and the hellpot swings on its chains forty fathoms down, cold, with nobody to light it.


I go into the Captain’s cabin without knocking.

She is sitting at her table with her back very straight and her hands flat on the wood, and her mouth is open, and she is singing. Aud Kessel, who has forty years in the trade and a face like a split plank, singing with her eyes full of tears. On the table in front of her is the ship’s articles book, open, and a letter with the Guild’s seal broken.

I read the letter first, slowly, because I read slowly. It is short.

If she sings, and the song takes the crew, the stopped ear is to go out on the line and finish her at the throat-bell. His share is a tenth of the song-oil. Do not tell him before.

Then I turn the articles to my own page. My name, my lay, my mark. And under it, in a different hand, small and neat, with ink on the cuff of it I would know anywhere:

O. Lind. Bell-tested at signing. Stopped in the low register, both ears. Suitable.

I sit down on the floor of her cabin.

I think about the bell by my ear on the quay, and the surgeon watching my face instead of listening. About Halvard looking at my hands on the shrouds. About low, lad, low on the throat, she likes them low. About my articles, which I signed without reading because I cannot read well, and the clause the purser called the song-share, and laughed, and said I’d never see it. Song-oil. My father told me once that the lamps in the Guildhall burn something finer than the rest. Brighter, steadier. Ten times the price. He never knew what it was. Neither did I.

They make them sing. They put the iron in the throat on purpose, because a whale that dies singing gives the best oil there is, and the men who hear the song go over the side, and that is priced in too, it is a line in somebody’s book in the Guildhall. And for that they need one man aboard who cannot hear it. One man who will still be standing at the end with his own voice in his mouth and a lance in his hands.

They did not choose me because I am a good shot. They chose me because I am deaf in the part of the world where she is singing.

Aud Kessel turns her head and looks down at me sitting on her floor. Her mouth closes for a moment. When it opens again, out of it comes a word in her own voice, cracked and dry, the last word she has.

“Go.”


There are two ways to stop it, and I stand at the bow post with my hands on the humming line and look at them both.

I can cut the line. One stroke of the flensing knife. She goes free into the cloud, still singing, with my iron in her throat, and the Guild gets nothing, and the crew, the few left, go to the rail one by one and follow her down, and I take the Kittiwake home alone, if I can, with nobody to trim the vanes.

Or I can go out on the line, and finish her.

Halvard has already gone. I see him from the bow: halfway out along the line, hanging under it, hand over hand, with his legs crossed over it the way they teach you on the quay, going out across two hundred yards of open cloud towards her, singing. He taught me that crossing. He taught me to tie my hair into the splice.

I strap the long lance across my back. I take hold of the line.

The song comes into my palms.

The farther out I go, the more of it there is. The line is alive with it, a deep slow pulse that goes up my arms and into my chest and my jaw and my eyes, until the white cloud below me shivers with it, until I can feel it bend and turn and come round again, and I understand that I am hearing it the only way I can. With my hands. And it is not one voice. There are other voices in it, braided in, under it and through it. I know them. I have heard them all my voyage, at the rail, at the oars, saying pass the bread. Sten. The bowman. Tobi. They are in it. She is singing with all of them.

I catch Halvard up halfway. He is hanging still, his face turned up to the sky, singing. When I come alongside him on the line he turns his head and looks at me, and his eyes are clear, and he says my name in her voice. I feel it through the line. Oskar. Long and low and bent.

I climb over him. I do not know how. I put my boot on his shoulder and go on.

Her flank comes up out of the cloud in front of me like a wall of blue horn with a city inside it, lights going away down the length of her, and the lichen beards hanging, and the skuas wheeling, and the crabs. I get my feet on her. I take my hands off the line and put them flat on her hide.

And I hear her.

All of her. For the first time in my life, the whole of a sound, through my palms and the soles of my feet and the bones of my face, so loud and so low that the sky goes dark at the edges. It is not pain. I thought it would be pain. It is calling. It is the way you would call across a dark field for somebody who is late home, over and over, and the voices of my crew in it calling with her, and every one of them sounds glad.

Her throat-bell hangs below me under the jaw, huge and pale, with my iron standing out of it. I can see it move with every note.

I think of the Stair at dusk, and my father going up it with his long pole, lamp after lamp, blue after blue.

I go down to the throat-bell on the moss and the beards, with the lance in both hands, and I put it in.

The song stops in my palms.


I do not see Halvard let go. I look back along the line when I can stand again, and it is empty.

She dies by evening. We lash her alongside with the girth-chains, those of us who are left, nine out of thirty-one, and she hangs under the Kittiwake in the cloud, and we flense her by hand and light the hellpot, and the smoke comes up around the ship for three days. Nobody sings. Nobody speaks. The men who came back from the rail stand at their work with their mouths a little open, and no sound comes out of them, not a word, not a groan, not when they burn their hands on the try-chains. Aud Kessel sits in her cabin. Tobi brings me my bread and looks at me, and opens his mouth, and nothing.

They never speak again. Not one of them. In Haldersund the Guild pays them off on the quay with their full lay and a pension, and they go up into the city, and I see them sometimes on the Stair, standing still, with their hands flat on the glass of the lamps.

The Guild pays me my tenth. I give it to my father. He does not know what it is for.

The Kittiwake’s oil goes to the Guildhall, all of it, sealed in casks with the song-mark burnt into the heads. They say it is the finest in forty years. I walk up the Stair with my father at dusk, the way I did as a boy, and I hold the ladder while he lights the lamps. At the top, at the Guild door, the lamps burn brighter than the rest, steady and blue, with no smoke at all.

I put my hand on the glass.

It is warm. And under my palm, faint, so faint I would never have known it if I did not know it, there is a thrum. Slow. Deep. Bending, and turning, and coming round again. And braided into it, calling, glad, a laugh I would know anywhere, from a man who carried my sea-chest up a gangway as if I were a child.

I cannot hear it. I never could. I take my hand off the glass, and my father climbs down the ladder, whistling, and stops himself, the way he always does, at the Guild door.