The Moonlit Market

By Strange Light Dark fantasy 18 min

Folk horror Dark fantasy

Before you go in
  • A child put at risk and separated from his mother
  • Infertility and pregnancy loss, implied
  • Memory loss, and a parent who no longer knows her child

When the full moon clears the ridge, the top of the Knap peels back like the lid of a tin, and the market comes up out of the hill already lit.

You have never seen it, so I will tell you once, properly. The turf rolls away from the crown in one long strip with the sheep-droppings still on it. Underneath is a bowl as wide as Lowstock, terraced like a bread oven, and down the terraces run the rows: stalls grown out of root and hawthorn, roofed with bark and hung with lamps. The lamps are will-o’-the-wisps in birdcages. They beat their light against the bars all night, and if you stand under one too long it learns your face and tries to lead you home a wrong way. The stair down is made of roots. It is warm under your hand, and you can feel it breathing.

And the noise. The first time I heard the Fair Folk talk I thought there was a fair in the next valley, a crowd too far off to make out, rising and falling on the wind. That is their language. It is never one voice. It is a crowd far away, every word of it, even from a mouth an arm’s length from yours. You learn to catch words out of it the way you catch fish with your hands: by being still, and wanting nothing, and closing fast.

I am a tongue. That is the market’s word for it. I wear a ring of silver through the middle of my tongue, which Granny Ash put there with a hot needle when I was fourteen, and it makes me sworn. A tongue stands between the Folk and the valley and says to each what the other said. I have done it for nineteen years, every full moon, in the dry and the snow. Granny Ash taught me one rule before she taught me a single word, and made me say it back every night of my first winter.

Speak as. Never for.

I thought it meant: be honest. Most of us think that, in our first years.

The Folk pay the valley in cures and weather and luck. They pay us tongues in small forgettings. At moonset, before the hill closes, the Gleaner comes round with her soft face, and each of us gives her one thing we would rather not carry, and she eats it, and it is gone. A bad tooth. A quarrel. The smell of a fever room. I have given her most of a small room in my own house, over the years. I still have the room. There is a little bed in it. I have sold her, a month at a time, every reason I ever had for it.

That is enough about me. This is about the night Nell Tamsett brought her boy up the hill.


You must not bring a child to the Knap. It is the oldest rule there is. Older than coats turned inside out, older than no iron, older than never saying thank you. I saw them coming down the root stair a little after moonrise, Nell with her shawl over her head and a boy of six holding her hand, in his nightshirt and his father’s boots, looking at everything.

I went straight up to her, and she knew what I was going to say.

“There’s nobody to leave him with,” she said. “Col can’t get his breath. I couldn’t leave him with Col.”

Col Tamsett has worked the quarry since he was twelve, and the stone dust has been filling his chest for twenty years. Everyone in Lowstock knows how that ends. Nell had come for a cure. She had our currency in her pocket, the only kind we have: herself.

“Keep him by you,” I said. “Don’t let go of his hand. Don’t let him eat anything, whatever they hold out. Don’t say his name.”

“Pip,” the boy said, helpfully, to a will-o’-the-wisp, and its cage swung towards him.

I took them down the rows, because that is the job.

I will try to tell you what we passed, so you know what I mean when I say I was used to it.

A selkie stood at the stall of a tall gentleman of the Folk, bargaining for her own skin, which he was wearing as a cloak. It was grey and spotted and still wet, and it smelled of kelp, and she kept reaching up to touch the hem of it and taking her hand back. I translated for her. He wanted her voice for a year. She said yes before I had finished saying it.

At the next stall the Year-Tailor was working. He is a long grey thing like a heron in a waistcoat, with a tape round his neck and fingers as fine as tweezers, and he takes years in hair: one hair for one year, plucked from the head. It is always a grey hair, even from a girl of sixteen. He finds one. You feel each one go like a step missing on a stair in the dark, and then he winds them on a spindle of bone and they shine.

The Weigher sat in his own brass pan, no bigger than a hen, weighing a memory against a single feather. The memory came out of a farmer’s eye on a silver thread, slowly, the farmer weeping without seeming to know it, and wound itself on a bobbin, and the Weigher held it up to the moon and said it was light, it was a light one, he would give a dry week in June for it, no more.

The troll at the corner keeps his stall on his own tongue: you lay what you are buying on the wet grey shelf of it and he holds his jaw open for as long as it takes you to choose. Spiders the size of a man’s hand were knitting sold names into lace collars, and the ladies of the Folk wore the collars and stroked them and you could hear the names in them very faintly, crying to be called. The kelpie stood in his trough, a horse made of river with weed for a mane, offering rides that nobody took. Small hob children with hares’ bodies and the hands of little old men ran between our legs and laughed.

That is the other thing. The laughter. When the Folk laugh, the laugh comes first and the joke after, if it comes at all. You get used to that as well. I had got used to all of it.

Pip held his mother’s hand and looked at everything with his mouth open, and the far crowd of their talking rose and fell over us like weather.


Lady Sallow sells breath.

Her stall is the highest on the north terrace, a bower of blackthorn, and she sits in it like a moth in a lampshade. She is tall the way they all are, too tall by a hand, and her face is beautiful, and it arranges itself a moment late, as if it is being described to her as she goes. Her bottles hang from the thorns. In each is a breath, a clean one, a child’s or a girl’s or a runner’s at the top of a hill, and if you uncork it under a sick man’s nose and he breathes it in, it is his. Col’s lungs could be mended with one bottle.

Nell asked. I said it to Lady Sallow as Nell said it, word for word, as.

Lady Sallow looked down at Pip for a long time. Then she answered, and the answer came out of her as a crowd far off, and out of the crowd I caught it.

The boy. Seven years.


I want to tell you the truth about this part, because the rest of it depends on it.

I was not sure.

The far crowd is never sure. You catch the word in it that you are ready for. Granny Ash used to say a tired tongue hears what it fears and a greedy tongue hears what it wants, and a good tongue hears neither, and there are no good tongues, only careful ones. And there are words in their language that sit very close together. The word for a boy is close to the word for a breath. The word for years is close to the word for wool. I stood in front of Lady Sallow and I said to myself: you are tired, you have been on the hill five hours, a child is standing on the Knap against the oldest rule and you are frightened for him, and so you heard the thing you are frightened of.

I wanted that to be true. A tongue may ask once for a thing to be said again. It costs you a hair from your own head, which the Year-Tailor comes over to take, smiling. I paid it. I asked.

Lady Sallow laughed, first, and then said it again, the same rise and fall, the same crowd.

The boy. Seven years.

Or the breath, seven wools. I do not know. I knew then. I know now that I knew then, and I also know that I could not swear to it, and both of those are true.

And there is a part of me I have never told anyone about, and I will tell you, because you are owed it. It lives in the little room. It is the part that kept the bed. Every month I feed the Gleaner a piece of it, and every month there is a little less of it and it gets a little louder. It said to me, plainly, standing in front of Lady Sallow: not this one. You can save this one.

So I turned to Nell and said, “Seven years. Seven of your own.”

And I turned to Lady Sallow and said, in her tongue, “Seven years. Agreed.”

It was not a lie to either of them, you see. Not quite. Seven years was said both ways. I only left out whose.

Nell’s face went white and then set. She nodded. The Year-Tailor came and bent over her with his tweezers, and plucked seven grey hairs out of her dark head, one, two, three, and each time she swayed a little. When he was done there was a streak at her temple like frost on a ploughed field. Lady Sallow unhooked a bottle from the thorns and gave it to her. Nell held it against her chest with both hands.

The bells rang for the bargain, the way they do, up and down the rows.

Then they stopped.

Not all at once. They stopped at the far end of the north terrace first, and then the next stall, and the next. The far crowd of the Folk went quiet with them, a stall at a time. The quiet was coming up the row towards us like a tide coming over sand.


The valley calls him the Duke. Nobody in Lowstock can tell you who began calling him that, or why, and the Folk do not call him anything I have ever been able to catch.

He is the warden of the market. He is tall, but not as tall as they are. He wears a coat the colour of frost on a field and a hood that he never puts back, and under the hood there is shadow, and that is all I can tell you about his face, though I have stood closer to him than I am standing to this page. He carries the only iron allowed on the Knap: a key on a chain at his belt, black and plain, and the Folk lean away from it as he passes the way grass leans from wind. Where he walks, the market holds its breath.

He stopped at Lady Sallow’s bower. He did not look at me first. He looked at her.

“Content?” he said. He speaks our language. He is the only one on the hill who does not need a tongue.

Lady Sallow laughed, first, and then said that she was content.

He turned his hood to Nell. “Content?”

Nell held the bottle tighter. “Yes.”

Then he turned the hood to me. I stood there and felt the shadow in it rest on me like a hand.

“Tongue,” he said. “Whose words were those?”

“Hers,” I said.

He was quiet long enough for the wisps to beat against their cages twice.

“Then you’ve spoken for him,” he said.

That was all. He went on up the row, and behind him the bells started again, a stall at a time, and the far crowd came back over the market like rain after a gust. The market dog came and sniffed me then, the black one as big as a cart horse with eyes like a pair of lamps, and it whined, once, the way a dog whines at a door it does not want to go through.

I told myself the Duke had let it stand. That was the reason I gave myself on the root stair, and I said it to myself more than once. He had asked the buyer and the seller, and both had said content, and a bargain where both say content is a bargain. Spoken for was only the sort of thing they say on the Knap, like mind your step, a manner of speaking. If he had meant harm by it he would have done the harm. He had not done anything.

At moonset the Gleaner came round. She bent her soft face to mine, the furred grey wings of it, and asked me what I would give her this month.

I said: a sound. There was a sound I had heard that night that I did not want to keep.

She ate it from my eyelashes, and it was gone.


Pip held my hand on the way down. Not his mother’s. Mine. I did not think anything of it. Nell had the bottle in both hands, and she walked ahead of us down the sheep track in the grey light, fast, the way you walk with good news.

At her door she went in, and shut it.

I stood on the step with her son. I thought she had forgotten him in her hurry to get to Col, so I knocked. She opened the door with the bottle still in her hand and looked at me, and then down at Pip, kindly, the way you look at someone else’s child.

“Is he poorly, Mara?” she said. “You look done in, the both of you. Do you need something for him?”

“He’s yours,” I said.

She smiled the way you smile when someone says a thing that is not funny and you do not want them to feel it.

“Get him home to bed,” she said. “It’s cold for him.” And she shut the door.

I know about years. When the Year-Tailor takes them, people go strange for a night, light in the head, like after a bleeding. The miller’s wife sold three years one winter for her daughter’s eyes and did not know her own dog till the next evening. So I told myself that, standing on Nell’s step with her son’s hand in mine. It’s the years. By morning she’ll be at my door in a state, wanting him back. I said it out loud to Pip, and he nodded, because he was six and it was nearly dawn.

I took him home.

He went straight to the little room. I had not shown him where it was. He opened the door, climbed into the small bed I had kept for nothing all these years, pulled up the blanket, and slept as if he had slept there every night of his life.

I sat in the kitchen until it was light.


Nell did not come in the morning.

At the baker’s the girl gave Pip a heel of the loaf and said, “There you are, Pip, tell your mam she owes me a penny,” and looked at me. The smith’s wife stopped me in the lane to say how well he was looking. Old Hobb at the stile said I was not to let the lad near the quarry edge, the way he says it to every mother in Lowstock. Nobody said anything strange. That was the strange thing. Nobody in the whole valley had a single question for me.

I went to Nell’s at noon and said it plainly, on her own floor, with Col breathing in the next room clean and deep for the first time in years.

“Nell. Pip is your son. You had him in the spring six years ago. I was there. You took him up the Knap last night and you gave seven of your years, and I took his hand on the way down, and something has happened.”

Nell went pale under the frost streak in her hair. She sat down. She took both my hands, which she has never done.

“Mara, love,” she said. “I never had one. I never could. You know that. You sat with me after the second, you made the tea.” She looked into my face as if she were looking down a well. “You took that boy in yourself. Years ago. Don’t you remember?”

Behind her, through the door, Col called out, “Is that Mara? Tell her Pip can come for the pup if he wants it,” in a voice like a young man’s.

I went home. I told myself it was the years, still, and then that it was the night, and then that it was my own head. I had been on the hill nineteen years. Tongues go strange. Granny Ash went strange at the end. Perhaps I had taken a foundling in, years ago, and fed every piece of the taking to the Gleaner, and here he was. I tried that on, sitting at my table, and it fitted better than I wanted it to.


It was Granny Ash’s rule that undid it.

Speak as. Never for.

It does not mean be honest. I understood that at my kitchen table, with Pip asleep in the little room. It is not a rule about telling the truth at all. It is a rule about what happens to you. On the Knap, words are not like ours. They do not describe things. They are the things. If you speak as someone, the words pass through you like water through a pipe, and leave you clean. If you speak for someone, if you put your own word where theirs should be, then what you spoke for is yours. You hold it. Granny Ash was not teaching me manners. She was telling me the price.

I had spoken for him. So I held him. And a thing that is held by one cannot be held by another, and so the valley, which is very simple about these matters, had simply moved him from Nell’s hand to mine, and closed up over the place he had been, like water.

And then I thought: but what did she ask for?

I reached for it. Lady Sallow in her bower, the bottles in the thorns, the long look down at the boy, the far crowd coming out of her mouth. I had heard it twice. I had paid a hair to hear it twice.

There was nothing there. A smooth place, like the gap where a tooth was.

I had given it to the Gleaner myself, at moonset, with her soft face an inch from mine. A sound I did not want to keep. I had chosen it. I had not even had to think. Some part of me had known exactly which sound to give her, the only one that could ever tell me whether I had saved that boy or taken him.


I went up the Knap the next night. The moon was one night past full and already going, and the market does not come for a moon that is going. The hill was only a hill, sheep and turf and wind combing the grass flat. I did not expect anyone.

He was sitting on the stone at the top of the sheep track, where the root stair comes up on market nights, as if it were any night at all. The hood was up. The key lay on his knee.

“Tongue,” he said, before I was close enough to be seen.

“What did she ask for?”

“You were the tongue.”

“I don’t remember it. I gave it away.”

“Yes.”

I stood in front of him with the wind pulling at my shawl, and I asked him again, and again, until I heard my voice go high like a child’s, and he waited until I had finished, and then he told me how it stood. He did not say it kindly and he did not say it cruelly. He said it the way you read out a list.

The moon was going. Until it was dark, I could unsay it. If I unsaid it, the bargain would go back to what had been said at the bower, whatever that was, and the valley would open again where it had closed. If Lady Sallow had asked for Nell’s years, then Nell would have her son back in her arms by morning and would never know he had been gone. If Lady Sallow had asked for the boy, then the boy would go under the hill for seven years, and Nell would remember him every day of them.

“And if I don’t unsay it?”

“Then he’s yours,” the Duke said. “And what’s spoken for on the Knap keeps a little of the Knap.”

“What does that mean?”

He did not answer that. He never does. He only turned the hood towards the valley, where my house was, where there was a lamp in the little room’s window that I had not lit.

I want to tell you that I stood on that hill and weighed it like the Weigher, the boy against the feather. I did not. I made the reasons, one after another, quickly, the way you pile stones against a door. Seven years under the hill is not seven years; the ones who come back eat nothing, and talk to no one, and walk out into the river in the end. Nell does not grieve. Col does not grieve. Nobody in all of Lowstock grieves, not for a single hour. Only one person would know anything was wrong, and that person is me, and I can carry it. I am used to carrying things up and down that hill.

All of those reasons were true. None of them was why. The little room was why. I could hear it, standing on the stone, louder than the wind. It had never been so loud. It had never had anything to want before.

I did not unsay it.

The Duke stood up. He did not say anything about the choice. He did not tell me it was wrong, or right. He looked at me a moment longer from inside the hood, and then he was not on the stone any more, and I had not seen him walk.


This is for you, Pip. I am going to fold it up and put it in the tin under the little bed, and you can have it when you are grown, if you ever wonder. Somebody on the Knap will tell you one day. Better you hear it first from me, and in our own words, the plain ones that mean only what they say.

The moon went dark, and then it came round again. On the night it was full you got out of the little bed and stood at the window, in your nightshirt, facing the Knap. I did not go up the hill that night. I stood in the doorway and watched you.

You started to talk. It was not our language. It came out of you like a crowd a long way off, rising and falling, in my own house, the sound I have spent nineteen years learning to catch words from.

I am a sworn tongue. I caught every one.

You were asking for your mother.

You did not mean me.