The Sphinx Toll
By Strange Light Dark fantasy 17 min
Before you go in
- Death by a monster, and human remains
- Death of a parent, and a child made complicit in it
- Sacrifice of a person to save others
The sphinx sings her riddle at first light, and in Tollfoot the eggs crack in their baskets.
You feel it before you hear it. A hum in the roof tiles, then in your teeth, then the whole town ringing like a pot that has been struck, and then her voice comes down the Throat, the one pass through the Ash Mountains, a voice like a bronze bell the size of a house, and every word of it arrives whole. The goats kneel. Dogs lie flat. The bone-crows lift off the mountain in a black sheet and wheel and settle again. And on the Answer Steps in the market, forty sellers under forty dyed awnings stop breathing and listen, because whoever solves it first eats that day, and whoever solves it best eats well.
That morning she sang:
I have teeth and never bite. I go through the mane and leave it whole. Once a year I am made of the dead.
I had it before the echo came back off the Fang. A comb. The last line was a gift: every spring the girls of Tollfoot climb under truce to comb her mane, with combs cut from the ribs on the Stair. By the time the bell-hum had left my teeth I had my chalk out, and by the time the first caravan master came up the Steps with his purse open, I was the only seller writing a price.
I am good at it. I want that said before the rest, because the rest is going to make it sound like I was a fool.
The hooded man came at noon, when the comb had sold out and I was packing my scales.
Everyone in Tollfoot has seen a hooded man. Travellers come up from the salt flats with their faces wrapped against the ash, and you learn not to look. But this one had his hood up in the shade of my awning, where there was no ash, and inside it there was nothing to see. Not darkness exactly. More the way the inside of a well is not dark, only deep.
“Today’s is sold,” I said.
“I know,” he said. His voice was low and courteous and from nowhere I could name. “I’d like tomorrow’s.”
Nobody sells forward. It is the first thing Ush teaches an apprentice, before the scales, before the chalk. You sell the answer to a riddle you have heard. A forward answer is a promise, and a seller who cannot keep a promise to the mountain goes up the mountain herself at dusk to explain why. Over the door of the Guild house it is carved with the other old sayings, the ones nobody reads any more. We do not sell forward. We do not climb. Nobody sells her own name.
I told him the price was triple. I said it to make him go away.
He held out his hand, gloved, and put a coin in my scale pan.
I sell by weight. A buyer’s silver goes in one pan and my mark goes in the other, a lead weight stamped with my sign, and the silver must pull it down. His one coin was heavy as a hen’s egg and stamped with no face I knew. The pans swung, and dipped, and came to rest.
Level. Exactly level. Scales never stand level. There is always a hair in it.
Up on the mountain, high above the town, I heard the bones settle on the Stair. A long dry clatter, like dice shaken in a cup, and then nothing.
“Tomorrow’s,” he said. “Whatever it is.”
I took the coin. I am going to be honest about why.
I rent my seat on the Steps from Ush, who is Guild-mother and owns nine seats and has owned them since before I was born. Every season I give her a third of what I take. Forty silver buys a seat outright, and I had thirty-one, and the pass closes for the winter in nine days when the snow comes down on the ash. One coin like that would see me to forty with something over. My own seat. My own awning. Nobody’s third.
And I thought: what can a forward answer cost a seller as good as me? She sings, I solve, I find him, I whisper. It is only a morning’s work done in advance.
Ush saw it from across the market. She is old and small and walks with two sticks, and she was across the Steps and under my awning before I had finished wrapping the coin.
“You sold forward,” she said.
“He paid triple.”
“He’d have paid anything.” She looked at the coin in my hand without touching it. “Where is he?”
He was going up the Stair.
The Ossuary Stair is the path up the Throat. It is not a stair, and it is not built. It is six hundred years of the people who answered wrong, raked into a slope by the bone-sweepers so that the living have something to walk on. White and grey and yellow, skulls and long bones and the little bones of hands, packed with ash, and it shifts under your feet and settles behind you. Sellers do not climb it. We do not climb. Buyers climb it alone with our answers sealed on their lips.
He climbed it with no answer at all, because there was nothing to answer yet. Brask, the salt merchant, who had the last big caravan of the season camped at the river gate, lent me his spyglass, and at dusk I found him: a small dark shape on the ledge by the toll-stone, sitting with his back against the sphinx’s forepaw like a man against a wall.
She did not eat him. She lay across the pass with her chin on her paws, and he sat beside one of them, and the two of them watched the sun go down over the salt.
I need you to see her, or none of this will matter.
She fills the Throat from wall to wall, the way a cork fills a bottle. Her body is a lion’s, tawny once and now the grey-gold of brass under ash, and ash lies on her back in drifts that slide off when she breathes. Her wings are folded along her sides like the sails of two great ships furled, and bone-crows nest in the feathers. Her claws are each the length of a man, and where she flexes them the basalt is scored in grooves you could lie down in. Her tail goes back over the pass and down the far side of the mountain, and nobody has ever seen the end of it.
And her face is a woman’s face. Broad as a threshing floor, heavy-lidded, calm. The girls paint her lips with cinnabar at the spring combing, so they are always red, a little cracked, like a mouth that has been out in the cold.
I sold my first answer to that face when I was thirteen. Ush gave me the riddle as my test. It was a balance. The same month, my mother went up the Throat in an ash fever, the way people sometimes do, walking in their sleep towards the voice. She was the weigher at the river gate. We never found her on the Stair. You don’t, usually.
At first light the hum came into the tiles, and into my teeth, and the sphinx sang.
I weigh what I never made. I sit at the foot and never climb. My seat is not my own. My first coin paid for my mother’s road. I sell the last word and keep none.
And then, where she always says what am I, in six hundred years of the Book of Tolls, she said:
Who am I?
The town was very quiet after.
I was sitting on my seat with my chalk in my hand. I did not move. I could feel the Steps around me, forty awnings, forty sellers, and I could feel each of them turning, one after another, the way grass turns in wind, until every face on the Answer Steps was looking at me.
I said it out loud, to the market, before anyone else could say anything. I had to.
“It’s a broker,” I said. “A grain broker. Any seller on the Steps. It fits a hundred people. Riddles are cut to fit.”
I wanted that to be true so badly that I tried the lines on everyone I could think of. A broker weighs what he never made, yes. Sits at the foot, never climbs, yes. His seat not his own, if he rents his stall. Sells the last word. Fine. My first coin paid for my mother’s road.
What broker? Whose mother? It did not fit them. It did not fit anyone, unless you knew that a girl of thirteen had sold her first answer the month her mother walked up the Throat. And everyone on the Steps knew that, because it was me.
Then I did what we do on the Steps when a riddle points at a person: I looked for the thing. Every seller knows the trick. A riddle that sounds like a man can usually be answered with an object, and the object is safer to sell. A balance weighs what it never made. It sits at the foot of a stall and never climbs. Its seat is not its own. It gives the last word on a price and keeps none of the money. I said it out loud: a balance. Old Fenn on the next seat nodded, too quickly.
My first coin paid for my mother’s road.
A balance has no mother. The line would not take it. I tried a ferry, a well-bucket, a toll-gate, and that one line stopped every one of them, the way a single wrong tooth stops a key.
“Coincidence, then,” I said, and heard how thin it was.
Brask came up the Steps with his caravan master behind him. He is a big soft man in good wool with salt in the creases of his hands, and he had a hundred and forty beasts at the river gate eating fodder that cost him silver every hour the pass stayed shut.
“So answer it, girl,” he said, cheerfully. “Sell me Saba. I’ll pay you double and say your name to the cat myself, and we’ll all be over the mountain by noon.”
Nobody laughed.
Ush said it, from her chair under the Guild house porch, without raising her voice. “Nobody on the Steps will sell her name to you, Master Brask. It is not done.”
“Then I’ll say it unsold.”
“An unsold answer is a theft,” Ush said. “She eats thieves first and asks after.” She looked at me. “And the answer is sold already. Forward. It is owed to the man on the ledge, and it falls due at dusk.”
Then she told the market what everyone but Brask already knew. A riddle stays sung until it is answered. Nobody crosses. The Throat shuts. And a seller who owes a forward answer and does not deliver it by dusk goes up the Stair herself and stands before the stone.
So that was the shape of it. Sell my name to the hooded man, and he would carry it up and say it, and she would take what it named. Or don’t, and walk up at dusk and be taken anyway. And Brask’s beasts would starve at the river gate and the snow would come down in eight days, and the whole of Tollfoot would remember whose name had shut the pass.
I tried one more explanation that morning, and it was the worst one, because it made me feel better.
He did it. The man in the hood. He had sat all night beside her paw. He had told her about me. He was some rival from the salt towns, some old enemy of the Guild’s, and he had bought my answer forward so that I would be bound when he gave her my life to riddle on. A trick. A cruel one, but a man’s trick, which a woman could hate and understand.
He came down the Stair at noon.
The bones settled under him all the way down, a long rattle following him like a dog. The crows got out of his way. High above him the sphinx had lifted her head off her paws to watch him go, which she never does for anyone, and the whole town saw it, and the town stood back from the bottom of the slope to let him through. He walked straight across the market to my awning and stood in the shade of it with his hood up and the deep nothing inside it.
“You owe me an answer,” he said.
“You told her about me.”
“I don’t ask the riddles.” He said it gently, as though I were a child who had blamed the rain on the man carrying the umbrella. Then he asked me a question of his own. It was the only one he asked.
“What did you sell first?”
The Book of Tolls is kept in the Guild house on a lectern, and the Guild-mother keeps it. It is not one book. It is two hundred, chained in a row, the oldest crumbling, and every day for six hundred years has a line. The riddle. The answer. Who sold it. And a last column, headed Paid, which I had always taken for a tally of the people she ate. Strangers, mostly. Caravan boys who would not pay a seller’s price and tried their own wit on the stone.
It smells of tallow and mice and old ink, and the chains clink when you turn a page, so that you always know in the Guild house when somebody is reading. Ush let me in. She did not stop me. She sat in her chair with her two sticks across her knees and watched me find the year.
The riddle was there in a hand I knew, small and careful, because I had written it myself, at thirteen, with Ush’s hand over mine.
I stand at the gate and judge, and am no judge. I hold the salt of strangers and am not paid in it. I tell the truth by leaning.
Answer: the scales at the river gate. I remembered being proud of that. Ush had always said: be exact, the mountain likes exact.
Sold by: Saba, apprentice. First sale.
Paid: Hela, weigher at the river gate.
My mother.
I turned the pages back. Not every day. But often enough. Once a season, perhaps, a riddle whose honest answer was a person of Tollfoot, and a seller who had found a thing that fitted it as well. The bread oven on Tanners’ Row. Paid: Oda, baker. The ferry. Paid: Lem, ferryman. And every few years, on the line of an apprentice’s first sale, a name with the same family as the seller’s.
I found Ush’s. Sixty-one years back. First sale. Paid: her mother.
I stood at the lectern with my hand flat on the page, and I understood the sayings over the door at last. Nobody sells her own name. No. You sell your mother’s, at thirteen, when you are too young to know, and then you are a seller, and you are the town’s, and the pass stays open, and the salt comes over the mountain, and Tollfoot is rich.
“It’s how the mountain knows you’re ours,” Ush said behind me. Her voice was very tired. “It was done to me. I did it to you. I am sorry, Saba. It is the toll.”
I turned round to look at her, the old Guild-mother in her chair, and as I did, the riddle sang itself through my head again, line by line. I could not stop it. It is what I am for.
I weigh what I never made. She did, for forty years on the Steps. I sit at the foot and never climb. Never. My seat is not my own. It is the Guild’s chair; she only sits in it. My first coin paid for my mother’s road. There it was, in the book under my hand. I sell the last word and keep none.
It fitted her. Every line.
She saw me see it. She did not move. She only closed her eyes, the way the sphinx does when she is considering an answer, and sat there with her sticks across her knees.
He was waiting under my awning at dusk.
I could still go up myself. I want that understood. Nobody was holding me. I could walk up the Stair with my answer unsold and stand before the stone and let her take what the riddle meant, and Ush would keep her chair, and in the spring she would give some other child of thirteen a riddle about the bread oven.
I took the coin out of my apron, heavy as an egg, and held it. I thought about my mother at the river gate with salt on her hands, and Ush’s hand over mine on the chalk.
Then I put it back in my apron and stood up and said, “Bend down.”
You whisper an answer behind your raised hand, into the buyer’s ear, so nobody on the Steps can take it for free. Then you seal it: you press your thumb into the ash and touch it to his lips, and a sealed answer cannot be spoken by anyone but him.
I put my mouth to the side of his hood. There was no ear that I could find, only the cold of the deep inside it, and I said into it, “The Guild-mother of Tollfoot.”
I dipped my thumb in the ash. I reached into the hood, and found his mouth by touch in the dark, and pressed. I could not tell you what I touched. It was cold, and it did not move.
“Seller stands at the stone for a forward answer,” he said. “That is the custom.”
So I climbed.
You do not walk the Ossuary Stair, you wade it. The bones take your feet to the ankle and let go grudgingly, and behind you they settle with that dry dice-cup rattle, and the bone-crows walk beside you on the slope like dogs, big as dogs, watching your hands. The walls of the Throat are black glass, ash-streaked, and the wind comes down it hot and smelling of lion and old brass. Ash falls up there all the time, fine and grey, like snow that has given up. Halfway, we passed the bone-sweepers’ rakes standing upright in the slope where they leave them, iron tines rusted orange, and a crow worrying a ring off a finger that had been on the Stair longer than Tollfoot has had a name. Then the breath reached us. She breathes once to every twenty of yours, and each one comes down the Throat like the door of a bread oven opening, and the bones on the surface of the slope stir and lift and fall back with it. He went ahead of me, steady, and never once looked back.
At the top the slope flattens into the ledge, and the ledge ends at the toll-stone, a slab of black glass polished by six hundred years of knees. And past the stone, filling the whole sky, she was.
She lifted her head from her paws when we came. Ash poured off her mane in a long grey fall. The face came down out of the dusk towards us, slow as a moon setting, until it hung over the stone, and the red cracked lips were higher than a house above me and the eyes were each the size of a cartwheel and gold all through, with no white at all.
He knelt at the stone and laid both hands flat on it, as the custom is. I stood behind him on the bones.
She sang the riddle again, down at us, and the bell of it went through me so that my teeth rang and my knees went.
He answered. His voice was quiet. It carried anyway.
“The Guild-mother of Tollfoot.”
She closed her eyes.
The lids came down like two hides pulled over a doorway, slow, and the gold went out of the dusk. Nothing moved on the mountain. The wind stopped. The crows did not stir. And in the silence, under my feet, the Stair began to settle.
It went slowly at first, a trickle, a rattle, like a cup being shaken far away. Then more. The bones slid from under my heels, and I sank to my shins, and then to my knees, the long bones pouring round me with that dry dice sound, louder, louder, the whole white slope behind me beginning to move, and I understood that if she said no, it would not stop, and I would go down into it with my mother and everyone else who had answered wrong.
I did not pray. Sellers don’t. I knelt in the bones up to my waist and watched her closed eyes.
She opened them.
Yes, she said.
The bones stopped.
She lifted her right forepaw from the stone, slowly, the whole vast weight of it, the way a gate is lifted, and the man in the hood stood up and walked under it, over the top of the pass, and down the far side into the dark. He did not turn round. Then the paw came down, and the sphinx laid her chin on it, and looked at me.
For a long time she looked. I knelt there in the bones and let her. Then she closed her eyes again, and I dug myself out and went down.
Ush walked up the Stair that night. I watched from the Steps. She left her sticks leaning against the Guild house door, and she went up without them, slowly, but straight, the way people do when they are walking towards the voice. About halfway, I heard the bones settle, a long way off, a little rattle like dice. Then nothing.
In the morning the eggs cracked in their baskets, and the sphinx sang about a well, and Brask’s caravan went over the mountain, all hundred and forty beasts. My seat on the Steps is my own now. So are the other eight.
I keep the Book of Tolls. That is the Guild-mother’s work, and I am the Guild-mother. I have written this in the back of the last volume, for whoever keeps it after me, so that you know what the columns mean before you give a child her first riddle.
I filled in yesterday’s line myself. Riddle. Answer: the Guild-mother of Tollfoot. Sold by: Saba. Paid: Ush.
It was a good answer. Exact. The mountain likes exact.
It is still a good answer. It fits whoever is sitting in this chair.