Lasting Power

By Streetlight Supernatural horror 17 min

Demon stories Psychological horror Plague and medical horror

Before you go in
  • Dementia, and caring for a husband with early-onset Alzheimer's
  • Cancer and chemotherapy, in the past
  • A bargain with the devil

You have asked for my account of why I refused, on my husband’s behalf, a private treatment that might have given him his memory back, and I will give it, but you should know before you read any further that it was not a treatment.

My son has told you I did not consult anyone. That is true. I will explain that as well.

My name is Maureen Whitworth. I hold both of Philip Whitworth’s Lasting Powers of Attorney, the one for property and financial affairs and the one for health and welfare, registered with your office three years ago. Phil is sixty-four. He was diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer’s at sixty. He worked at the forge for forty years and was a union rep for twenty of them, and he is still the most stubborn man in Hillsborough when he knows who he is. I keep every piece of paper that has ever come into this house, in labelled folders, in the sideboard. I was a school business manager. You will find my account is in order.

The man from the firm came on Tuesday the third of March, at three o’clock in the afternoon.

He wiped his feet before I had opened the door all the way. Fifty or so, clean-shaven, a good grey overcoat, the kind with a velvet collar that nobody wears any more. A leather document wallet under his arm. He said, “Mrs Whitworth? I’m sorry to call unannounced. I’ve come about Phil’s agreement. The one from 2014.”

I said we had no agreements with anybody that I did not know about.

He opened the wallet and showed me a single sheet. He did not hand it to me. He held it so I could read it, the way a solicitor holds a will for a family who might tear it.

It was Phil’s handwriting. In the blue-black ink he used in his fountain pen, the one he signed every union paper with for twenty years. A few lines. “I agree to the terms as discussed. Payable by instalments, from my sixtieth birthday.” His signature, with the W crossed the way he crosses it, like a man striking out a line. And beside it a thumbprint, in something brown and rusty that had soaked into the paper. The date was written at the top in his hand: Tuesday 11 March 2014, 3 a.m.

I had my first chemotherapy at Weston Park on Monday the tenth of March 2014.

From the front room, behind me, Phil called out, clear as a bell, “Tell him it’s paid.”

Then, after a moment, in his other voice, the one he has now: “Who’s at the door, love?”


I shut the door. I am not proud of how hard. The man said through it, quite unbothered, “I’ll call again next Tuesday, Mrs Whitworth. There’s no hurry. There never is, with us.”

I stood in the hall until I heard the gate.

I want you to know what I thought, because it was the sensible thing to think and I thought it properly.

People like us are a market. I knew that before Phil was ill. I spent eleven years in a school office fielding emails from people pretending to be the head, asking me to change the bank details for the catering contract. Families of people with dementia get letters, calls, men at the door. Somebody had seen the envelopes in our recycling: the memory clinic, the hospital, the council. Somebody had watched the house. A clever fraudster does his homework, and a sheet with a thumbprint on it is exactly the kind of theatre that frightens a tired woman into signing something.

I wanted that to be true more than I can tell you. A fraud is a crime. A crime can be reported. You ring Action Fraud and you get a reference number, and I did, that same afternoon, and I wrote the number on a sticky label and put it on a new folder.

Then I tested it, because that is what I do.

The signature first. I took out the folder marked HOUSE 2014 and found our home insurance renewal, which Phil signed in April of that year, and our anniversary card from the same June. The same W. The same tail on the h. The same pen, I would have said, though I am not an expert. I sat at the kitchen table with the three of them side by side in my head and I could not make them different.

The date second. This is the part I could not get past. Nobody knew the date of my first chemotherapy except Phil and the hospital. Liam was in his second year at Leeds and we did not tell him until it was over, because he had exams, and that was Phil’s decision and I agreed with it. I did not tell my sister. I did not tell work; I was off sick and that was all they knew. There was no letter in any recycling bin in 2014 with that date on it, because I kept them all. They are in a folder marked WESTON PARK.

And I remembered the night. I had not thought about it in years. I woke at three o’clock, sick and frightened, and Phil’s side of the bed was cold, and there was a line of light under the door of Liam’s old room. I lay there and listened to the house. I could hear his pen. That small dry scratch a nib makes, steady, like someone writing a long letter. I thought he was writing to Liam. I thought he was doing it so as not to wake me. I went back to sleep.

Four months later my consultant told me I was in remission, and used the word remarkable, and then used it again, as if he had not expected to need it.


On the Saturday I went through Phil’s union scrapbook. I told myself I wanted more signatures. I think I wanted to look at him when he was whole.

It is a big red album with the corners gone soft. Cuttings from the Star, ballot papers, his first branch card with the corner bent where he kept it in his wallet. And photographs. Phil was eighteen in the winter of 1980, when the steel strike started, and he went down to the picket at the Hadfields gate in February with half the lads from his shift. There is a photo from the Star of the big day, hundreds of men in donkey jackets packed against a line of police, breath steaming, and in the front of it, there, is Phil, all ears and hair, shouting something.

Behind him, in the second row, is a man who is not shouting.

Clean-shaven. A good grey overcoat with a velvet collar. Looking not at the police but at the boy in front of him, the way you look at a house you mean to buy.

He has not aged. I looked for a long time, with my reading glasses and then with the magnifier Phil used for his stamps.

I tried the sensible things first, the way I had with the signature. Newspaper photographs from 1980 are grain and shadow, and half the men in Sheffield wore grey coats. A face like that is a common face: neat, pleasant, forgettable. He could be the father of the man on my doorstep, or an uncle, and a family firm might have a type. I wanted it to be a resemblance, because a resemblance is only an odd afternoon. I took the photograph out of its sleeve and held it under the kitchen light next to my memory of him, and I counted the things that matched, the way I would check an invoice against an order. The velvet collar. The parting. The leather wallet tucked under the left arm. A small pale scar through the right eyebrow, which I had noticed on the doorstep because I was looking anywhere but at the sheet.

I am telling you as a careful woman that it is the same face. Forty-six years, and the same face, and the same coat.

I put the album away and went and sat with Phil in the front room. He was in his chair by the window, watching the people come and go from the park. I asked him if he remembered Hadfields. He smiled and said, “Valentine’s Day. We shut it.”

I asked him if he remembered a man in a grey coat.

He stopped smiling. He looked at me as though he were trying to work out who had let me in. “Tell him it’s paid,” he said.


Here is what happened on the Tuesdays, because you will want it in order.

Until March it had been slow, the way the consultant said it would be. A word here, a face there, over months. Then it went onto a timetable.

On Tuesday the third, at three in the morning, twelve hours before the man first knocked, I woke to a sound in Liam’s room and thought I had dreamt it. I only placed it later. In the morning Phil did not know his sister’s name. He had known it the day before. He has not known it since. I put it down to the illness, because at that point there was nothing else to put it down to.

On the tenth, at three, I heard it again and this time I was awake. The same dry scratch I had heard in 2014, steady, unhurried. I got up and opened the door. Nobody there. Liam’s single bed made up, his posters long gone, the desk bare, no pen, no paper. The sound stopped when the door opened. In the morning, he could not tie his shoes. He sat on the edge of the bed with the laces in his hands, looking at them as if they were a knot somebody else had made, and I knelt and did them, and he said, “Ta, love,” and I said it was nothing.

I told myself what anybody would. An old house ticks at night. The pipes cool, the joists settle, and a woman who has not slept a full night in two years will hear a pen in it if a pen is what she is frightened of. And the illness goes at its own pace, which is no pace at all, and I was only noticing Tuesdays because a stranger had put Tuesdays in my head. I wanted that very much. It meant the only thing wrong in the house was me.

So on the sixteenth I turned the heating off at the boiler and let the house go cold, and I sat up in Liam’s room in my coat, on his bed, with the light off.

At three the nib began. Not in the walls. In the room, at the desk, a yard from my knees. I could hear it reach the end of a line and go back. I put my hand out to the desk and there was nothing on it but the cold.

In the morning, the seventeenth, Phil had lost the word for spoon. On the twenty-fourth, the way home from the park, which is three hundred yards and one road.

I know what Bev would say, because I asked her.

Bev is a nurse at the memory clinic. She has looked after Phil for three years and she is kind in the way only people who have seen everything are kind. When we went in on the nineteenth I waited until Phil was with the consultant and I asked her whether this illness could go on a timetable. Whether a person could lose something every week, on the same night.

“It can feel like that, Maureen,” she said. “It often does.”

I asked her whether any of the other families had ever mentioned a man from a firm.

She looked at me for a moment longer than I liked. Then she put her hand on my arm. “We see a lot of scams, love. Don’t sign anything. Ring me if he comes back.”

That is all she said. I have gone over it many times. It confirms nothing.


I should go back. He came back on the afternoon of the tenth, as he had said he would. I let him in. I would like to say I did it to gather evidence, and that is partly true. Mostly I wanted to know.

He sat on the settee with his coat folded over the arm and his document wallet on his knees and he did not look at the room the way visitors do. Phil looked at him from the chair by the window and said, “You’re early,” and then looked out at the park again.

“I’ll be brief,” the man said. “Mr Whitworth’s account is being settled as agreed. I’m not here about that. I’m here because the firm permits a variation, in certain cases, and it falls to you to decide on it.”

“What variation?”

“Mr Whitworth restored. Fully. As he was the year before his sixtieth birthday. Everything we have collected, returned to him.” He said it as if he were reading out a mortgage rate. “The balance would transfer to you.”

“What balance?”

“The remainder of what was given in 2014.”

I asked him what had been given in 2014.

He looked at me with great patience. “You were, Mrs Whitworth.”

I am trying to set this down plainly. I said, “You want my life.”

“What is left of it. In exchange for his mind, which is a fair price, I think, for a woman who has spent four years watching it go. He would remember you. He would have Liam back, and his sister, and his shoes.”

“And you can’t ask him, because he can’t consent. So you’ve come to me.”

“You hold his power of attorney for property and financial affairs. What he pledged was his own. It is, in the strictest sense, a property matter.” He smiled a little. “We have always been very careful about the paperwork.”

“You’re the devil,” I said.

He did not deny it. He did not say anything at all. He took a second sheet out of the wallet and laid it on the coffee table, face down, and stood, and put on his coat. “I’ll leave you the papers,” he said. “I’ll call on the thirty-first for your answer. There’s no hurry.”

There were three Tuesdays between that afternoon and the thirty-first. He knew I could count them.

When he had gone I rang Liam.

I did not tell him what I have told you. I could not find the words that would not make him drive down the M1 that night with a social worker. I told him a man had offered a private treatment that might bring his dad back, and that it would cost me everything.

“Then we’ll find the money,” Liam said. “We’ll remortgage. I’ll sell the car. Mum, what do you mean everything?”

“I don’t mean money.”

“Then what do you mean?”

I did not answer him. He went quiet on the line, the way his father does. Then he said, gently, “You’re exhausted. You haven’t slept properly in two years. Let me come down this weekend.”

I said not this weekend. That was when he started to worry about me, and I understand it.


Over those weeks I read everything your office publishes. I read the Mental Capacity Act. I read the guidance for attorneys three times, with a highlighter. I know what you will ask me, because I asked it myself.

An attorney must act in the person’s best interests. She must consider, among other things, the person’s past and present wishes and feelings, and in particular any relevant written statement made when he had capacity. She must, where practicable, consult others.

So on the twenty-fourth, a week before his third call, which he had booked as politely as a dentist’s appointment, I took both of Phil’s LPAs out of the sideboard, to find what written statement there was.

I had not read them since the day they came back registered. I filled them in at the kitchen table three years ago, with Phil beside me, because his hands had started to shake and mine had not. He told me what to put and I wrote it. I remember him insisting that the same instruction go in both forms, the money one as well as the health one, and I remember thinking it was a mistake and that your office would send it back. You did not.

I thought I knew what it said. I thought it was the usual thing. No tubes, no heroics, let me go when it is time. I had been carrying that version of it for three years.

I read the box for instructions, in my own handwriting.

My attorneys must say no if anyone offers to bring me back. Maureen, it’s paid.


I sat on the kitchen floor with the form on my knees for a long time.

He knew. Three years ago, with the diagnosis still new, he knew the man would come, and he knew who the man would come to, and he knew what I would want to say. He had me write it myself, so I could not tell myself afterwards that somebody else had put the words there.

It’s paid. He had been saying it to me all month and I had been hearing it as illness.

And the rest came after it, the way it does once one thing gives. Phil, who had not set foot in a church since his wedding, going every Sunday after my remission, sitting at the back, never going up. “Somebody ought to say thank you,” he told me, and I thought it was the sweetest thing he had ever said. The boy at the Hadfields gate with the man behind him, looking at him like a house he meant to buy. I do not know what was asked of Phil in 1980, or what he answered. But in 2014, when I was dying, he knew where to go.


The man came for the third time on Tuesday the thirty-first of March, at three.

When I came back from letting him in, Phil’s fountain pen was on the coffee table. Uncapped. It lives in the bureau, in its box. I had not taken it out. Phil was in his chair by the window with his hands folded in his lap, watching the park.

The man turned the second sheet face up. It was short. My full name, typed. A line for a signature, and under it: Philip Whitworth, by his attorney, Maureen Whitworth.

“His own pen,” the man said. “I thought you’d want that.”

I asked him why it had to be in pieces. Why a word on a Tuesday, and then a name, and then his shoes. Why not all at once, if it was owed.

“Those were his terms,” he said. “He asked for instalments. He wanted time with you. Eight good years before the first instalment fell due, and four since, and he’s had them.” He looked across at Phil, quite kindly. “Most people ask for time. Very few of them think about what it will be like to spend it.”

“And if I say no, it goes on.”

“As agreed. Until it’s settled.”

“How long?”

“That isn’t a figure we disclose.” He folded his hands over the wallet. “I will say that the arrangement on offer is a good deal simpler. One signature. Nothing by instalments. You’d have the summer, I should think, the two of you, and he’d know you for all of it.”

I picked up the pen. I want you to know I picked it up. It was warm, as if somebody had just been holding it.

I am not going to pretend I did not want to sign. I have not slept properly in two years, as Liam says. I have washed my husband and fed him and told him who I am at four in the morning more times than I can count, and I would have given him what is left of my life gladly, and I think most people who have done this would say the same. It would have been a good trade. He would have had perhaps twenty years. I would have had the knowledge that I gave them to him.

And it would have been my decision, made in his name, against the only instruction he ever wrote for exactly this.

The law says I must act in his best interests. It says I must take into account his wishes, and in particular anything he put in writing when he could. He put it in writing. He made me put it in writing. I can think of no clearer wish a man could leave.

As for consulting others, I did not consult Liam, because Liam would have said yes. Anybody would. That is why Phil left the instruction to me, and not to the people who love him less sensibly.

I put the cap back on the pen.

“No,” I said. “On his behalf. As his attorney.”

The man waited, in case there was more. When there was not, he nodded, the way a good solicitor nods when a client has made a decision he would not have made himself but will defend to anyone.

“Then we go on as agreed,” he said.

He put the sheet back in the wallet. On the way out he stopped at the sideboard and put a card in the fruit bowl, between the bananas and the satsumas, a plain white card. “The offer stands, Mrs Whitworth. It always does.”

Phil did not look round when the door shut. He was watching a man walk a dog across the park.


That is my account. I know what it reads like, and I know you will draw your own conclusions about my state of mind, and I would ask you only to look at the documents, which I have enclosed in order, with copies of the LPA instruction, the Action Fraud reference, and the photograph from the Star.

One more thing, because it is the reason I am sure.

On an evening in May, a Wednesday, I was clearing the tea things and Phil said from his chair, “Has the man from the firm been?”

It was his voice. His own, from before. I put the plates down.

“Yes,” I said.

He looked at me. He knew me. I have not been looked at like that for two years.

“Did you say no?”

“Yes.”

“Good lass,” he said.

Then it went, the way the light goes off the park in the evening, all at once, and he looked at me politely and asked me my name.

The card is still in the fruit bowl. I have not thrown it away, and you may make of that what you like. On Tuesdays at three in the morning I still hear the nib, in Liam’s old room, where nobody sleeps. It is not writing anything new. It is keeping the account.