The Farewell Rock

By Candlelight Historical horror 11 min

Cosmic horror

Before you go in
  • Entrapment underground and the threat of suffocation
  • A child in mortal danger
  • Death of a trapped miner
  • An animal in distress

The top comes in at ten past eleven, and I know the time because Ifor Price has his watch open to see if it is food yet.

There is no crack first. There is a sound like a door being shut in a big house, and then the air is solid. It fills my mouth and my eyes. Captain screams in the shafts of the dram and I hold his head by the bridle and he nearly lifts me off the rail.

When the dust thins I count. It is the first thing you are taught.

Ifor, on his knees by the face, still holding the watch. Tomos, the door boy, flat against the side where he dropped. Captain, trembling, whole. Me.

Three men and a horse.

Two lamps. Ifor’s and mine. Tomos had his put out on the way in because it was smoking, and the lamp-man locks them, so it will not be lit again this side of the pit top. Ifor’s jack is half full. Mine is nearly full. Tomos has bread and a bit of cheese in his tommy box and he holds it against his chest like it might be taken.

Behind us, where the road to the double parting was, there is a wall of stone and broken timber from the floor to where the roof used to be.

“Well,” Ifor says. He closes the watch. “There’s the dinner hour gone.”


The knocking starts inside an hour.

It is faint and it comes through the rail, which runs under the fall and out the other side, so the rail is the only thing that still goes anywhere. Three knocks. A wait. Three knocks.

Are you there.

Ifor takes his mandrel and kneels on the sleepers. He knocks three times on the rail, slow and hard, to say three of us. Then he gives it two soft taps with the side of the head, the way he finishes every signal he has ever made.

“Amen,” he says, for Tomos, who is watching his hands.

The rail is quiet. Then the answer comes.

Not through the rail. Behind us, down the heading, past the face, where the old dip goes off to the left behind its boards.

Three knocks. Two soft.

Ifor does not turn round. I do.

The dip is boarded across with two planks and chalked NO ROAD in the fireman’s hand. It was driven down into the Farewell Rock in ninety-nine, to prove whether there was any coal beneath the Nine Feet. There was not. I have seen it on the plan in the overman’s cabin: a line going down for two hundred yards and stopping, and under it nothing, just the grit, because the Nine Feet is the bottom of the valley and the Farewell Rock is what you reach when the coal is finished.

“The rock carries,” Ifor says. “Sound goes all ways down here. You know that.”

I do know that.


I spend the next hour proving it.

I take the mandrel from him and knock on the rail myself. Four, and then one, the number of my mother’s house in Bute Street. It is not a signal. Nobody on the other side of the fall would know what to make of it.

The dip answers. Four, and then one.

“There,” Ifor says. “Your own echo.”

But an echo comes back while the sound is still in your arm. This waits. It waits about as long as it takes a man to hear something, and think, and lift his hand.

I say this. Ifor wipes his lamp glass with his thumb.

“My taid used to say the coblynau knock where there’s coal,” he says. “To show you where to cut.”

“There’s no coal down there.”

“No.” He looks at the boards, and then at me, and he smiles because Tomos is listening. “Then they’re knocking for something else, aren’t they.”

Tomos laughs, a high laugh with nothing under it. Ifor puts a hand on his neck and keeps it there.


The rescue knocks again at what Ifor’s watch says is half past two. Three, a wait, three. And then a longer run that we have to count with our lips: they are asking how many.

I take the mandrel. I kneel. I knock three.

Before the rail has stopped ringing, the dip answers them.

Four.

Nobody says anything. Captain shifts his feet on the sleepers. The flame in my lamp is steady and small inside its gauze, and I watch it rather than look at either of them.

“It’s wrong,” Tomos says. “There’s three of us. You said there was three.”

“There’s three,” I say.

Ifor is looking at the dip.

“It’s counting somebody,” he says quietly.

I tell him to stop that, and he does not argue, which is worse. He goes over to the boards and holds his face near the gap between the planks, and when he comes back there is a look on him I have seen on men at the pit top when they are told there is a card for them in the office.

“There’s air moving,” he says. “Down there. Feel it.”

I go and feel it. He is right. There is a thread of cold against my cheek, and when I hold my lamp to the gap the flame leans, very slightly, toward the dark.

Air that moves goes somewhere. Every haulier knows that. It is how you find your way in smoke.

“It goes through,” Ifor says. “It must connect. The old Graig workings, maybe, or a fault. There’s a way out down there, Dafydd, and whatever’s knocking has found it.”

“Blackdamp lies low,” I say. “You know it does. You go down a dip into still ground and it’ll be waiting for you at the bottom like water.”

“It’s not still. You felt it.”

“You don’t know what’s down there.”

“I know what’s up here.” He nods at the fall. “They’ll be three days through that. Four. You’ve looked at the jacks same as I have.”

I have. A pint and a half between us, and a horse that has already found the puddle under the face and is drinking it.


We argue until the watch says six. We do it low, for Tomos, which means we do it with our teeth.

In the end he does not wait for me to agree. He never did, not in six months of me bringing his drams. He wraps his bread in his handkerchief and gives it to Tomos. He takes his lamp.

“I’ll knock,” he says. “When I’m through. You’ll know it’s me.”

“Ifor.”

“Three and amen.” He is already stooping at the boards. “Keep the boy by the rail, where they can hear you.”

He pulls the bottom plank away and goes through on his knees, and his light goes down the dip, bobbing, getting smaller, the way a lamp goes down a road at night. The chalk NO ROAD hangs above the gap on the top plank, which he has left.

For a while I can hear him. Boots on the grit, and his breathing, and then, once, his voice coming up to us, pleased and a long way off.

“There’s a road here. Proper, timbered. Somebody’s worked it.”

Then nothing.

Then, from down the dip, three knocks, and two soft.

Tomos starts to cry. I put my hand on his neck the way Ifor did, and it does not help him, because it is not Ifor’s hand.


We have one lamp now. I turn it as low as it will go without dying.

The rescue knocks come every hour or so, and they are louder each time. That is what I hold on to. At first I have to press my ear to the rail. By what the watch calls midnight I can hear them sitting up. They are driving through. They are coming.

I ration by them. When a knock comes, Tomos gets a mouthful from the jack and so do I. When it is louder, I let him have the cheese. Captain gets nothing and I tell him I am sorry and he pushes his nose into my coat anyway.

I answer every time. Two knocks on the rail. Two of us. No amen.

I do not listen for the dip. I make myself not listen.


The lamp goes out a little after three in the morning. It does not flicker. The flame gets shorter and shorter, sinking into the wick like something drawing its head in, and then there is no flame, and then there is a red point, and then there is nothing.

It is not the oil. There is oil in it. It is the air.

I have never known dark like it. There is no less dark and more dark. My eyes make lights of their own, green and brown, and I close them because it is easier to have the dark be my own.

The knocks come again. So loud now. So near.

Tomos is lying with his ear to the rail. I hear him shift, and then I hear him go still.

“Dafydd,” he whispers. “They’re not on the rail.”

“They are.”

“They’re not. Listen.”

I lie down beside him and put my ear to the cold iron. Nothing. The rail is as quiet as a dead thing.

The knocks come again. Three. Two soft.

I feel them in my hip, in my palm flat on the floor. In the ground. Under us.

I try to remember the last time the knocking came through the rail. I go back through it in the dark, knock by knock, the way you go back through a shift to find where you lost a sprag. The mouthfuls from the jack. The cheese. And before that, before all of it, the last time I heard the rescue on the far side of the fall and knew it for the rescue.

It was before Ifor went down.

Every knock since has been in the floor. Every knock I rationed by. Every knock I thanked God for, getting louder, getting nearer, coming up. And the thread of air at the boards, leaning toward the dark, was never air coming up to us from a way out.

It was going down. The dip was drawing its breath.


Something knocks on the boards.

Not the rail. Not the floor. The plank Ifor left, the one with NO ROAD on it, eight yards from where we lie. I know the sound of wood.

Three knocks.

Are you there.

Tomos’s hand finds the mandrel before mine does. He is thirteen and he has been in the dark for sixteen hours and somebody is asking if he is there. I catch his wrist.

“Don’t,” I whisper.

“They’re asking.”

“I know.”

“If we don’t answer they’ll think there’s nobody.”

He is right, and that is the whole of it. If the rescue is still out there beyond the fall, they have gone quiet for a reason I know and forgot: the fireman calls for silence, and every man stops his pick and holds his breath and listens for the ones inside. If I say nothing, they hear nothing, and a party that hears nothing stops driving, and seals the district, and goes home to tell the mothers.

And if I answer, I answer everything.

Three knocks on the boards again. Patient. It can wait. It has waited since the coal ran out.

I take the mandrel out of Tomos’s hand. I pull him up by his coat and I find Captain’s bridle, and I walk us, all three, back along the rail in the dark with my free hand on the side, counting the props by touch, until my fingers meet the loose, sharp stone of the fall.

I put my mouth near it. It smells of powder and wet timber. I knock on the stone itself, not the rail, not the floor. Three, slow, to ask. Then two.

Two of us.

I do not add anything. I let the silence after the second knock sit there, plain, with nothing soft at the end of it.

From behind us, from the boards, the answer comes at once.

Two. And two soft.

Then nothing, for a long time. I stand with my forehead against the fall and Tomos’s coat in my fist and Captain’s breath on my neck, and I wait to find out which of them heard.

A stone shifts, somewhere high on the far side. Then a scrape. Then a voice, muffled, in Welsh, saying hush, hush, there, there, and a crack of light no wider than a straw.


They bring us out at nine. The fireman who led the party is a big man from Ton with a cut across his nose, and at the pit top, in the snow, with a blanket over me and a can of hot tea I cannot hold, he squats down and tells me they nearly gave up.

“Midnight, we were going to call it,” he says. “No sound from you since the afternoon. We had the stoppings ready.”

“We were knocking.”

“Not through that fall you weren’t. Couldn’t hear a thing.” He shakes his head. “But then there was the other. All through the evening, regular as chapel. Three, and then two little ones after. Never got the number, but it never stopped. It was low down, see. Well down. So we thought, there’s a man under the stone, and we drove low for him.”

He grins at me.

“Which of you was it, doing the amen?”


I go back down in March, because the house in Bute Street is the Company’s and a haulier who will not go down is a haulier with no house. They put me back in the Nine Feet. There is no other work in it.

In April, when the fan has cleared the air, a party goes down the dip for Ifor. He is at the bottom of it, a hundred and ninety yards down, sitting against the end wall with his lamp in his lap, still locked. There is no road there. There never was. The heading stops at clean grit, the way it does on the plan.

His mandrel is beside him. The head of it is worn bright.

At the end of a shift, when the journey is made up, you knock on the rail to tell the engine house. Three knocks, and the rope goes tight.

Most days that is all.

Some days the rail gives two soft taps back, from somewhere under our feet, and the older men say amen without looking up.

So do I.