Subtraction

By Strange Light Psychological horror 10 min

Psychological horror Sci-fi horror

Before you go in
  • Alcoholism, implied
  • Family grief and estrangement
  • A childhood injury, remembered

I made two cups of coffee on the morning my brother stopped existing, because on Thursdays I always made two.

Kasim came up from the low decks every Thursday before his shift. He had done it for six years, since our father’s first bad winter, and he never knocked, because he had a key. He would take the second cup off the counter without asking, stand at my window looking antispinward along the long curve of the Ring as it climbed into the haze, and tell me he was fine. Sometimes he asked for money. Sometimes I gave it to him. He always drank the coffee.

At twenty to eight the second cup was still on the counter, going cold. His key was not on the hook by my door, where he always hung it. There was no hook. There were no screw holes where a hook had been.

I called him through the lace. It gave me the soft chime and the flat voice it uses for mistakes. No contact by that name.

I said his whole name, Kasim Haddad, slowly, the way you speak to an old machine.

No contact by that name.


I opened the hearthlog next, standing at the counter with my own coffee going cold as well. Every family on the Ring keeps one. The lace records whatever you choose to share, and the log keeps it forever: birthdays, first steps, my mother’s terrible singing at the Turning festival. I had been in it all my life. So had he.

Our family was three people.

I went to my fifteenth birthday, because I remembered it best. We had eaten at the noodle bar on Meridian, and Kasim had paid, and it was the only time I could remember him having money. In the log there was the noodle bar, and the paper lanterns, and my mother and my father and me at a table for three. The picture was not wrong. That was what frightened me. There was no gap where he had been, no chair pushed back, no arm at a strange angle round nothing. It was composed for three. It had always been composed for three.

I called my mother.

She answered on the second chime, bright, in her kitchen. Behind her my father sat at the table with a cup of tea and the news feed, and the light from the window lay across his hands.

“Nadia, love. You’re up early.”

“Mum. Have you heard from Kasim?”

She waited, smiling, for the rest of the sentence.

“Kasim,” I said. “Mum.”

“I don’t think I know a Kasim, sweetheart. Is he from your work?”

I looked at her hands. She was holding her cup in both of them, the way she always did, and it was not shaking. I had not seen my mother hold a cup still since I was nineteen.


The clinic on Deck Four fitted me in the same afternoon, which should have told me something.

There were four other people in the waiting room. A man in a transit jacket kept turning a ring on his finger, round and round, and every so often he took it off and looked inside the band and put it back. Nobody spoke. The screen on the wall played a loop of the gardens on Deck Nine.

The technician was young and kind and did not seem at all surprised. She ran my lace through a diagnostic that felt like cold water behind the eyes, then turned her screen so that I could see a map of my own memory, lit up in blue.

“Here.” She pointed to a dense bright knot near the centre. “See how busy that is? That’s structure the lace has built out of spare capacity. It happens. It’s called phantom kin.” She said it the way you would say migraine. “The lace likes to file things. Sometimes it builds a person to file them under.”

“He’s not a filing error. He’s my brother.”

“I know it feels like that.” She gave me a leaflet with a soft green cover and a photograph of a woman looking out of a window, relieved. “Have a read of the second page. It’s more common than people think. About one in three hundred. There’s a recalibration. It resolves ninety-four per cent of cases.”

I read the second page on the tram. Phantom kin are usually experienced as a sibling or partner. They are frequently remembered as a source of difficulty within the family, someone who needed help or caused worry. Sufferers may also attach them to physical evidence, such as scars or damage, whose actual origins have been forgotten.

I put the leaflet in my bag and took my left hand out of my pocket and looked at the scar across the palm.

I was nine. There is a maintenance gap by the viewing rail on Deck Twelve, where the floor of the Ring gives way to a grille and the long drop of the spoke, and I had climbed through to watch the stars go round. Kasim pulled me back by my collar. My hand caught on the grille. There was a great deal of blood, and he carried me to the clinic on his back, crying louder than I was.

That evening I called my mother and asked her, carefully, how I had got it.

“You slipped on the viewing rail,” she said. “All on your own, the little monkey. Your father carried you all the way to the clinic.”

My father nodded from the table. “Screamed the whole way,” he said fondly. “Right in my ear.”


The next day I took the Loop down to the low decks, to the block on Carrow Spur where Kasim had lived for four years.

I knew the way without thinking. Down the stairs where the handrail was loose, past the noodle cart that was never open, along the gallery where the spin makes you feel slightly too heavy and the ceiling pipes drip. His door was the third from the end. It had a sticker on it, half peeled, of a cartoon moon, which he had put there to annoy the landlord.

The sticker was there. I put my fingers on it. Then I knocked.

A woman opened the door with a baby on her hip. Behind her I could see a clean room, a cot, a line of washing strung across where his sofa had been. She looked at me politely, the way you look at someone who has the wrong address.

“Sorry,” I said. “I was looking for Kasim Haddad.”

“No one here by that name, love. We’ve been here since before she was born.” She jiggled the baby. “Before we met, nearly.”

“The sticker,” I said.

She glanced at it. “That was here when we came. I keep meaning to scrape it off.” She smiled. “She likes it, though.”

The baby was looking at me with great seriousness. I said thank you and went back along the gallery, and on the stairs I put my hand on the handrail and it was loose, exactly as loose as it had always been, and I stood there holding it until someone came up behind me and I had to move.


That evening I went round to my parents’ flat, for the first time since it had happened, and stood in the doorway of the study.

It had been Kasim’s room. Now it was a study, with my father’s books and a reading chair and a plant, and it looked as though it had always been a study. But low on the door, at the height of a sixteen-year-old’s foot, there was a crescent-shaped dent in the panel where the paint had cracked.

“How did that happen?” I asked.

My mother looked at it as though she had never seen it before. “I don’t know,” she said. “It’s always been there.” She frowned at it a moment longer than she needed to. Then she smiled, and went to put the kettle on.


I saw him at Meridian Halt on the way home.

Not Kasim. The platform was full, the evening crowd packed along the edge waiting for the spinward Loop, and there was a tall figure standing still against the flow of it, near the stairs. He wore a long coat and a hood pulled so far forward that I could not see any face beneath it. People stepped round him without looking, the way they step round a pillar.

I was nearly past him when he said, “Kasim.”

I stopped so suddenly that someone walked into my back.

“Kasim Haddad,” he said. He did not seem to be saying it to me, exactly. He said it the way you might read a name off a list to make sure it was still there.

“You know him.”

“I know his name.”

“Where is he?”

“Nowhere a tram goes.”

“Is he dead?”

The hood tilted, very slightly. “The dead leave more than this.”

“Then what happened to him? Everyone’s forgotten. My mother. My father. The log.” My voice was climbing and I could not bring it down. “I’m the only one.”

“Yes,” he said. “You’re carrying him.”

The Loop came in behind me with its long rising hum, and the crowd surged, and I was pushed half a step toward the doors.

“Mind who you hand him to,” he said.

When I got my footing back there was nobody by the stairs.


I did not book the recalibration. What I did, that Sunday, was go to dinner at my parents’ and tell them about my brother.

I told it carefully, the way you tell someone a story about a person they have never met. The noodle bar. The Thursdays. How he had carried me with my hand bleeding down his collar. How he laughed with his whole face and could not keep a job or keep money, and how he had once walked all night round the Ring the wrong way to prove to me that it came back to the same place.

My mother listened the way she listens to other people’s holiday stories. My father said nothing at all.

Halfway through pudding he got up and went to the cabinet. There was a bottle of arak in there that someone had given them years ago, for guests. I had never seen it opened in this life. He poured a glass and stood by the cabinet with it, and did not drink it, and did not put it down.

“Dad.”

“Hm.” He was looking at the glass. “I don’t know why I did that.”

My mother was looking at her hands.

They had started. Very slightly. A tremor you would only see if you had spent twelve years watching for it: the fingertips first, then the cup against its saucer, a faint small ringing like something a long way off.


I understood it then, sitting at that table with the pudding going soft between us, and I have not been able to stop understanding it since.

They were fine because he was gone. My mother’s steady hands, my father’s tea, their bright flat with its spinward view, my own clean kitchen and the savings I had never lent out: all of it was what our lives looked like with him taken out of them. And he was not quite gone. He was in me, and I had just lifted him out and passed him round the table like a dish.

What I could not tell, and still cannot, is what was coming back. Whether my father reached for the bottle because of the son who had kept him up nights for twenty years, or because of a son he could no longer remember and had somehow lost all the same. Whether my mother’s hands shook with the old worry, or with grief that had nowhere to go. The leaflet had an answer. The man at the station had not given me one.

“Tell me about him,” my mother said.

Her voice was very small. Her hands were in her lap now, holding each other.

“Tell me more. What was he like?” She was frightened, and hungry, and did not know why she was either. “Nadia. Please. What did he like to eat?”

I looked at my father, still standing at the cabinet with the glass he had not drunk.

“I made him up, Mum,” I said. “It’s a lace thing. The clinic explained it. It’s very common.”

She looked at me for a long moment. Then she nodded, and let out a breath, and after a while her hands were still. My father tipped the arak back into the bottle, slowly, spilling some, and put it away.


I keep him now. That is the arrangement. On Thursdays I still make two cups, and I drink mine at the window, and let his go cold, and say his whole name once, quietly, to nobody. Then I wash both cups and put them away and do not say it again all week.

My mother called this morning. It was Thursday. She was laughing at herself in the kitchen, her cup in both hands, and the cup was perfectly still.

“The silliest thing,” she said. “I made two cups this morning. Your father was already at the table with his. I don’t know who I thought was coming.”

“That is silly, Mum,” I said.

“Isn’t it,” she said, and neither of us said anything else, and after a moment I watched her pour the second one away.